Skip to main content
. 2020 Oct 31;10(10):e034153. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2019-034153

Table 1.

Characteristics of studies included in the review of the intimate partner violence and breastfeeding outcomes

Reference Study design Country Setting Sample size Age Tool to measure IPV Outcome measures Quality
Madsen et al32 Cohort Tanzania Hospital 1128 20–30 Interview (from WHO multicountry study) Premature termination of exclusive BF Good
Martin-de-las-Heras et al33 Cohort Spain Antenatal care clinic 718 >20–40+ ISA BF avoidance (initiation) Fair
Miller-Graff et al20 Cohort USA Women, infant and children clinic 69 26.5 (mean) CTS BF exclusivity, initiation and cessation Fair
Tiwari et al21 Cross-sectional India Household 26 587 15–49 CTS-2 BF duration Good
Wallenborn et al22 Cross-sectional USA PRAMS (Pregnancy Risk Assessment Monitoring System) 195 264 <20–35+ Questionnaire BF initiation and duration Good
Boyce et al23 Cross-sectional India Household 10 469 20–29 Questionnaire Early BF initiation and exclusivity Good
Finnbogadottir and Thies-Lagergren24 Cross-sectional Sweden Project: ‘Pregnant women and new mother’s life experience’ 713 30 (mean) Norvold Abuse Questionnaire Exclusive BF Poor
Holland et al25 Cross-sectional USA PRAMS 760 20–29 Questionnaire (based on CDC’s monitoring system) BF initiation, duration and exclusivity Unsatisfactory
Hasselmann et al34 Cohort Brazil Primary health clinic 564 <20–20+ CTS-1 Interruption of exclusive BF Poor
Islam et al26 Cross-sectional India Community-based survey 426 14–25+ Questionnaire (based on WHO demographic health survey) Exclusive BF Good
Sørbø et al35 Cohort Norway The Norwegian Mother and Child Cohort Study 53 934 14–35+ Norvold Abuse Questionnaire Early cessation of any BF Fair
James et al27 Cross-sectional (embedded from an RCT) Australia Improving maternal and child health nurse care for vulnerable mothers 2621 15–35+ CAS BF duration Unsatisfactory
Moraes et al28 Cross-sectional Brazil Public health centre 811 <20–20+ CTS-2 Early cessation of exclusive BF Good
Shroff et al29 Cross-sectional (embedded from an RCT) India Household 600 (mother–infant pairs) 22.14 (mean) Questionnaire Exclusive BF Unsatisfactory
Lau and Chan30 Cross-sectional Hong Kong 1150 <25–20+ AAS, CTS BF and mixed feeding Good
Silverman et al31 Cross-sectional USA PRAMS 118 579 <20–30+ Questionnaire BF initiation and early cessation Satisfactory

AAS, abuse assessment screen; BF, breastfeeding; CAS, composite abuse scale; CDC, centers for disease control and prevention; CTS, conflict-tactic scale; IPV, intimate partner violence; ISA, index of spouse abuse; RCT, randomised controlled trial.