Skip to main content
. 2021 Jan 6;11(1):63. doi: 10.3390/biom11010063

Table 1.

Overview of immunization and biopanning strategies for the identification of cell plasma membrane-protein targeting nanobodies.

Immunization and Biopanning Strategies Advantages Disadvantages References
Transfected cells
  • -

    Presents membrane protein in its native form

  • -

    Applicable for both immunization and panning procedures

  • -

    Generation of nanobodies directed towards undesired membrane proteins by the host animal

  • -

    Requires the construction of transfected cells expressing high levels of the protein of interest

[17,71,84,85,86,87,88]
Membrane extracts
  • -

    Presents membrane protein in its native form

  • -

    Enables to identify intracellular and extracellular binders

  • -

    Applicable for both immunization and panning procedures

  • -

    Generation of nanobodies directed towards undesired membrane proteins by the host animal

  • -

    Requires the construction of transfected cells expressing high levels of the protein of interest

[71,89,90]
Nanodiscs
  • -

    Presents membrane protein in its native form

  • -

    Enables to identify intracellular and extracellular binders

  • -

    Does not imply the risk of retrieving unspecific nanobodies that target other components present on cells

  • -

    Might require the construction of transfected cells expressing high levels of the protein of interest

  • -

    Complex membrane model (antigen-dependent)

[91,92,93,94,95,96]
Virus-like particles
  • -

    Presents membrane protein in its native form

  • -

    Applicable for both immunization and panning procedures

  • -

    Does not imply the risk of retrieving unspecific nanobodies that target other components present on cells

  • -

    Complex membrane model (antigen-dependent)

[71,97,98,99]
cDNA immunization
  • -

    Presents membrane protein in its native form (in vivo)

  • -

    No need to construct specific membrane models

  • -

    No generation of nanobodies directed towards undesired membrane proteins by the host animal

  • -

    Difficult retrieval of desired nanobodies due to a weak immune response of the host animal

[68,84,100,101]
Detergent solubilized proteins
  • -

    Applicable for both immunization and panning procedures

  • -

    No need to construct specific membrane models

  • -

    Detergents may cause an altered structure and function of the cell plasma membrane proteins

[92]
Endogenous proteins at the cell surface
  • -

    Presents membrane protein in its native form

  • -

    Applicable for both immunization and panning procedures

  • -

    No need to construct specific membrane models

  • -

    Difficult retrieval of desired nanobodies due to a weak immune response of the host animal

  • -

    Generation of nanobodies directed towards undesired membrane proteins by the host animal

  • -

    Low expression levels of the antigen of interest

[71,100]