Skip to main content
. 2020 Nov 20;12(1):171–184. doi: 10.1007/s12687-020-00494-0

Table 2.

Summary of responses to general survey questions about Secondary findings (SFs)

Statement in the survey Data available n Responses
n %
Attitude towards returning SFs. Research participants should: 657
  Be given the option of deciding whether to have genetic SFs returned 524 79.9
  Probably have the option of deciding whether to have genetic SFs returned 116 17.7
  Not have the option of deciding whether to have genetic SFs returned 17 2.6
Should low-income countries (LICs) have different guidelines to high-income countries (HICs) for disclosing SFs? 659
  Yes, because researchers from LICs might not have the resources to deal with SFs. 184 27.9
  Yes, because research participants from LICs might not be able to afford treatment. 142 21.5
  No, because countries that cannot deal with SFs should not start studies. 71 10.8
  No, because research participants from countries that do not have the resources to deal with SFs should not participate in studies. 52 7.9
  Other 210 31.9
Should South Africa have unique guidelines for returning SFs? 660
  Yes, because South Africa does not have the same resources for dealing with SFs as other countries, therefore different guidelines are needed. 207 31.4
  Yes, because there are many different types of people and cultures in South Africa, therefore unique guidelines are needed. 144 21.8
  No, researchers from all countries should follow the same guidelines so that there is standardization and uniformity. 230 34.8
  No, research should not be allowed to be conducted if the resources for dealing with SFs are not in place. 41 6.2
  Other 38 5.8
SFs in genetic research may be inheritable. This could mean that the participant’s family members are also affected by the finding. 669
  The participant is responsible for informing his family. 396 59.2
  It is the researchers' responsibility to ensure the participant's family is informed. 138 20.6
  It is not feasible for researchers to inform participants' families of SFs. 135 20.2