TABLE 1.
Bias (%) [95% CI] | RMSE (mg/L) [95% CI] | Bias (%) [95% CI] | RMSE (mg/L) [95% CI] | |
All patients—a priori predictions (159 observations, 49 patients) | All patients—a posteriori predictions (110 observations, 43 patients) | |||
Adane et al1 | −20.0 [−30.1 to −9.97] | 5.49 [4.58 to 6.41] | −12.4 [−19.2 to −5.51] | 3.52 [2.89 to 4.15] |
Carreno et al2 | −1.4 [−11.1 to 8.26] | 4.43 [3.48 to 5.38] | −7.54 [−13.9 to −1.22] | 3.27 [2.60 to 3.94] |
Colin et al5 | −7.0 [−16.1 to 2.13] | 4.34 [3.40 to 5.27] | 1.96 [−4.03 to 7.94] | 2.75 [2.21 to 3.29] |
Crass et al3 | 21.1 [7.29 to 34.8] | 5.93 [4.75 to 7.11] | −6.54 [−13.9 to 0.84] | 3.65 [2.87 to 4.43] |
Goti et al6 | 26.2 [12.2 to 40.2] | 6.12 [4.99 to 7.24] | 17.2 [6.71 to 27.6] | 4.45 [3.55 to 5.36] |
Smit et al4 | −41.9 [−49.9 to −33.8] | 7.16 [5.86 to 8.45] | −10.8 [−18.4 to −3.12] | 3.71 [2.82 to 4.60] |
Class I obese—a priori predictions (81 observations, 25 patients) | Class I obese—a posteriori predictions (56 observations, 21 patients) | |||
Adane et al1 | −28.4 [−41.8 to −14.9] | 5.97 [4.69 to 7.26] | −13.8 [−24.2 to −3.37] | 3.82 [2.73 to 4.92] |
Carreno et al2 | 1.81 [−12.5 to 16.1] | 4.29 [2.91 to 5.68] | −8.18 [−18.2 to 1.89] | 3.23 [2.26 to 4.21] |
Colin et al5 | −4.14 [−20.0 to 11.7] | 4.93 [3.42 to 6.44] | 4.56 [−5.27 to 14.4] | 2.96 [2.10 to 3.83] |
Crass et al3 | 19.2 [−4.76 to 43.1] | 6.73 [4.73 to 8.73] | −6.07 [−16.3 to 4.10] | 3.11 [2.13 to 4.09] |
Goti et al6 | 31.4 [8.09 to 54.8] | 6.77 [4.75 to 8.80] | 21.8 [3.88 to 39.8] | 5.14 [3.44 to 6.85] |
Smit et al4 | −39.7 [−53.1 to −26.2] | 7.30 [5.24 to 9.36] | −5.66 [−17.2 to 5.90] | 3.22 [1.93 to 4.51] |
Class II obese—a priori predictions (32 observations, 9 patients) | Class II obese—a posteriori predictions (23 observations, 9 patients) | |||
Adane et al1 | −15.1 [−34.8 to 4.73] | 4.16 [2.79 to 5.54] | −11.0 [−20.6 to −1.32] | 3.06 [1.90 to 4.22] |
Carreno et al2 | −6.40 [−23.8 to 11.0] | 3.36 [1.82 to 4.89] | −12.7 [−25.3 to −0.04] | 3.32 [2.11 to 4.52] |
Colin et al5 | −4.12 [−23.2 to 15.0] | 3.17 [1.64 to 4.71] | −0.36 [−16.9 to 16.1] | 2.44 [1.35 to 3.53] |
Crass et al3 | 29.7 [9.10 to 50.2] | 4.56 [2.50 to 6.63] | −12.1 [−27.1 to 2.86] | 3.48 [2.24 to 4.73] |
Goti et al6 | 34.4 [−1.07 to 69.9] | 6.44 [4.40 to 8.48] | 12.3 [−13.3 to 37.9] | 4.18 [2.82 to 5.54] |
Smit et al4 | −42.8 [−64.3 to −21.2] | 6.88 [2.92 to 10.8] | −12.0 [−28.4 to 4.49] | 3.64 [2.27 to 5.02] |
Class III obese—a priori predictions (46 observations, 15 patients) | Class III obese—a posteriori predictions (31 observations, 13 patients) | |||
Adane et al1 | −9.06 [−32.1 to 14.0] | 5.49 [3.35 to 7.64] | −11.0 [−27.6 to 5.52] | 3.34 [2.27 to 4.42] |
Carreno et al2 | −3.75 [−25.1 to 17.6] | 5.31 [3.21 to 7.41] | −2.97 [−15.6 to 9.65] | 3.30 [1.65 to 4.95] |
Colin et al5 | −13.5 [−26.1 to −0.83] | 4.04 [2.36 to 5.72] | −0.64 [−9.53 to 8.24] | 2.63 [1.53 to 3.73] |
Crass et al3 | 19.1 [−3.5 to 41.7] | 5.41 [3.60 to 7.21] | −3.43 [−21.5 to 14.6] | 4.63 [2.58 to 6.68] |
Goti et al6 | 12.5 [−6.5 to 31.4] | 5.49 [3.35 to 7.64] | 13.0 [−2.19 to 28.3] | 3.53 [2.51 to 4.56] |
Smit et al4 | −45.0 [−56.6 to −33.3] | 7.09 [5.20 to 8.98] | −18.2 [−33.8 to −2.53] | 4.54 [2.39 to 6.69] |
Models with the smallest absolute mean bias and lowest root mean square error of each group are indicated in bold.
CI, confidence interval.