Skip to main content
. 2021 Jan 11;21:29. doi: 10.1186/s12888-020-03021-0

Table 1.

Characteristics of included studies

Study Intervention(n) Diagnosis Type of Anxiety Age, Range
(Mean)
TreatmentDuration Treatment
Sessions
Anxiety Scales Primary Efficacy
Outcomes
RSG AC BPP BOA IOD SR OB

Cartwright-Hatton

2011 [18]

parent only CBT(38)

vs. WL(36)

ADIS-IV PD&SAD &SPP&SOP 2.7–9(6.6±2) 10 w 10 Sessions MASC-C 0.39 vs.-3.26 + + + + ?

Cobham

2017 [13]

parent only CBT(33)

vs. WL(30)

ADIS-IV GAD&SAD&SPP&SOP 7–14(9.3±2) 6 w 6 Sessions SCAS-C −10.5.vs.2.8 + ? + + +
Mendlowitz 1999 [27]

parent only CBT(21)

vs. CBT + parent(18)

DSM-IV Mixed anxiety disorders 7–12(9.8±x) 12w 12 Sessions RCMAS-37 −4 vs. 0 ? ? + + +
Monga 2015 [28]

parent only CBT(32)

vs. CBT + parent(45)

ADIS-IV Mixed anxiety disorders 5–7(6.8±0.8) 11w 11 Sessions SCARED-P −5.73vs.-4.42 ? ? + + + +
Özyurt 2016 [29]

CBT parent only(37)

vs. WL(37)

K-SADS-PL GAD&SAD&SPP&SOP 8–12(9.7±1.45) 8 w 8 Sessions SCARED-C-41 −12.42 vs.-1.31 + ? ? +
Waters 2009 [17]

parent only CBT(38)

vs. CBT + parent(31)vs. WL(11)

ADIS-IV GAD&SAD&SPP&SOP 4–8(6.8±1.19) 10w 10 Sessions CSR −4.27 vs.-3.68vs.-0.60 ? ? + + + + +

Abbreviations: AC allocation concealment, ADIS Anxiety Disorders Interview Schedule for DSM-4, BOA blinding of outcome assessment, BPP blinding of participants and personnel, CBT cognitive-behavioral therapy, CSR Clinician severity ratings, DSM Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, IOD incomplete outcome data, MASC Multidimensional Anxiety Scale for Children, OB other bias, RCMAS Revised Children’s Manifest Anxiety Scale, RSG random sequence generation, SADS Schedule for Affective Disorders and Schizophrenia, SCARED Screen for Anxiety and Related Disorders, SCAS Spence Children’s Anxiety Scale, SR selective reporting, WL waitlist

Symbol: -:high risk of bias, +:low risk of bias,?:unclear risk of bias, x:not stated