Table 2.
Study Characteristics | Effects a | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Duration (Weeks) | Number of Patients |
Exercise Capacity | IG: Within-Group | CG: Within-Group |
∆ IG vs. ∆ CG: Between-Group | |
mTechs during home-based CR vs. outpatient CR (n = 297) | ||||||
Avila et al. [13] b | 6 w | n = 90 | ⩒O2peak | - | - | - |
Kraal et al. [20] | 6 w | n = 45 | ⩒O2peak | ↑ | ↑ | - |
Maddison et al. [21] | 6 w | n = 162 | ⩒O2peak | ⊗ | ⊗ | ⊙ |
Outpatient CR with mTechs vs. outpatient without mTechs (n = 102) | ||||||
Rosario et al. [31] | 6 w | n = 66 | 6MWT | - | - | - |
Vogel et al. [32] c | 12 w | n = 36 | Peak W | ↑ | ↑ | - |
Outpatient CR followed by home-based CR with mTechs vs. outpatient CR without further formal CR (n = 1659) | ||||||
Avila et al. [13] d | 12 w | n = 90 | ⩒O2peak | - | - | ↑ |
Duscha et al. [14] | 12 w | n = 32 | ⩒O2peak | ↑ | ↓ | ↑ |
Fang et al. [33] | 6 w | n = 80 | 6MWT | ↑ | ↑ | ↑ |
Frederix et al. [15] | 18 w | n = 80 | ⩒O2peak | ↑ | - | ↑ |
Frederix et al. [16] e | 24 w | n = 140 | ⩒O2peak | ↑ | - | ↑ |
Piotrowicz et al. [12] f | 8 w | n = 111 | ⩒O2peak | ↑ | - | ↑ |
Piotrowicz et al. [30] f | 9 w | n = 850 | ⩒O2peak | ↑ | ↑ | ↑ |
Skobel et al. [17] | 24 w | n = 118 | ⩒O2peak | - | - | ↑ |
Snoek et al. [19] | 14 w | n = 122 | ⩒O2peak | ↑ | ↑ | - |
Vogel et al. [32] g | 12 w | n = 36 | Peak W | ↑ | ↓ | ↑ |
↑: statistically significant improvement; ↓: statistically significant deterioration; -: no statistically significant difference; ⊗: no within-group statistical comparison reported, but similar improvements observed in both groups descriptively; ⊙: statistically non-inferior. a Effects are related to changes in exercise capacity directly after intervention compared to baseline. b IG: home-based CR, CG: outpatient CR. c First 6 weeks of study period: both IG and CG underwent an outpatient CR. d IG: home-based CR, CG: no formal CR. e First 6 weeks of study period (18 weeks) in outpatient CR for both IG and CG. f Effects for both ⩒O2peak and 6MWT. g Last 6 weeks of study period: home-based continuation vs. no formal CR.