Skip to main content
. 2021 Jan 14;51(11):4054–4066. doi: 10.1007/s10803-020-04864-y

Table 4.

Summary of content validity evidence strength by level, domain, and category

Level Domain Domain relevance Age appropriateness Measurement appropriateness Domain representation
1 Mand Strong Strong Moderate Moderate
Tact Strong Strong Moderate Moderate
Listener responding Strong Strong Moderate Moderate
Visual perceptual skills & matching-to-sample Moderate Strong Moderate Limited
Independent play Moderate Moderate Limited Limited
Social behavior & social play Moderate Moderate Limited Moderate
Motor imitation Moderate Strong Strong Strong
Echoic Moderate Strong Strong Moderate
Spontaneous vocal behavior Moderate Strong Strong Moderate
2 Mand Strong Strong Moderate Moderate
Tact Strong Strong Strong Moderate
Listener Responding Moderate Moderate Moderate Limited
Visual perceptual skills & matching-to-sample Moderate Moderate Strong Strong
Independent play Strong Strong Moderate Moderate
Social behavior & social play Moderate Moderate Limited Limited
Motor imitation Strong Strong Strong Limited
Echoic Limited Strong Strong Moderate
Listener responding by function, feature, & class Moderate Moderate Strong Limited
Intraverbal Strong Strong Strong Moderate
Classroom routines & group skills Limited Limited Moderate Moderate
Linguistic structure Strong Strong Moderate Limited
3 Mand Strong Strong Moderate Strong
Tact Strong Strong Strong Moderate
Listener responding Moderate Strong Strong Strong
Visual perceptual skills & matching-to-sample Limited Limited Moderate Moderate
Independent play Strong Strong Strong Strong
Social behavior & social play Strong Strong Moderate Limited
Reading Moderate Moderate Strong Moderate
Writing Moderate Limited Strong Limited
Listener responding by function, feature, & class Strong Strong Strong Moderate
Intraverbal Moderate Strong Moderate Limited
Classroom routines & group skills Moderate Strong Strong Limited
Linguistic structure Moderate Strong Moderate Strong
Math Moderate Moderate Strong Moderate
N/A EESA Moderate Strong Moderate Strong
N/A Barriers Strong N/A Moderate Limited

Shading used to aid in readability. EESA = Early Echoic Skills Assessment. Limited Evidence = Fewer than half of SMEs rated the items at highest response category (e.g., Essential, Very Appropriate, Adequate), on average; Moderate Evidence = Between than 50% and 68.9% of SMEs rated the items at highest response category (e.g., Essential, Very Appropriate, Adequate), on average; Strong Evidence = 69% or more of SMEs rated the items at highest response category (e.g., Essential, Very Appropriate, Adequate), on average. Neither EESA nor Barriers Assessment were specific to any level from the VB-MAPP Milestones