. 2018 Aug 1;18(9):284–290. doi: 10.1016/j.bjae.2018.05.005

Table 3.

Comparison of original evidence used in published meta-analyses and BTF guidelines. 3rd Edn, 2007 BTF guidelines, third edition; 4th Edn, 2017 BTF guidelines, fourth edition.

Meta-analysis authors (Original research)	Kamel (2011)¹⁴	Mortazavi (2012)¹⁵	Rickard (2014)¹⁶	Li (2015)¹⁷	Berger-pelleiter (2016)¹⁸	BTF¹
Schwartz et al. (1984)²⁴						^∗3rd Edn
Fisher et al. (1992)²⁷		^∗
Shackford et al. (1998)²³					^∗^,^¶	^∗3rd Edn
Schwartz et al. (1998)²⁸	^∗	^∗
Qureshi et al. (1999)⁹						^∗3rd Edn
Afifi et al. (2003)²⁹	^∗
Vialet et al. (2003)¹⁹		^∗		^†	^∗^,^‡
Cooper et al. (2004)²⁰					^∗^,^‡
Battison et al. (2005)³⁰	^∗	^∗	^∗	^∗
Harutjunyan et al. (2005)³¹		^∗	^∗	^∗
Bentson et al. (2006)³²		^∗
Francony et al. (2008)³³	^∗	^∗	^∗	^∗	^∗^,^¶
Ichai et al. (2009)³⁴	^∗	^∗	^∗		^∗^,^¶	^∗4th Edn
Oddo et al. (2009)³⁵				^∗
Bulger et al. (2010)²¹					^∗^,^‡^,^¶
Bordreaux et al. (2011)³⁶					^∗^,^¶
Cottenceau et al. (2011)³⁷			^∗	^∗	^∗^,^¶	^∗4th Edn
Morrison et al. (2011)³⁸					^∗^,^‡
Sakellardis et al. (2011)³⁹			^∗	^∗	^∗
Scafani et al. (2012)⁴⁰					^∗
Mangat et al. (2014)⁴¹						^∗4th Edn

^∗

Study used as part of meta-analysis.

^†

Data not used for primary outcome analysis (osmolality data used only for secondary outcome analysis).

^‡

Mortality data extracted.

^¶