Table 1.
Developmental time points | Mouse lung development DEG list | Gene count a | LUAD DEG list | Gene count | Observed gene intersectionb | Simulated gene intersection (min–max) | Empirical P-valuec | Observed > Simulated intersection?d |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
E11.5–12.5 vs E13.5-E15.5 | EMB vs PSG ↑ | 1335 |
Lowest LRRK2 vs Highest LRRK2 (↑) |
1302 | 88 | 32–102 | 0.0014 | No |
E11.5–12.5 vs E13.5-E15.5 | EMB vs PSG ↓ | 190 |
Lowest LRRK2 vs Highest LRRK2 (↓) |
2199 | 27 | 2–35 | 0.0018 | No |
E13.5-E15.5 vs E16.5-E17.5 | PSG vs CAN ↑ | 1021 | ↑ | 1302 | 40 | 23–87 | 0.91 | No |
E13.5-E15.5 vs E16.5-E17.5 | PSG vs CAN ↓ | 757 | ↓ | 2199 | 45 | 32–96 | 0.99 | No |
E16.5-E17.5 vs E18.5_E19.5 | CAN vs SAC ↑ | 853 | ↑ | 1302 | 31 | 18–70 | 0.95 | No |
E16.5-E17.5 vs E18.5_E19.5 | CAN vs SAC ↓ | 806 | ↓ | 2199 | 26 | 36–102 | 1.00 | No |
E18.5_E19.5 vs P0-P3 | SAC vs ALV1 ↑ | 855 | ↑ | 1302 | 45 | 17–70 | 0.25 | No |
E18.5_E19.5 vs P0-P3 | SAC vs ALV1 ↓ | 594 | ↓ | 2199 | 59 | 23–77 | 0.055 | No |
P0-P3 vs P4-P7 | ALV1 vs ALV2 ↑ | 473 | ↑ | 1302 | 208 | 6–46 | < 0.0001 | Yes |
P0-P3 vs P4-P7 | ALV1 vs ALV2 ↓ | 692 | ↓ | 2199 | 252 | 27–89 | < 0.0001 | Yes |
P4-P7 vs P9-P12 | ALV2 vs ALV3 ↑ | 273 | ↑ | 1302 | 15 | 0–30 | 0.25 | No |
P4-P7 vs P9-P12 | ALV2 vs ALV3 ↓ | 371 | ↓ | 2199 | 25 | 11–57 | 0.82 | No |
P9-P12 vs P13-P18 | ALV3 vs ALV4 ↑ | 592 | ↑ | 1302 | 18 | 10–56 | 0.98 | No |
P9-P12 vs P13-P18 | ALV3 vs ALV4 ↓ | 623 | ↓ | 2199 | 85 | 24–84 | < 0.0001 | Yes |
P13-P18 vs P21-P56 | ALV4 vs MAT ↑ | 836 | ↑ | 1302 | 63 | 16–70 | 0.00030 | No |
P13-P18 vs P21-P56 | ALV4 vs MAT ↓ | 643 | ↓ | 2199 | 139 | 27–83 | < 0.0001 | Yes |
↑/↓ increased/decreased, EMB embryonic, PSG pseudoglandular, CAN canalicular, SAC saccular, ALV1-4 alveolarization stages 1–4, MAT mature lung.
aGene count is defined as the count of differentially increased or decreased genes, identified in lung development stage comparisons by Beauchemin et al.44 or in this study.
bObserved gene intersection was calculated as the count of shared DEGs, per comparison.
cEmpirical p-value was calculated per gene intersection as p = (b + 1)/(m + 1), where: b was the number of times a simulated gene intersection was ≥ the observed gene intersection and m was the number of permutations (m = 100,000) (Bonferroni adjP < 0.003 for 16 comparisons).
d’yes’ and bold rows indicate that the observed gene intersection was greater than the maximum simulated gene intersection.