Xu et al. [23] |
Chondrocytes |
Alginate gel beads with chondrocytes |
Spinner flasks |
Improved the GAG quantification and relevant gene expression |
Yoon et al. [24] |
hADSCs |
Cellular metabolic response to dynamic loading |
Spinner flasks |
Enhanced chondrogenic differentiation of hADSCs |
Zhu et al. [25] |
hADSCs |
Chitosan/gelatin hybrid hydrogel and subsequent dynamic loading |
Rotating wall vessels |
Enhanced proliferation and matrix secretion |
Nordberg et al. [26] |
RCS |
Culture of cell pellets |
Rotating wall vessels |
Mechanical stimulation influenced the expression of LRP4/5/6 in chondrocytes |
Theodoridis et al. [27] |
hADSCs |
3D-printed PCL scaffolds seeded cells |
Perfusion bioreactors |
Achieved better penetration and uniform distribution of the cells within the scaffold |
Pigeot et al. [28] |
hBM-MSCs |
Human MSCs cultured in the perfusion bioreactor |
Perfusion bioreactors |
Generated a homogeneous hypertrophic cartilage ECM; efficiently induced towards apoptosis |
Dikina et al. [31] |
hBM-MSCs |
Scaffold-free human mesenchymal stem cell sheets in response to variable magnetic fields |
Magnetic bioreactors |
Did not affect cartilage formation |
Thakurta et al. [34] |
Chondrocytes |
Chondrocyte-seeded scaffolds |
Ultrasonic bioreactors |
Ultrasonic stimulation significantly impacted cell proliferation and depth-independent cell population density |
Subramanian et al. [36] |
Chondrocytes |
Studying the response of cells to ultrasonic stimulation |
Ultrasonic bioreactors |
Positively influenced several factors, including cell proliferation, viability, and gene expression of select chondrocytic markers |