First author (y) |
Intervention |
Start time |
Acupuncture points |
Needle retaining time |
Intervention Dose |
|
AG |
CG |
AG |
CG |
|
|
|
Liao et al. (16) |
Analgesia drugs, routine rehabilitation, traditional manual acupuncture |
Analgesia drugs, routine rehabilitation |
From 2 d before surgery to post-operative 2 w |
LI4 and LR3 in both sides |
30 min |
Once/d, 2w |
Wang (17) |
Analgesia pump, traditional manual acupuncture |
Analgesia pump |
2 d after operation |
BL36, LR3, BL37, SP10, SP9, GB34 |
Not mentioned. |
Once/d, 2w |
Zhang et al. (18) |
Analgesia pump, routine rehabilitation, traditional manual acupuncture |
Analgesia pump, routine rehabilitation |
1 d after operation |
LR3, BL 60, KI3, BL 62, SP6 and SI3 in the operated side; LU5, LI11, and LI10 in both sides |
30 min |
Once/d, 2w |
Petersen et al. (24) |
Standard rehabilitation, western medical acupuncture |
Standard rehabilitation |
(2.2 ± 1.3) w after operation |
(2.4 ± 1.6) w after operation |
ST32, GB31, GB39, ST41, and LR3 in the operated side; SP10, ST34, LR8, SP9, and ST36 in the opposite side |
15 20 min |
Twice/w, 6w |
Mikashima et al. (19) |
Basic rehabilitation program, traditional manual acupuncture |
Basic rehabilitation program |
7 d after operation |
ST31, 32, 38; SP6; BL-23, 25, 37, 57, 60; KI3; GB31,39, 40, 41, 42, and LR3 in the operated side |
20 30 min |
3 times/w, 2w |
Chen et al. (20) |
Auricular acupuncture and electroacupuncture |
Only sham auricular acupuncture |
Anesthetized and right before surgery started. |
Auricular acupoints: TF4, AH4, AH6a and AT4; acupuncture points: SP10, ST34, BL40, LR7, ST36, GV20, and GV24 |
20 min |
1session only |
Tsang et al. (25) |
Standard physiotherapy program and traditional manual acupuncture |
Standard physiotherapy program and sham acupuncture |
4 d after operation |
ST32, ST33, GB31, GB35, GB34 and ST36 |
20 min |
10 sessions within 2w |
Mayoral et al. (21) |
Dry needling |
Sham dry needling |
Anesthetized and right before surgery started. |
Myofascial trigger points |
Hong's fast-in, fast-out technique |
1 session only |
Wang (22) |
Standard physiotherapy program and traditional manual acupuncture |
Standard physiotherapy program. |
3 d after operation |
ST34, 35, 36, 41; SP10, SP9, GB33,34; LI4, BL40, EX-LE5 |
30 min |
Twice/w, 6w |