Table 1.
Ref | Study Design | Aim | Population (Activity) | Intervention (Duration), n |
Comparator (Duration), n | Key Findings |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Exclusive Enteral Nutrition | ||||||
Belli et al. [85] | Prospective | To reestablish growth | Pediatric CD with growth failure (n.r.) |
Intermittent EEN (1 year: 3 times 1 month EEN, with 3 month breaks) n = 8 |
No EEN, matched n = 4 |
-Intermittent EEN show sign. decrease in CDAI and prednisone intake -Intermittent EEN shows sign. height and weight gain -Similar rate of pubertal development in both groups |
Ludvigsson et al. [78] |
RCT | To compare efficacy and safety of elemental and polymeric diets | Pediatric CD (PCDAI > 12) |
Elemental formula (6 weeks) n = 17 |
Polymeric formula (6 weeks) n = 18 |
-Similar remission rates in both groups at week 6 -Sign. higher weight gain in polymeric formula |
Rubio et al. [79] | Retrospective | To analyze the efficiency of oral fractionated versus continuous enteral feeding | Pediatric CD (n.r.) |
EEN oral (8 weeks) n = 45 |
EEN continuous enteral (8 weeks) n = 61 |
-Similar remission rates in both groups -Similar effects on PCDAI and inflammatory markers in both groups -Sign. more weight gain in enteral feeding group |
Connors et al. [21] | Retrospective, propensity score-matched | To compare short- and long-term disease outcomes | Pediatric new-onset CD (PCDAI ≥ 10) |
EEN (8–16 weeks) n = 82 |
CS (n.r.) n = 45 |
-EEN sign. more effective in inducing remission -EEN associated with long term steroid avoidance over 6 years -Similar outcomes on long term linear growth, hospitalization, need for biologic therapy and surgical intervention in both groups |
Pigneur et al. [72] | RCT | To study anti-inflammatory effects and its modulatory effect on the microbiota | Pediatric new-onset CD (HBI > 5) |
EEN (8 weeks) n = 13 |
CS (4 weeks, tapered) n = 6 |
-EEN induces sign. higher mucosal healing at week 8 -Similar drop in inflammatory markers at week 8 -Higher proportion of Ruminococcus bacteria and bacteria belonging to clostridium genus in EEN group |
Logan et al. [76] | Observational | To study changes in FCP during EEN and at food reintroduction and explore associations with MEN | Pediatric CD (n.r.) |
EEN (8 weeks) n = 68 optional MEN |
- | -Sign. increase in FCP within 17 and 52 days after food reintroduction -Sign. lower FCP in MEN group compared to EEN at day 17 -MEN not associated with prolonged remission |
Partial Enteral Nutrition | ||||||
Wilschanski et al. [91] | Retrospective | To examine whether continuation of EN as nocturnal supplement lengthens remission | Pediatric CD successfully treated with EEN (n.r.) |
PEN nocturnal (n.r.) n = 28 |
No PEN n = 19 |
-Additional PEN induces sign. prolongation of remission at 6 and 12 months -Additional PEN induces sign. increased linear growth |
Johnson et al. [86] | RCT | To compare PEN with EEN for induction of remission | Pediatric CD PCDAI > 20 |
PEN (6 weeks) n = 26 |
EEN (6 weeks) n = 24 |
-EEN sign. superior to PEN in inducing clinical remission -EEN and PEN both induce sign. drop in PCDAI -PEN PCDAI drop due to/symptomatic/nutritional benefits -EEN suppresses inflammation |
Kang et al. [94] | Prospective open-label study | To examine the effects of concomitant use of PEN as adjuvant therapy | Pediatric severe CD PCDAI > 45 |
PEN (4 weeks) n = 18 |
Normal diet n = 16 |
-PEN improved nutritional status sign. after 1 year |
Lee et al. [88] | Prospective | To compare effectiveness between PEN, EEN, and anti-TNF therapy for induction of remission | Pediatric CD PCDAI > 10 |
EEN (8 weeks) n = 22 PEN (8 weeks) n = 16 |
Anti-TNF (n.r.) n = 52 |
-Clinical remission PEN 50%, EEN 76%, anti-TNF 73% -EEN sign. superior in inducing remission -FCP < 250 ug/g sign. higher in EEN and anti-TNF -Improvement QOL similar in all groups |
Schulman et al. [92] | Retrospective | To evaluate efficacy of PEN for preventing clinical relapse | Pediatric CD successfully treated with EEN (n.r.) |
PEN as supplementary diet (median 6 months) n = 42 |
No PEN n = 45 |
-Similar duration of maintenance of remission in both groups -Suppl. PEN sign. increases weight and BMI |
Specific diet | ||||||
Sigall et al. [99] | Retrospective | To report on experience with CDED and its efficiency in inducing remission | Pediatric and young adults with CD PCDAI ≥ 10 HBI > 3 |
CDED + PEN (12 weeks) n = 40 CDED alone (12 weeks) n = 7 |
- | -Remission achieved in 78.8% of participants at week 6 (24/34 children and 9/13 adults) -Remission maintained in 84% of participants at week 12 -Remission in 6/7 participants on CDED alone -Sign. reduction of PCDAI and inflammatory markers |
Sigall et al. [98] | Retrospective | To report on experience of CDED for induction of remission in patients with loss of response to infliximab/adalimumab or combination therapy | Pediatric and young adults with CD with flare/active inflammation on biological (n.r.) |
CDED + PEN (12 weeks) n = 12 CDED alone (12 weeks) n = 4 Modified EEN + CDED (2 + 12 weeks) n = 5 |
- | -Clinical remission 62% (13/21) -Among patients failing combination therapy 53% reach remission (9/17) -Sign. reduction of inflammatory markers overall |
Levine et al. [3] | RCT | To study tolerability of the diet and efficacy in induction of remission | Pediatric mild to moderate CD 10 ≤ PCDAI ≤ 40 |
CDED + PEN (12 weeks) n = 40 |
EEN (6 weeks) n = 34 |
- CDED and EEN equally effective in inducing remission at week 6 - CDED superior in sustained remission at week 12 -CDED sustained changes in fecal microbiome at week 12 -CDED and EEN induce a rapid clinical response (by week 3) -Identification of patients with a rapid response to diet could identify those who will be in clinical remission by week 6 with good compliance [103] |
Svolos et al. [44] | Open-label | To test efficacy of CD-TREAT to induce clinical remission and ameliorate inflammatory markers | Pediatric relapsing CD wPCDAI ≥ 12.5 |
CD-TREAT (8 weeks) n = 5 |
- | -CD-TREAT induced clinical response 80% (4/5) -CD-TREAT induced clinical remission 60% (3/5) -CD-TREAT induced decrease in fecal calprotectin 4/5 |
Urlep et al. [97] | RCT | To compare clinical and endoscopic remission rates and mucosal healing | Pediatric CD PCDAI > 10 |
AID-CD + PEN (6 weeks) n = 12 |
EEN (6 weeks) n = 13 |
-AID-CD and EEN equally effective in inducing clinical and endoscopic remission -EEN had superior mucosal healing, although not significant |
RCT: randomized controlled trial. CD: Crohn’s disease. EEN: exclusive enteral nutrition. CS: corticosteroids. HBI: Harvey Bradshaw Index. PCDAI: Pediatric Crohn’s Disease Activity Index. FCP: fecal calprotectin. MEN: maintenance enteral nutrition. EN: enteral nutrition PEN: partial enteral nutrition. CDED: Crohn’s disease exclusion diet. CD-TREAT: CD treatment with diet. AID-CD: anti-inflammatory diet–CD; sign.: significant. n: sample size. n.r.: not reported.