Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2021 Nov 24.
Published in final edited form as: Chem Mater. 2020 Nov 5;32(22):9508–9530. doi: 10.1021/acs.chemmater.0c03018

Table 2.

Comparative table of crosslinking methods to fabricate hydrogels for bone regeneration

Crosslinking Advantages Drawbacks
Photo-radical
graphic file with name nihms-1649935-t0006.jpg
- Fast and mild reaction by not altering pH or temperature enormously
- Forming a stable crosslinked network
- May damage cells or bioactive molecules depending on the light sources
- Irreversible reaction
Schiff base
graphic file with name nihms-1649935-t0007.jpg
- Reversible reaction with self-healing properties
- Mild reaction condition
- Relatively low stability of pseudocovalent bond
- Need to prepare two separate reactive polymers
Michael addition
graphic file with name nihms-1649935-t0008.jpg
- Forming a stable crosslinked network
- Self-healing properties under certain conditions such as excess presence of thiols
- Potential side reaction to form unexpected disulfide bonds
- Need to prepare two separate reactive polymers
Diels-Alder
graphic file with name nihms-1649935-t0009.jpg
- Specific bio-orthogonal reaction
- No side reactions and byproducts
- Need to prepare two separate reactive polymers
- Considered as an irreversible reaction under physiological condition (reversible at extremely high temperature above 800K)
Enzyme
graphic file with name nihms-1649935-t0010.jpg
- Fast and mild reaction with controlled gelation kinetics
- Forming a stable crosslinked network
- Short half-life of enzymes
- Enzyme potentially involving in inflammatory reaction by activating cytokines
- Irreversible reaction
Ionic
graphic file with name nihms-1649935-t0011.jpg
- Fast and mild reaction
- Reversible reaction with self-healing properties
- Relatively low stability
- Possibly disrupt the crosslinking by ion bleaching
Hydrogen bond
graphic file with name nihms-1649935-t0012.jpg
- Fast and mild reaction
- Reversible reaction with self-healing properties
- Relatively low stability
- Require multiple multivalent hydrogen bond to form hydrogel
Hydrophobic
graphic file with name nihms-1649935-t0013.jpg
- Reversible reaction with self-healing properties
- Can form a fixed geometry using a host-guest interaction
- Relatively low stability
- Potentially form a brittle network by pushing water from hydrogel network