Skip to main content
. 2021 Jan 7;22(2):551. doi: 10.3390/ijms22020551

Table 8.

Main advantages and disadvantages of MRTs.

MRT Advantages Disadvantages
GVT
  • -

    Embryo generation not required

  • -

    Germinal vesicle is large and easy to manipulate

  • -

    Very low efficacy (requires in vitro maturation)

  • -

    Deficient growth in murine model

MST
  • -

    Embryo generation not required

  • -

    Spindle has few surrounding mitochondrion (low carry-over)

  • -

    Large number of articles with good results

  • -

    Meiotic spindle is hard to visualize (not surrounded by membrane)

  • -

    Possibility of not transferring a chromosome disperse within the cytoplasm (frequent in elderly women’s oocytes)

  • -

    Spindle is sensitive to micromanipulation (maturation premature activation)

PNT
  • -

    Pro-nuclei resist micromanipulation

  • -

    Pro-nuclei are easily visible under the microscope (surrounded by membrane)

  • -

    Large number of publications

  • -

    Generation and destruction of an embryo (donor zygote)

  • -

    Carry-over rate depends on the operator (cytoplasm surrounding the pro-nucleus is rich in mitochondrion)

PB1T
  • -

    Embryo generation not required

  • -

    Minimum carry-over

  • -

    Easy manipulation of PB1 (isolated in a membrane)

  • -

    Possible to combine with MST (saving maternal ovules)

  • -

    Possible epigenetic differences between PB1 and oocyte genomes **

  • -

    Lack of publications

PB2T
  • -

    Minimum carry-over

  • -

    PB2 is easy to manipulate (isolated in a membrane)

  • -

    Possible to combine with PNT (saving maternal ovules)

  • -

    Generation and destruction of an embryo (donor zygote)

  • -

    Possible epigenetic differences between PB2 and oocyte genomes **

  • -

    Lack of publications

  • -

    Poor efficacy: difficult to distinguish female pro-nucleus in human zygotes

** This disadvantage has been refuted by recent works [31,39], although further data will be required. MRT: mitochondrial replacement techniques. GVT: germinal vesicle transfer. MST: meiotic spindle transfer. PNT: pro-nucleus transfer. PB1T: first polar body transfer. PB2T: second polar body transfer.