Skip to main content
. 2020 Oct 23;52(12):590–601. doi: 10.1152/physiolgenomics.00084.2020

Table 6.

Detailed comparison of the proposed method with the-state-of-art methods

Model Overall Accuracy for Task 1 Overall Accuracy for Task 2 Classification Type Number of Cases Data Sets Used Type of Images
Togacar et al. (29) 99.27% • Normal, Pneumonia and COVID-19 295 COVID-19(+)
458 Pneumonia
65 Normal
COVID-19 image data collection (8) Chest X-ray images
Lin et al. (19) 96% • Normal, Pneumonia and COVID-19 1296 COVID-19(+)
1735 Pneumonia
1325 Normal
6 different hospitals (19) Chest CT images
Ozturk et al. (22) 98.08% 87.02% • Healthy, Not healthy
• Normal, Pneumonia and COVID-19
127 COVID-19(+)
500 pneumonia
500 normal
COVID-19 image data collection (8) and
ChestX-ray8 (35)
Chest X-ray images
Loey et al. (20) 99.9% 85.2% • Healthy, Not healthy
• Normal, Pneumonia and COVID-19
307 COVID-19(+)
307 Pneumonia
307 Normal
COVID-19 image data collection (8) and Data set by Kermany et al. (18) Chest X-ray images
Apostolopoulos et al. (4) 96.78% • Normal, Pneumonia and COVID-19 224 COVID-19(+)
714 Pneumonia
504 Normal
COVID-19 image data collection (8) and COVID-19 X-rays (8a) Chest X-ray images
Hemdan et al. (15) 90% • Normal, Pneumonia and COVID-19 25 COVID-19(+)
25 Normal
COVID-19 image data collection (8) Chest X-ray images
Wang and Wong (32) 92.4% • Normal, Pneumonia and COVID-19 53 Covıd-19(+)
5526 Covid-19(−)
8066 Healthy
COVID-19 image data collection (8), COVID-19 Chest X-ray Data set initiative (34), RSNA Pneumonia Detection Challenge (22a), Actualmed COVID-19 Chest X-ray Data set Initiative (33) and (23) Chest X-ray images
Proposed Method 98.92% 98.27% Healthy, Not healthy
Normal, Pneumonia and COVID-19
1524 COVID-19(+)
1524 Normal
1527 Pneumonia
COVID-19 image Data Collection (8), Chest X-Ray images (21), ChestX-ray8 (23), COVID-19 Radiography Database (35), Data set by Kermany et al. (18) and COVID-19 X-rays (8a) Chest X-ray images