Skip to main content
. 2021 Jan 27;11(1):e043166. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2020-043166

Table 2.

Adjusted marginal structural models estimating controlled direct effects (CDE) of inflammatory markers (i.e., high-sensitivity C reactive protein (CRP), tumour necrosis factor (TNF), and Interleukin 6 (IL-6)) on systolic blood pressure (SBP) measures in the presence and absence of vitamin D (VD) insufficiency [25(OH)D<50 nmol/L] among Indigenous Cree adults from the Multi-Community Environment-and-Health Study, 2005–2009

CDE for SBP measures
VD insufficiency present (m=1) P value* VD insufficiency absent (m=0) P value*
†E(Y(a, m(1) – Y(a*, m(1))) †E(Y(a, m(0) – Y(a*,m(0))
Estimate β 95% CI Estimate β 95% CI
CRP
 Model 1 −2.32 −15.19 to 10.54 0.724 0.78 −5.30 to 6.85 0.803
 Model 2 −1.06 −14.50 to 12.37 0.877 0.90 −5.72 to 7.56 0.789
 Model 3 1.76 −14.75 to 18.29 0.839 0.41 −6.93 to 7.75 0.913
TNF-α
 Model 1 −13.67 –23.78 to –3.56 0.008* −5.70 −11.47 to 0.08 0.053
 Model 2 −13.61 –23.54 to –3.07 0.011* −5.92 –11.65 to –0.18 0.043
 Model 3 −13.61 –24.42 to –2.80 0.014* −5.73 −11.59 to 0.13 0.052
IL-6
 Model 1 5.79 −15.26 to 26.85 0.589 1.85 −7.94 to 11.64 0.711
 Model 2 7.81 −13.59 to 29.22 0.474 1.54 −7.70 to 10.80 0.743
 Model 3 13.9 −13.32 to 41.15 0.317 2.62 −10.75 to 15.99 0.701

*Statistical significance (p<0.05).

†CDE for the each inflammatory marker exposure level indicating the average direct effect change on SBP and diastolic blood pressure outcomes if the exposure is contrasted (ie, a=1, and a*=0), while uniformly fixing the intermediate variable (m) to either designated level, VD insufficiency or VD sufficiency (ie, m(1) and m(0), respectively) in the population. Model 1: age, sex; Model 2: model 1, plus smoking status; Model 3: model 2, plus body mass index.