Skip to main content
. 2021 Jan 22;11:100089. doi: 10.1016/j.wroa.2021.100089

Table 2.

Effects of categorical variables as percent increase or decrease of the mean HAN:THM ratio estimated for surface water.

Category % Effect (2.5%, 97.5% CI) Adjusted mean ratio Sig.
Base-case: SW, FINISH, Summer, CL2-CL2 0.119 ∗∗∗
Source water (FINISH, Summer, CL2-CL2)
GW 165 (122, 217) 0.315 ∗∗∗
MIX 72.9 (31.4, 128) 0.205 ∗∗∗
GI 52.7 (7.5, 117) 0.181
PUR 24.1 (−30.6, 122)
Sampling location (SW, Summer, CL2-CL2)
DSE −20.9 (−23.2, −18.6) 0.094 ∗∗∗
AVG1 −26.4 (−28.5, −24.2) 0.087 ∗∗∗
AVG2 −27.0 (−29.1, −24.9) 0.086 ∗∗∗
MAX −40.0 (−41.7, −38.2) 0.071 ∗∗∗
Season (SW, FINISH, CL2-CL2)
Autumn 11.9 (8.7, 15.2) 0.133 ∗∗∗
Winter 38.1 (33.6, 42.8) 0.164 ∗∗∗
Spring 19.7 (15.7, 24.0) 0.142 ∗∗∗
Disinfectant sequence (SW, FINISH, Summer)
CL2-CLM 1.0 (−11.8, 15.7)
Cl2-CLM-CLM 19.3 (61, 24.1) 0.141 ∗∗∗
CLM 22.3 (1.1, 48.0) 0.145
CLX-CL2 −28.5 (−45.0, −7.2) 0.085
CLX-CLM −11.8 (−27.3, 6.9)
CL2 −4.0 (−27.8, 27.7)
O3-CL2 11.9 (−8.6, 37.0)
O3-CLM 29.2 (3.7, 61.0) 0.153

Table key: Sig.: significance to the ∗ 95%, ∗∗ 99%, or ∗∗∗ >99.9% confidence level. Disinfectant sequence abbreviations: chlorine (CL2), chloramines (CLM), chlorine dioxide (CLX), ozone (O3).

Table notes: Effect estimates in Table S5A were converted to percent effect by exponentiating, subtracting one, and multiplying by 100. To calculate the adjusted mean ratio for a particular category, add 100% to the percent effect and multiply by the conditional mean ratio (i.e., the intercept, the base-case, 0.119).