Skip to main content
. 2020 Dec 21;8(12):e23082. doi: 10.2196/23082

Table 5.

Performance analysis of model-based reasoning methods for each syndrome pattern in the test data set with corpus 1 and corpus 2.a

Syndrome pattern Corpus 1 Corpus 2
Precision Recall F1 score Support Precision Recall F1 score Support
Qi-deficiency of lung and spleen 0.9363 0.9514 0.9438 247 0.9957 0.9665 0.9809 239
Qi-deficiency of lung and kidney 0.9362 0.9999 0.9670 176 0.9781 0.9944 0.9861 179
Yin-deficiency of lung 0.9777 0.9733 0.9755 225 0.9902 0.9999 0.9951 203
Wind-cold attacking lung 0.9943 0.9943 0.9956 176 0.9878 0.9999 0.9939 162
Wind-heat attacking lung 0.9899 0.9120 0.9494 216 0.9150 0.9826 0.9476 230
Cold wheezing 0.9724 0.9832 0.9778 179 0.9750 0.9653 0.9701 202
Deficiency of qi and yin 0.9934 0.9804 0.9868 153 0.9932 0.9932 0.9945 147
Hot wheezing 0.9051 0.9931 0.947 144 0.9563 0.9808 0.9684 156
Phlegm-heat obstruction in lung 0.9389 0.9021 0.9201 613 0.9357 0.9125 0.9240 606
Phlegm obstruction in lung 0.9183 0.9344 0.9263 686 0.9461 0.9407 0.9434 691
Average (weighted) 0.9477 0.9471 0.9470 2815 0.9586 0.9584 0.9584 2815

aCorpus 1 consists of syndrome and sign information, and corpus 2 consists of syndrome and sign information plus clinical diagnosis information. The average accuracy was 0.9471 (95% CI 0.9382-0.9549) for syndrome pattern in the test data set with corpus 1, and 0.9584 (95% CI 0.9510-0.9655) for syndrome pattern in the test data set with corpus 2.