Table 3.
Strategy | Life expectancy, y | Discounted costs, $ | Discounted QALYs | Comparator | Cost difference, $ | QALY difference | ICUR, $ |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Annual MAM beginning at age 30 years | 45.73 | 32 643 | 24.419 | — | — | — | — |
Annual MAM beginning at age 25 years | 45.76 | 33 331 | 24.435 | Annual mammography beginning at age 30 years | 688 | 0.016 | 43 000 |
Annual MRI beginning at age 30 years | 45.86 | 38 494 | 24.458 | Annual mammography beginning at age 25 years | 5163 | 0.023 | 224 478† |
Annual MRI beginning at age 25 years, switch to annual MAM at age 50 years | 45.86 | 38 659 | 24.471 | Annual mammography beginning at age 25 years | 5328 | 0.036 | 148 000 |
Annual MRI beginning at age 25 years | 45.90 | 40 704 | 24.480 | Annual MRI beginning at age 25, switch to annual mammography at age 50 years | 2045 | 0.009 | 227 222 |
Annual MAM and MRI beginning at age 30 years | 45.88 | 40 932 | 24.467 | Annual MRI beginning at age 25 years | 229 | −0.013 | Dominated‡ |
Annual MRI beginning at age 25 years, addition of annual MAM at age 50 years | 45.89 | 41 475 | 24.472 | Annual MRI beginning at age 25 years | 771 | −0.008 | Dominated‡ |
Annual MAM and MRI beginning at age 25 years | 45.90 | 43 739 | 24.477 | Annual MRI beginning at age 25 years | 3035 | −0.003 | Dominated‡ |
All values are discounted to time period 1, when simulated women are aged 25 years. QALYs and Discounted QALYs report QALYs remaining after age 25 years. ICUR = incremental cost utility ratio; QALY = quality-adjusted life-year; MAM = mammography; MRI = magnetic resonance imaging.
Indicates strategies that can be eliminated via the principle of extended dominance. Extended dominance is applied in incremental cost-effectiveness analysis to eliminate from consideration strategies whose costs and benefits are improved by a mixed strategy of two other alternatives.
”Strongly dominated” indicates a strategy that is more expensive and produces less benefit than its comparator, resulting in a negative ICUR, which is not standardly reported.