Skip to main content
. 2020 Dec 4;11:573314. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2020.573314

Table 3.

Significant correlations between dimensions in normative studies of line-drawings and photographs.

AoA CA Fam IA I-var NA% NA(H) PNA Typ VC
AoA NR −0.91**p
−0.37**q
−0.13*s NR −0.25**q
−0.82***u
0.17*t
0.75**p
NR −0.72**r
−0.91**p
−0.26**p
0.34**x
CA NR 0.30*r
0.22**q
0.14**q NR NR −0.93**p NR NR NR
Fam −0.38**a
−0.64***b
NR −0.19**s
0.46**t
NR 0.35**q
0.89***u
−0.29**v
−0.71***u
NR 0.75**x
0.92**p
−0.21**q
−0.57**x
IA −0.30**c
−0.14**d
NR −0.15**e
0.44*k
NR 0.46**q
0.49**t
−0.17**s
−0.43**q
NR NR −0.19**r
I-var −0.24**d
−0.64**e
0.19**e
0.62*j
−0.17**h
−0.29**k
NR NR NR NR NR
NA% −0.16*f
−0.52**d
NR −0.57*l
0.52**m
0.20*l
0.49*c, n
0.20**a
0.32** d
−0.83***u
−0.96*r
NR 0.52**x
0.73**p
−0.11*r
−0.26***u
NA(H) −0.18***e
−0.57**g
NR −0.15*n
−0.39** m
−0.24**a
−0.55***n
−0.14*j
−0.28**k
−0.74**k
−0.96***n
NR −0.51**z
−0.66**p
NR
PNA −0.08*f
−0.14**b
NR −0.21**k 0.72**k −0.35**k 0.12*f −0.25***b NR NR
Typ NR NR NR NR NR NR NR NR −0.27**x
−0.26**p
VC −0.25*h
0.53***i
NR −0.12*o
−0.48**c
−0.14*k
−0.59**n
−0.17*h
−0.24* j
−0.15**h
−0.49***n
−015**c
0.54***n
−0.22***b NR

The correlations are significant at

*

p < 0.05;

**

p < 0.01;

***

p < 0.001. The signal (–) is reported for negative direction of the correlations.

The photographs (10) results are presented above the diagonal and line-drawings (28) results are presented below the diagonal of the table. Only the maximum and minimum correlational results for each correlation across studies are presented. AoA, Age-of-acquisition; CA, Category agreement; Fam, Familiarity; IA, Image Agreement; I-var, Image variability; NA%, Name agreement percentage; NA(H), Name agreement H-value; PNA, Picture name agreement; Typ, Typicality; VC, Visual complexity. NR, not reported across studies. Affective dimensions (i.e., arousal, aesthetic appeal, and valence) were not reported in this table, once there were no studies reporting such dimensions in line-drawings studies samples.

Line-drawing references:

a

Bonin et al., 2003;

b

Johnston et al., 2010;

c

Raman et al., 2014;

d

Alario and Ferrand, 1999;

e

Liu et al., 2011;

f

Morrison et al., 1997;

g

Nishimoto et al., 2005;

h

Manoiloff et al., 2010;

i

Sirois et al., 2006;

j

Nishimoto et al., 2012;

k

Sanfeliu and Fernandez, 1996;

l

George and Mathuranath, 2007;

m

Boukadi et al., 2016;

n

Tsaparina et al., 2011;

o

Khwaileh et al., 2018.

Photographs references:

p

Moreno-Martínez et al., 2011;

q

Clarke and Ludington, 2018;

r

Brodeur et al., 2010;

s

Shao and Stiegert, 2016;

t

Paolieri and Marful, 2018;

u

Adlington et al., 2009;

v

Zhou and Chen, 2017;

x

Moreno-Martínez and Montoro, 2012.