Skip to main content
. 2020 May 20;15(1):1764830. doi: 10.1080/17482631.2020.1764830

Table III.

An overview of included papers of patients’ treatment experiences.

References Aim/research question Recruitment methods Setting Diagnostic criteria Research design and analysis Intervention Sample characteristics Findings expressed in the authors’ themes
Broughton et al., 2017 UK To explore experiences of patients who were completing a treatment at specialist clinics Convenience sampling Specialist clinics Diagnosed- criteria not reported Semi-structured, individual interviews Thematic analysis Comprehensive treatment including CBT and GET 14 women. 2 men Age 24 to 62 yrs Illness duration 1 to 17 yrs Journey to specialist care, Things that hinder treatment Support systems
Cheshire et al., 2020 UK What are the differences and similarities in treatment perceptions and experiences of guided graded exercise among those reporting improvements compared with those deteriorated? Strategic sampling according to responses to questionnaires showing much improvements/much deterioration Specialist clinic Diagnosed—criteria not reported Semi-structured, individual interviews Thematic analysis Guided graded exercise self-help (GES) 17 women, 3 men Age 21 to 66 yrs Getting started and false starts Indeterminate phase of GES Competing commitments Interfering symptoms and comorbid conditions Maintaining motivation
Chew-Graham et al., 2011 UK What factors are important for patients to engage in a new intervention? Purposive sampling from an RCT trial Primary health care Diagnosed by Oxford criteria Semi-structured individual interviews Inductive thematic analysis based on data from those in trial arm Nurse-led rehabilitation program 13 women, 6 men Age 23 to 61 yrs Illness duration 9 months to 16 yrs Feeling accepted by therapist Own acceptance of diagnosis Accept of (treatment) model
Dennison et al., 2010 UK To examine participants’ views and experiences of taking part in family-focused cognitive behavioural therapy All participants in an RCT around three years earlier were invited Outpatient clinic at a hospital Diagnosed—criteria not reported Semi-structured individual interviews Inductive thematic analysis Either cognitive behavioural therapy or psycho-education 16 out of 46 invited were interviewed 10 women, 6 men Age 16 to 24 yrs Pre-therapy ideas and expectations Therapy experiences Perspectives on effectiveness
McDermott et al., 2011 UK To explore hopes and expectations of patients newly referred to a ME/CFS centre All referred to the service last five months were invited Specialist clinic Diagnosed—criteria not reported Semi-structured individual interviews Constant comparative analysis Self-help advice to improve symptoms informed by Lifestyle Management Group Program 20 out of 56 invited were interviewed 17 women, 3 men Age 22 to 60 yrs Needing a diagnosis In search of guidance and support Engaging with complexity to understand the illness In search of hope for the future
Picariello et al., 2017 UK To explore the reasons for why some patients engage in treatment more than others, and to assess whether CBT meets patients’ needs Consecutively recruited if finished or in follow-up after treatment Specialist clinic Diagnosed—criteria not reported Semi-structured individual interviews Inductive thematic analysis Cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT) 13 out of 32 invited were interviewed 11 women, 2 men Age 18 to 64 yrs Hopes and expectations Real, not imagined Collaborative therapeutic alliance Motivation and engagement Gain and loss Change
Pinxsterhuis et al., 2015 Norway To elicit participants’ experiences with a patient education programme and its usefulness All participants in a patient education, self-management programme were invited Outpatient clinic at a hospital Centres for Disease Control and Prevention—1994 criteria and Canadian Consensus Criteria Focus group interviews immediately and 9 months after the program Thematic analysis A self-management programme based on envelope and self-efficacy theories 10 out of 33 invited were interviewed 8 women, 2 men Age 32 to 57 yrs Illness duration 2.5 to 20 yrs Experiences of chaos and insecurity Experiences of understanding, acceptance and coping Mediating factors
Reme et al., 2013 US/UK To explore the experienes of young people after having undergone Lightening process Recruited through a website for young people with ME Members of website forum Oxford criteria Semi-structured individual interviews Inductive thematic analysis Lightening Process 8 females, 1 male Age 14 to 26 yrs Illness duration 2 to 12 yrs Pretreatment thoughts and expectations Experiences with treatment Perspectives on effectiveness