Skip to main content
. 2021 Jan 13;16(1):e0245272. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0245272

Table 2. Historical MAPE per model—Metropolitan Region.

1st week 2nd week
Date Ensemble ARIMAX MLPR ELM TBATS GMDH ICD Ensemble ARIMAX MLPR ELM TBATS GMDH ICD
2020-05-20 2.34 4.79 2.37 6.64 1.38 4.21 5.59 14.70 15.45 4.19 7.36 22.24
2020-05-22 5.15 4.68 7.21 8.21 7.63 6.86 6.95 4.00 3.03 9.91 3.30 37.49
2020-05-24 4.94 1.86 0.96 2.60 2.27 19.32 25.09 5.65 5.56 2.46 10.07 85.79
2020-05-26 8.64 4.42 3.33 4.68 4.29 21.55 25.57 14.51 12.13 16.99 14.21 57.76
2020-05-28 7.22 2.70 4.00 2.54 3.35 19.94 24.28 11.09 12.48 10.92 12.47 62.65
2020-05-30 7.00 2.94 2.91 2.24 2.54 21.41 22.99 12.75 6.50 10.59 10.38 62.11
2020-06-01 8.06 6.91 6.98 5.83 5.21 12.52 24.63 18.97 23.78 15.78 14.95 40.01
2020-06-03 9.74 3.80 7.74 3.74 3.33 23.81 23.62 11.02 14.57 9.50 8.06 59.39
2020-06-05 7.26 6.85 3.65 2.79 3.80 17.71 12.41 11.43 9.10 3.01 4.15 29.63
2020-06-07 6.31 4.40 9.38 3.19 2.83 14.80 7.64 4.75 19.77 2.56 3.11 27.66
2020-06-09 1.87 1.19 3.08 1.19 1.84 7.75 1.75 2.94 1.68 6.97 10.85 16.39
2020-06-11 3.70 2.88 6.45 4.58 5.31 1.53 2.46 10.23 5.75 16.44 12.22 14.99 5.41 7.96
2020-06-13 6.60 4.97 8.12 5.33 7.07 4.40 5.88 10.02 5.36 13.78 7.88 12.87 7.24 5.65
2020-06-16 6.31 1.39 7.93 5.69 6.29 7.42 6.36 4.27 7.78 8.26 3.65 5.24 5.36 2.37
2020-06-18 0.94 2.66 1.99 1.42 2.92 1.55 2.02 2.68 13.38 10.09 6.55 14.31 2.61 7.82
2020-06-20 4.32 6.09 7.37 3.44 6.60 2.56 4.36 8.03 18.85 14.82 10.91 20.00 8.65 2.66
2020-06-22 2.43 5.23 3.85 3.56 4.73 1.47 2.54 5.55 18.36 14.94 12.19 14.54 6.46 13.91
2020-06-24 0.90 1.64 7.37 5.38 1.24 3.13 6.58 3.35 7.20 20.61 17.28 4.10 12.59 35.56
2020-06-26 3.18 2.23 3.28 4.66 1.17 3.77 10.29 7.23 10.52 2.99 17.21 1.63 12.91 41.43
2020-06-28 1.25 8.03 3.12 9.17 6.23 7.87 12.23 0.66 20.76 11.03 23.01 15.49 19.75 44.11
2020-06-30 2.34 6.14 2.71 5.83 1.03 4.75 19.30 3.49 19.42 5.20 19.37 4.39 13.76 49.93
2020-07-02 3.04 5.71 1.85 7.26 1.08 4.77 21.82 4.94 19.64 14.47 23.15 5.77 14.10 57.32
2020-07-03 1.58 3.96 3.04 8.26 3.18 5.70 21.35 3.07 13.49 17.54 25.09 10.95 16.14 56.06
2020-07-07 2.00 1.03 6.85 6.30 1.67 5.81 22.81 5.01 9.92 27.33 27.88 11.99 20.55 50.17
2020-07-10 3.05 2.99 4.66 7.71 3.55 10.20 24.43 1.44 12.19 21.93 29.64 13.59 25.77 53.79
2020-07-14 4.00 6.69 9.56 12.81 7.02 16.80 19.80 8.16 14.84 23.18 33.07 16.38 33.26 54.20
2020-07-17 2.69 6.02 1.77 4.62 1.31 12.37 23.20 4.72 12.84 5.84 17.07 1.50 25.17 53.88
2020-07-21 1.37 6.91 2.04 9.47 4.88 14.59 14.72 2.67 13.29 5.99 18.57 7.53 32.82 38.47
2020-07-24 2.50 3.70 3.07 7.89 4.59 10.97 7.46 3.73 4.27 4.07 10.01 2.72 25.32 23.36
2020-07-28 2.59 1.60 3.39 4.51 2.11 9.64 4.56 1.26 2.74 6.74 10.34 2.76 29.24 3.47
min 0.90 1.03 0.96 1.19 1.03 1.47 2.02 0.66 2.74 1.68 2.46 1.50 2.61 2.37
max 9.74 8.03 9.56 12.81 7.63 16.80 24.43 25.57 20.76 27.33 33.07 20.00 33.26 85.79
mean 4.11 4.15 4.67 5.38 3.68 6.80 13.40 9.03 11.41 12.31 13.93 9.32 16.69 36.77
std 2.52 2.01 2.54 2.65 2.04 4.54 7.75 8.28 5.45 6.95 8.34 5.23 9.73 22.24