Skip to main content
. 2020 May 15;16(5):785–801. doi: 10.5664/jcsm.8318

Table 4.

Interventions in treatment and control groups.

Study Intervention Therapy Details Duration Frequency Control Therapy
Diaferia et al, 201325 Myofunctional therapy Exercises of localized muscle resistance in the oropharyngeal area (soft palate, pharyngeal constrictor muscles, suprahyoid muscles, tip and root of the tongue, cheeks, and lips) 3 mo 20 minutes, 3 times per day. Exercise daily diary (new exercises every week) Sham speech/myofunctional therapy (head movements without any therapeutic function)
Diaferia et al, 201722 Myofunctional therapy a. Soft palate exercises 3 mo a. 3 minutes, 3 times per day Sham speech/myofunctional therapy (head movements without any therapeutic function)
b. Tongue brushing b. 5 times, 3 times per day
c. Tongue pushing and sucking c. 20 times, 3 times per day
d. Tongue rotation d. 10 times on each side, 3 times per day
e. Facial exercises
e1. Pressing the buccinators muscle outward e1. 10 times on each side, 3 times per day
e2. Sucking air from a syringe e2. 5 times, 3 times per day
f. Stomatognathic functions
f1. Breathing and speech including forced nasal inspiration and oral expiration in conjunction with phonation of open vowels f1. During sitting
f2. Balloon inflation with prolonged nasal inspiration and then forced blowing f2. 5 times per day
f3. Swallowing and chewing f3. During eating
Guimaraes et al, 200914 Oropharyngeal exercises a. Soft palate and tongue exercises 3 mo a. 3 minutes per day Supervised session (30 min per week of deep breathing + nasal lavage with 10 ml of saline in each nostril 3 times per day.
b. Tongue brushing (superior and lateral surface) b. Each movement 5 times, 3 times per day
c. Closing the orbicularis oris c. 30 seconds
d. Mouth angle elevation d. 10 intermittent elevations, 3 times per day
e. Stomatognathic functions e. Similar to Diaferia et al22
Ieto et al, 201521 Nasal lavage three times a day followed by oropharyngeal exercises. Oropharyngeal exercises: 3 mo 8-min set of exercises (20 times), 3 times a day for therapy and control Nasal washing/lavage 3 × day + deep breathing exercises while sitting)
a. Pushing the tip of the tongue against the hard palate and slide the tongue backward
b. Sucking the tongue upward against the palate, pressing the entire tongue against the palate
c. Forcing the back of the tongue against the floor of the mouth
d. Elevation of the soft palate and uvula
e. Pressing the buccinators outward
f. Alternate bilateral chewing and deglutition during eating
Kuo et al, 201716 Expiratory muscle training Resistance pressure at 75% of each participant’s PE max Inhalation and exhalation with an interval of 30–60 s with 2-min break after each breathing cycle 5 weeks 5 days per week, 25 breaths per day, 5 breaths per cycle, 5 cycles per day Expiratory muscle training (resistance pressure at 0% of each participant’s PE max)
Puhan et al, 200627 Playing Didgeridoo and daily practice at home with standardized instruments a. Week 1: Lip technique to produce and hold the keynote for 20–30 seconds. 4 mo. At least 20 minutes and at least 5 days per week Waiting list (no treatment)
b. Week 2 and 3: Circular breathing technique
c. Week 4: Optimization of the
complex interaction between the lips, the vocal tract, and circular
breathing
d. 8 weeks later: Repetition of techniques and corrections
Villa et al, 201526 and Villa et al, 201724 Oropharyngeal exercises a. Nasal breathing rehabilitation 2 mo. 10–20 repetitions, 3 times per day Nasal washing/lavage 2 times per day
b. Labial seal and lip tone exercises
c. Tongue posture exercises
Vranish & Bailey, 201628 Inspiratory muscle strength training (75% of PI max) Inspiratory muscle strength training 6 weeks 30 breaths per day Inspiratory muscle strength training (15% of PI max)

PE max = expiratory pressure, PI max = inspiratory pressure.