Fig. 2. Single cell isotope probing of nitrifying activated sludge in batch, recirculated, and flow-through incubations.

a–c Show representative FISH images of E2 (AOB in yellow; NOB in magenta; other cells counterstained by DAPI in gray) of batch, recirculated, and flow-through incubations, respectively, and d–f show the corresponding nanoSIMS images. Scale bar is 10 µm in all images. g–l Show ¹³C labeling of AOB, NOB, and other cells quantified by nanoSIMS at the single-cell level for E1 (g–i) and E2 (j–l) in batch, recirculated, and flow-through incubations, respectively. We used FISH probe sets targeting AOB (Nitrosomonas oligotropha cluster (Cl6a192), Nitrosomonas eutropha/europea/urea cluster (NEU)) and NOB (Nitrotoga (Ntoga122), Nitrospira Lineage 1 (Ntspa1431), and Nitrospira Lineage 2 (Ntspa1151)), respectively, for differential staining of the two nitrifier groups. In (g–l), dashed lines give the ¹³C natural abundance values of the filter surface. The number of cells analyzed per group is indicated below each boxplot. For each experiment, lower case letters indicate significant difference in ¹³C labeling between groups (AOB, NOB, other cells) within an incubation type and upper case letters indicate significant difference between incubation types for a given group (Kruskal–Wallis test followed by Dunn’s test; Statistics are given in Table S2). Boxplots depict the 25–75% quantile range, with the center line depicting the median (50% quantile) and whiskers encompass data points within 1.5× the interquartile range.