Skip to main content
. 2019 May 9;112(1):63–70. doi: 10.1093/jnci/djz037

Table 3.

Life expectancy, discounted costs, discounted QALYS and ICURs for all surveillance strategies*

Strategy Life expectancy, y Discounted costs, $ Discounted QALYs Comparator Cost difference, $ QALY difference ICUR, $
Annual MAM beginning at age 30 years 45.73 32 643 24.419
Annual MAM beginning at age 25 years 45.76 33 331 24.435 Annual mammography beginning at age 30 years 688 0.016 43 000
Annual MRI beginning at age 30 years 45.86 38 494 24.458 Annual mammography beginning at age 25 years 5163 0.023 224 478
Annual MRI beginning at age 25 years, switch to annual MAM at age 50 years 45.86 38 659 24.471 Annual mammography beginning at age 25 years 5328 0.036 148 000
Annual MRI beginning at age 25 years 45.90 40 704 24.480 Annual MRI beginning at age 25, switch to annual mammography at age 50 years 2045 0.009 227 222
Annual MAM and MRI beginning at age 30 years 45.88 40 932 24.467 Annual MRI beginning at age 25 years 229 −0.013 Dominated
Annual MRI beginning at age 25 years, addition of annual MAM at age 50 years 45.89 41 475 24.472 Annual MRI beginning at age 25 years 771 −0.008 Dominated
Annual MAM and MRI beginning at age 25 years 45.90 43 739 24.477 Annual MRI beginning at age 25 years 3035 −0.003 Dominated
*

All values are discounted to time period 1, when simulated women are aged 25 years. QALYs and Discounted QALYs report QALYs remaining after age 25 years. ICUR = incremental cost utility ratio; QALY = quality-adjusted life-year; MAM = mammography; MRI = magnetic resonance imaging.

Indicates strategies that can be eliminated via the principle of extended dominance. Extended dominance is applied in incremental cost-effectiveness analysis to eliminate from consideration strategies whose costs and benefits are improved by a mixed strategy of two other alternatives.

”Strongly dominated” indicates a strategy that is more expensive and produces less benefit than its comparator, resulting in a negative ICUR, which is not standardly reported.