Table 3.
Evidence assessment scheme for assessment of evidence for review
Quality of evidence | Effect size strength (only evidence I–II) | ||
---|---|---|---|
I | Randomized trial with clinical outcomes and/or validated laboratory endpoints | + + + | Strong positive effect on mortality (≥ 5%) |
II | Non-randomized trial or observational cohort study | + + | Positive effect on mortality (< 5%) |
III | Single-arm study or case series/reports | + | Some positive effect on an outcome |
IV | Editorials/expert opinion | 0 | No significant effect noted from treatment |
V | Animal or animal-model research | − | Some negative effect/increased adverse events |
VI | In vitro research or AI-based drug selection | − − | Negative effect on mortality (< 5%) |
P | In-progress clinical trials | − − − | Strong negative effect on mortality (≥ 5%) |
N/A | Not applicable |