Table 4:
Reference | Study Design | Comparator | Response | Progression free survival | Toxicity |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Blanes et al26, Annals of hematology 2019 | Phase II multi-institution, Spain; 1:2 matched control analyses | BuMel* v Mel200 | No difference: BuMel v Mel200 ORR: 82 v 91% |
Median PFS: 33 v 24m (p=0.04) | TRM: 4% in BuMel v 2% in control No grade III/IV mucositis in BuMel |
Park et al, BBMT 2019 | Phase I/II multicenter trial, Korea | No comparator BuMelVel** |
At day 90: ≥VGPR: 75% CR: 55% |
Median PFS: 26.8m | Grade 3 mucositis: 14.6% |
Bashir et al, Lancet Haematol 2019 | Phase III single institution, MD Anderson Cancer Center | BuMel*** v Mel200 | No difference at day 100 BuMel v Mel: MRD negative: 58 v 61% CR: 52 v 49% |
Median PFS: BuMel 64.7m v Mel 43.5m (p=0.022) |
Grade 3–4 non-haematological: BuMel (84%) v Mel (33%) (p<0.0001) Grade 3 Mucositis: BuMel 14% v Mel 0% (p<0.0001) |
Jung et al, BBMT 2018 | Phase II multicenter, Korea | No comparator BuMel# |
ORR: 94% 43.5% sCR 27.3% VGPR |
Median PFS: 27.2m | Grade 3–4 mucositis 15.2% 3 patients (3.2%) developed SOS |
Byun et al27, Blood Research 2018 | Korean National Health Database, retrospective comparison | BuMel## v HDMel | Non-reported | Improved 3-year PFS in the BuMel group: 70.3 v 52.5% (P-0.043) | No differences (mucositis not specifically reported) |
Rosinol et al, ASH 2017 | Phase III national multicenter, Spain | BuMel### v Mel200 | Per high dose arm, pending | Per high dose arm, pending | Per high dose arm, pending |
Barta et al28, CLML 2017 | Phase II multi-institution, US | No comparator BuMelVel ŧ |
ORR 100% at day 100 | 2-year PFS 59% (95%CI 38–89%) | 53% grade 3 or 4 mucositis |
(Blanes et al): BuMel: intravenous Busulfan at 3.2mg/kg daily over days −5 to −3
(Park et al) BuMelVel: intravenous busulfan (i.v., 3.2 mg/kg/day from days −5 to −3); melphalan (i.v.,140 mg/m2/day on day −2), bortezomib i.v. 1.3mg/m2 on days −6, −3, and +1
(Bashir et al) BuMel: Busulfan test dose followed by pharmacokinetically adjusted doses of Busulfan on days −7, −6, −5, and −4 to achieve a target daily area under the curve (AUC) of 5000 mmol-minute and melphalan 70 mg/m2 per day on days −2 and −1; melphalan 70mg/m2 on days −2 and −1
(Jung et al) BuMel: intravenous busulfan of 3.2 mg/kg was administered over 3 hours once daily from day −6 to days −4; melphalan of 70 mg/m2/day was administered on day −3 and day −2
(Byun et al) BuMel: Dosing not reported
(Rosinol et al) BuMel: intravenous busulfan at 9.6mg/kg; melphalan 140mg/m2
(Barta et al) BuMelVel: intravenous PK directed Busulfan to achieve target total AUC of 20,000 from days −6 to −3; melphalan 150mg/m2 onf day −2; intravenous Bortezomib given at 1mg/m2 on days −6,−3,+1,+4
M: months
TRM: Transplant-related mortality
PFS: Progression free survival
HDMel: High dose melphalan, melphalan at 200mg/m2 or less
sCR: stringent complete response
VGPR: very good partial remission
SOS: sinusoidal obstructive syndrome