Table 4.
Study | Intervention Therapy | Details | Duration | Frequency | Control Therapy |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Diaferia et al, 201325 | Myofunctional therapy | Exercises of localized muscle resistance in the oropharyngeal area (soft palate, pharyngeal constrictor muscles, suprahyoid muscles, tip and root of the tongue, cheeks, and lips) | 3 mo | 20 minutes, 3 times per day. Exercise daily diary (new exercises every week) | Sham speech/myofunctional therapy (head movements without any therapeutic function) |
Diaferia et al, 201722 | Myofunctional therapy | a. Soft palate exercises | 3 mo | a. 3 minutes, 3 times per day | Sham speech/myofunctional therapy (head movements without any therapeutic function) |
b. Tongue brushing | b. 5 times, 3 times per day | ||||
c. Tongue pushing and sucking | c. 20 times, 3 times per day | ||||
d. Tongue rotation | d. 10 times on each side, 3 times per day | ||||
e. Facial exercises | |||||
e1. Pressing the buccinators muscle outward | e1. 10 times on each side, 3 times per day | ||||
e2. Sucking air from a syringe | e2. 5 times, 3 times per day | ||||
f. Stomatognathic functions | |||||
f1. Breathing and speech including forced nasal inspiration and oral expiration in conjunction with phonation of open vowels | f1. During sitting | ||||
f2. Balloon inflation with prolonged nasal inspiration and then forced blowing | f2. 5 times per day | ||||
f3. Swallowing and chewing | f3. During eating | ||||
Guimaraes et al, 200914 | Oropharyngeal exercises | a. Soft palate and tongue exercises | 3 mo | a. 3 minutes per day | Supervised session (30 min per week of deep breathing + nasal lavage with 10 ml of saline in each nostril 3 times per day. |
b. Tongue brushing (superior and lateral surface) | b. Each movement 5 times, 3 times per day | ||||
c. Closing the orbicularis oris | c. 30 seconds | ||||
d. Mouth angle elevation | d. 10 intermittent elevations, 3 times per day | ||||
e. Stomatognathic functions | e. Similar to Diaferia et al22 | ||||
Ieto et al, 201521 | Nasal lavage three times a day followed by oropharyngeal exercises. | Oropharyngeal exercises: | 3 mo | 8-min set of exercises (20 times), 3 times a day for therapy and control | Nasal washing/lavage 3 × day + deep breathing exercises while sitting) |
a. Pushing the tip of the tongue against the hard palate and slide the tongue backward | |||||
b. Sucking the tongue upward against the palate, pressing the entire tongue against the palate | |||||
c. Forcing the back of the tongue against the floor of the mouth | |||||
d. Elevation of the soft palate and uvula | |||||
e. Pressing the buccinators outward | |||||
f. Alternate bilateral chewing and deglutition during eating | |||||
Kuo et al, 201716 | Expiratory muscle training Resistance pressure at 75% of each participant’s PE max | Inhalation and exhalation with an interval of 30–60 s with 2-min break after each breathing cycle | 5 weeks | 5 days per week, 25 breaths per day, 5 breaths per cycle, 5 cycles per day | Expiratory muscle training (resistance pressure at 0% of each participant’s PE max) |
Puhan et al, 200627 | Playing Didgeridoo and daily practice at home with standardized instruments | a. Week 1: Lip technique to produce and hold the keynote for 20–30 seconds. | 4 mo. | At least 20 minutes and at least 5 days per week | Waiting list (no treatment) |
b. Week 2 and 3: Circular breathing technique | |||||
c. Week 4: Optimization of the complex interaction between the lips, the vocal tract, and circular breathing | |||||
d. 8 weeks later: Repetition of techniques and corrections | |||||
Villa et al, 201526 and Villa et al, 201724 | Oropharyngeal exercises | a. Nasal breathing rehabilitation | 2 mo. | 10–20 repetitions, 3 times per day | Nasal washing/lavage 2 times per day |
b. Labial seal and lip tone exercises | |||||
c. Tongue posture exercises | |||||
Vranish & Bailey, 201628 | Inspiratory muscle strength training (75% of PI max) | Inspiratory muscle strength training | 6 weeks | 30 breaths per day | Inspiratory muscle strength training (15% of PI max) |
PE max = expiratory pressure, PI max = inspiratory pressure.