Table 1.
Clinical features of patients with coexistence of antibodies of MOG and anti-NMDAR.
Pérez, CA. 2020[9] | Zhou, L. 2017[10] | Aoe, S. 2019[12] | Zhou, J. 2018[13] | Sarigecili, E. 2019[14] | |
Age/sex | 29-year-old/male | 31-year-old/male | 36-year-old/female | 54-year-old/male | 6-year old/male |
Primary symptoms | Headache, fever, seizure, blurry vision, urinary retention, gait instability, and slurred speech in the 1st episode; bilateral painless blurry vision in the 2nd episode | Headache, seizure, fever, and headache in the 1st and the 2nd onset, respectively; right side anesthesia and continuous hiccup in the 3rd onset; blurred vision in the 4th onset | Headache, epilepsy, ataxia, depression, delusions, fever,somnolence, dyskinesia in the 1st onset; hallucinations, restlessness, tachycardia, hyperhidrosis, central apnea in the 2nd onset | Progressive dizziness, unsteadiness, narcoleptic attacks; light-headedness and intermittent spinning sensations | Alteration of gait, speech, behavior (agitation, aggression, irritability), and insomnia |
Location of lesions in MRI | Lesions in mesial temporal lobe in the 1st onset; lesions in the left thalamus, optic chiasm, optic nerve, and the optic tracts in the 2nd onset | Lesions in the right temporal, parietal, and occipital cortex | Lesions in the medial aspect of the bilateral frontal lobes in the 1st onset; lesions in the basal ganglia, temporal lobe, cerebellum in the 2nd onset | Multiple lesions involvingthe bilateral cerebellum, right cerebral peduncle, and the brain parenchyma surrounding the third ventricle | Brain and spinal MRI findings were normal |
Results of CSF | A mildly elevated level of protein, an elevated white blood cell count | Elevated leucocytes (80% mononuclear) and elevated protein | Protein level is unknown, mildly elevated leucocytes in the 1st and the 2nd onset | Normal opening pressure, with mild leukocytosis and elevated protein levels | No cells, normal protein and glucose levels |
Cancer | No | No mention | No | Unremarkable | No mention |
EEG | Unremarkable | Epileptic discharges exist | No mention | No abnormalities | Intermittent spike waves |
Antibody detection | CSF anti-NMDAR-Ab (1:16); serum MOG-Ab (1:1000) | Serum anti-MOG (1:320); CSF NMDAR-Ab (1:1); OB (–) | CSF NMDAR-Ab (+) in the 1st and the 2nd episode (1:20); serum MOG-Ab (+) in the two episodes; OB (+) | CSF NMDAR-Ab (1:32); serum MOG-IgG (1:320);IgG index was 0.62; OB (–). | CSF anti-NMDAR-Ab and serum anti-MOG-Ab (1:320) all (+); OB (+); an elevated IgG index |
Immunotherapy | Oral corticosteroids were initially used, and then1 course of IVMP (1 g/d × 5 days) in the 1st onset; a 5-day course of PE in the 2nd episode | IV DSM (10 mg/d) in the 1st onset; MP (80 mg/d × 2 weeks) in the 2nd onset. | 3 courses of IVMP (1 course: 1 g/d × 3 days) and 1 course (0.4 g/kg × 5 days) of IVIg in the 1st onset; 2 courses of MP and PE, 1 course of IVIg in the 2nd onset. | IVMP (0.5 g/d × 3 days), and IVIG (0.4 g/kg/d × 5 days), followed by IV rituximab (0.6 g/week × 3 weeks). | MP (30 mg/kg × 3 days), followed by (20 mg/kg × 2 days). |
Treatmentoutcomes | The symptoms improved after IVMP in the 1st onset. Neurological exam was normal at follow-up in the 2nd onset | The symptoms relieved after IV DSM in the 1st onset. His symptoms relieved in the 2nd episode | On the 81st day, she was discharged without sequelae in the 1st onset; relief of most symptoms in the 2nd onset | A mild gait disturbance at discharge. Resolution of most lesions at 2 months after discharge and symptomatic relief | Consciousness resumed on the 3rd day of the treatment. The patient was discharged with full recovery |
Actual diagnosis and the reasons | Overlapping MOG-AD and anti-NMDARe existed in the 1st onset, MOG-AD existed in the 2nd onset.Reasons: Simultaneously meeting the diagnostic criteria of anti-NMDARe and MOG-AD, and involvement of opticnerves in the 1st onset | Anti-NMDARe existed in the 1st to the 3rd onset; MOG-AD existed in the 4th onset.Reasons: Coexistence of encephalopathy and no MOG-Ab in the 1st to the 3rd onset; optic neuritis; and good response to immunotherapy existed in the 4th onset | Anti-NMDARe existed in the 1st episode, and anti-NMDARe reappeared 3.5 years later.Reasons: She met the diagnostic criterion[6] of anti-NMDARe;she did not have a good response toimmunotherapy; vision was unaffected | The more likely diagnosis was anti-NMDARe.Reasons: Encephalopathy existed; the patient had a poor response to multiple rounds of immunotherapy; vision is unaffected | The more likely diagnosiswas MOG-AD involving the hemicerebrum.Reasons: Good responseto immunotherapy. It did not meet the diagnostic criterion[6] of typical anti-NMDARe |