Skip to main content
. 2020 Jul 13;65(1):1900942. doi: 10.1002/mnfr.201900942

Table 1.

Human intervention studies comparing the effect of SFA and PUFA on liver steatosis

Subjects Intervention Duration Body weight Liver fat Other observations Reference

39 healthy men and women

age: 20–38 y

BMI: 18–27 kg m2

Randomized control study; overfeeding (+750 kcal per day) SFA (palmitate, 16:0)) or PUFA (linoleate 18:2 n‐6)) muffins. (Muffins were added to the habitual diet). 7 weeks

SFA:

1.6 kg ↑

PUFA:

1.6 kg ↑

SFA ↑

PUFA ↔

SFA: larger increase in visceral adipose tissue compared with PUFA

PUFA: increase in lean tissue

[14]

60 healthy men and women

Age: 20–55y

BMI: 25–32 kg m2

Randomized control study; overfeeding (+700 kcal per day) SFA (palmitate, 16:0)) or PUFA (linoleate 18:2 n‐6)) muffins.

(Muffins were added to the habitual diet).

8 weeks

SFA:

2.3 kg ↑

PUFA:

2.6 kg ↑

SFA ↑

PUFA ↔

SFA: increased serum ceramides

PUFA: reduced serum ceramides.

No changes in markers of inflammation, oxidative stress or endothelial function.

[15]

67 men and women with and without T2D

Age: 30–65 y

BMI: ≈30 kg m2

Randomized control study; diet high in SFA (butter) or PUFA (linoleate; ≈6.7 E%) intake.

Modest increase in total energy intake (PUFA: +138 kcal per day; SFA: + 225 kcal per day).

10 weeks

SFA:

0.8 kg ↑

PUFA:

0.4 kg↑

SFA ↑

PUFA ↓

Modest increase in inflammatory markers after SFA compared with PUFA. No difference in oxidative stress markers between the diets. [16]

39 healthy men and women

age: 18–65 y

BMI: 27–35 kg m2

Randomized control study; overfeeding (+1000 kcal per day).

SFA or UFA (MUFA and PUFA).

3 weeks

SFA:

1.4 kg ↑

PUFA:

0.9 kg↑

SFA ↑↑

UFA ↑

Increase in insulin resistance (clamp) and circulating ceramides in SFA. [17]

Only studies are selected in which treatment groups within studies are similar in energy intake and macronutrient content. Abbreviations: y: year; BMI: body mass index; kg: kilogram; m: meter; kcal: kilocalories: SFA: saturated fatty acids; PUFA: poly‐unsaturated fatty acids.