Table 2.
Characteristics of included peer-reviewed articles (n = 53).
Publication and Overall Purpose | Journal and Publication Type | Authors’ Primary Clinical Expertise | Patient, Family, or Provider Experience | Primary Communication Topic | Resources Provided | Evidence-based | Theoretical Model |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Adams [52] | Journal of Pain and Symptom Management, Summary with case | Physician | Provider | Goals of care | ✓ | ||
Challenges and recommendations for goals of care discussions | |||||||
Chen [53] | Critical Care Alert, Summary | Physician | Provider | Moral distress | |||
Ethical considerations in the intensive care unit | |||||||
Akgun, Shamas, et al [54] | Heart & Lung, Summary | Physician | Provider | Grief and bereavement | |||
Practical and actionable communication strategies | |||||||
Back, Tulsky, Arnold [55] | Annals of Internal Medicine, Summary | Physician | Provider | Advance care planning | ✓ | ✓ | |
Pro-active care planning, explaining resource allocation | |||||||
Barello, Palamenghi, Graffigna [56] | Patient Education and Counseling, Survey | Other | Provider | Empathy and compassion | ✓ | ||
“C.O.P.E.” Project (COVID 19 – related Outcomes of health Professionals during the Epidemic) | |||||||
Bergman, et al. [57] | Annals of Family Medicine, Summary | Physician | Provider | Telehealth | ✓ | ||
Possible ways relationships develop in different health care encounters | |||||||
Bowman, et al. [58] | Journal of Pain and Symptom Management, Summary | Nurse | Provider | General patient communication | ✓ | ||
Training gaps in symptom management and patient communication | |||||||
Brucato [59] | Journal of Communication in Healthcare, Interview | Physician | Provider | General patient communication | |||
Importance of communication as part of effective pandemic response in clinical settings | |||||||
Carico, Sheppard, Thomas [60] | Research in Social and Administrative Pharmacy, Summary | Other- Pharmacy | Provider | Prevention | ✓ | ✓ | |
Overview of Health Belief Model with a guide to patient communication in these uncertain contexts | |||||||
Cordero & Davis [61] | Journal of Patient Experience, Summary | Physician | Provider | General patient communication | |||
Offers practical tools for communication that can mitigate interpersonal bias | |||||||
Dhavale et al. [62] | Indian Journal of Palliative Care, Qualitative | Social Work | Provider | General patient communication | |||
Describe challenges of patients and caregivers during the lockdown due to COVID-19 pandemic | |||||||
Diamond, Jacobs, Karliner [63] | Patient Education and Counseling, Editorial | Physician | Provider | General patient communication | ✓ | ||
Algorithm approach to overcome language barrier for limited English proficient patients | |||||||
Fan, et al. [64] | World Journal of Clinical Cases, Summary | Nurse | Patient | General patient communication | |||
Common issues of being in isolation were raised and strategies offered | |||||||
Feder et al. [65] | Heart & Lung, Summary | Physician | Provider | General patient communication | ✓ | ||
Application of core palliative care principles during COVID-19 crisis | |||||||
Finset, et al. [66] | Patient Education and Counseling, Summary | Other- Multidisciplinary | Provider | Prevention | |||
Implementation of health communication in the COVID-19 crisis | |||||||
Gaur, et al. [67] | Journal of Post-Acute and Long-Term Care Medicine, Summary | Physician | Provider | Advance care planning | ✓ | ✓ | |
Proposes an evidence-based COVID-19 Communication and Care Planning Tool allowing for informed consent and shared decision making | |||||||
Gharzai, et al. [68] | Journal of the American Medical Association, Qualitative | Physician | Provider | Prognosis/End of life care | ✓ | ✓ | |
Identify clinical scenarios that pose communication challenges with patient reactions | |||||||
Gibbon, et al. [69] | Journal of Pain and Symptom Management, Summary | Physician | Provider | Prognosis/End of life care | ✓ | ||
Developed a point-of-care tool to summarize outcome data for critically ill patients with COVID-19 | |||||||
Hart, et al. [70] | Journal of Pain and Symptom Management, Summary | Physician | Family | Goals of care | ✓ | ||
Toolbox of strategies for supporting family-centered in-patient care during COVID-19 | |||||||
Hauser [71] Health care |
Hasting Center Report, Personal Narrative | Physician | Provider | General patient communication | |||
professionals disconnect with patients and families | |||||||
Hector [72] | Caring for the Ages: Journal of Post-Acute and Long-Term Care Medicine, Summary | Social Work | Provider | Grief and bereavement | ✓ | ||
Proactive communication and collaboration with families during COVID-19 | |||||||
Hill [73] | The Diabetic Foot Journal, Summary | Other | Provider | Goals of care | |||
Explores the role and influence of patient and healthcare professional communication in the context of diabetes and diabetes-related foot problems | |||||||
Holstead & Robinson [74] | Journal of Clinical Oncology, Summary | Physician | Provider | Telehealth | ✓ | ✓ | |
Strategies to help maintain a high standard of care and communication with patients | |||||||
Houchens & Tipirneni [75] | Journal of Hospital Medicine, Summary | Physician | Provider | General patient communication | |||
Challenges arising from communicate barriers in the time of COVID-19 | |||||||
Julka-Anderson [76] | Journal of Medical Imaging and Radiation Sciences, Personal Narrative | Other-Radiation Therapist | Provider | Telehealth | ✓ | ||
Adapting communication skills | |||||||
Lewin [77] | Canadian Medical Association Journal, Summary | Physician | Provider | Goals of care | |||
Making treatment recommendations during COVID-19 pandemic | |||||||
Lewis [78] | American Journal of Hospice & Palliative Medicine, Summary with Case | Physician | Provider | Goals of care | |||
Facilitating goals-of-care during the COVID-19 pandemic | |||||||
Lu [79] | Journal of Palliative Medicine, Summary | Physician | Provider | Goals of care | ✓ | ||
Establishing communication strategies for kidney disease in context of COVID-19 | |||||||
Marra, et al. [80] | Critical Care Bio Medical Central, Summary | Physician | Provider | General patient communication | |||
Highly compromised verbal and nonverbal communication in the COVID-19 pandemic | |||||||
McNairy, Bullington, Bloom-Feshbach [81] | Journal of General Internal Medicine, Personal Narrative | Physician | Provider | Empathy and compassion | |||
Recommend using technology to improve doctor-patient communication during COVID-19 | |||||||
Montauk, Kuhl [82] | Psychological Trauma, Summary | Nurse | Provider | Grief and bereavement | |||
Recommendations to support family members of COVID-19 patients in the ICU | |||||||
Negro, Mucci, et al [83] | Intense & Critical Nursing, Summary | Nurse | Provider | Telehealth | ✓ | ||
Recommend video conference with family of COVID-19 patients in the ICU | |||||||
Nemetz, Urbach, Devon [84] | Journal of Medical Internet Research, Summary | Physician | Provider | Telehealth | |||
To resolve communication challenges including preparation, professionalism, empathy, respect, and the virtual physical examination | |||||||
Pahuja, Wojcikewych [85] | Journal of Palliative Medicine, Summary with Case | Physician | Provider | Prognosis/End of life care | |||
To present a case of inadvertently created barriers to routine palliative intervention | |||||||
Prestia [86] | Nurse Leader, Summary | Nurse | Provider-Leadership | Moral distress | |||
Offers suggestions on staying resilient and upholding one’s moral obligations during COVID-19 | |||||||
Raftery, Lewis, Cardona [87] | Gerontology, Summary | Nurse | Provider | Advance care planning | |||
Proposes nurse-led and allied health-led ACP discussions to ensure patient and family inclusion and understanding of the disease prognosis, prevention of overtreatment, and potential out comes in crisis times | |||||||
Ramachandran [88] | Anesthesia Reports, Personal Narrative | Physician | Patient | Empathy and compassion | |||
To present a junior doctor’s view of how COVID-19 was managed by the health system and a personal view of his COVID-19 experience | |||||||
Rathore, Puneet, et al [89] | Indian Journal of Palliative Care, Summary | Physician | Empathy and compassion | ✓ | |||
Proposes a model of CARE approach for providing holistic care during the times of pandemic | |||||||
Ritchey, Foy, McArdel [90] | American Journal of Hospice & Palliative Medicine, Summary with Case | Physician | Provider | Telehealth | ✓ | ||
Describes a case illustrating the successful use of palliative care telehealth in the care of a COVID-19-positive patient at the end of life | |||||||
Robblee, Buse, et al [91] | Headache, Summary with scenarios | Physician | Provider | Moral distress | |||
To describe 11 scenarios of unhelpful and dysfunctional messages heard by the authors and their colleagues during the COVID-19 pandemic | |||||||
Rosenbluth, Good [92] | Journal of Hospital Medicine, Summary | Physician | Provider | General patient communication | |||
To discuss challenges during COVID-19 pandemic | |||||||
Schlögl, A. Jones [93] | Journal of the American Geriatrics Society, Summary | Physician | Provider | Empathy and compassion | |||
To provide recommendations to improve mindful communication | |||||||
Schrager [94] | American Academy of Family Physicians, Summary | Physician | Provider | Empathy and compassion | |||
To present recommendations for providers to stay connected with patients during COVID-19 pandemic | |||||||
Selman, Chao, et al. [95] | Journal of Pain and Symptom Management, Summary | Other: Ph.D. Researchers | Provider | Grief and bereavement | ✓ | ✓ | |
Recommendations for hospital clinicians on bereavement support | |||||||
Simpson, Porter [96] | Houston Methodist DeBakey Cardiovascular Journal, Personal Narrative | Physician | Provider | General patient communication | |||
To provide recommendations to | |||||||
improve patient-provider relationship during COVID-19 pandemic | |||||||
Sirianni, Torabi [97] | Canadian Family Physician, Summary | Physician | Provider | Goals of care | ✓ | ✓ | |
To provide recommendations to improve communication during COVID-19 pandemic | |||||||
Siropaides, Sulistio, Reimold [98] | Circulation, Summary | Physician | Provider | Prevention | ✓ | ||
To provide recommendations to optimize communication to patients with cardiovascular disease during the COVID-19 pandemic | |||||||
Sivashanker, Mendu, et al [99] | The Joint Commission Journal on Quality and Patient Safety, Summary | Physician | Provider | Prevention | ✓ | ||
To develop a pragmatic COVID-19 exposure disclosure checklist to improve communication | |||||||
Stilos, Moore [100] | Canadian Oncology Nursing Journal, Summary | Nurse and Physician | Provider | Prognosis/end of life care | |||
To discuss the challenges for communication during COVID-19 pandemic | |||||||
Ting, Edmonds, et al [101] | BMJ, Summary | Physician | Provider | General patient communication | ✓ | ||
To provide recommendation for communication and palliative care during COVID-19 | |||||||
Underwood [102] | Journal of Aesthetic Nursing, Summary | Other: CEO | Provider | General patient communication | |||
Reinventing patient communication to stay connected | |||||||
Wallace, Wladkowski [103] | Journal of Pain and Symptom Management, Summary | Social Work | Provider | Grief and bereavement | ✓ | ||
To describe the relationship of the COVID-19 pandemic to anticipatory grief, disenfranchised grief, and complicated grief for individuals, families, and their providers | |||||||
Wolf, Waissengrin [104] | The Oncologist, Summary with Case | Physician | Provider | Telehealth | ✓ | ||
To provide recommendations for telehealth communication |