Skip to main content
. 2021 Jan 26;21(3):808. doi: 10.3390/s21030808

Table 3.

Overview of the analyzed devices. The * indicates commercial availability. Power indicates the maximum assistive torque [Nm]. Listed DoFs are both actuated (A-DoF), counted unilaterally (#), and non-actuated (N-DoF). Corresponding humans joint DoFs are flexion-extension (α) and adduction-abduction (β). Sensors and control data are reported only where available.

Device Name f Assisted Task(s) Actuation Power A-DoF (#) N-DoF Sensors Control
SPEXOR * [15] 6 Static forward bending
Load lifting
Repetitive lifting
Passive 25 Nm α-Hip
α-L5-S1
(2)
Laevo * [18] 6 Static forward bending
Load lifting
Load carrying
Precision manual assembly
Passive α-Hip (1)
HAL * [19] 2 Stoop load lifting
Load lifting
Active 30 Nm α-Hip (1) EMG Angle sensors Hybrid EMG + Inclination (CVC + CAC)
BackX AC * [20] 1 Precision manual assembly Passive α-Hip (1)
Robo-Mate [21] 1 Load lifting Active 40 Nm α-Hip (1) EMG IMU EMG threshold; Inclination angle Hybrid EMG + IMU
APO [22] 1 Load lifting Hybrid 35 Nm α-Hip (1) β-Hip Joint encoders α-Hip-dependent torque profile
Active industrial exo’ [23] 1 Load lifting
Dynamic load handling
Active 40 Nm α-Hip (1) Inclination sensor Torque sin(αHip)
MeBot-EXO [24] 1 Static forward bending
Semi-squat lifting
Active 160 Nm α-Hip (1) KinematicsInteraction force α˙-Hip torque control w/interaction force minim.
Lower-limbexoskeleton’ [17] 1 Squat load lifting
Load carrying
Active 76 Nm α-Hip
α-Knee
(2) α-Ankle
β-Ankle
Torque sensors
Joint encoders GRF sensors
(Human torque amplification (estimated by Kalman Filter)
Lifting Assist Device (LAD)’ [16] 1 Load lifting Hybrid α-Hip
α-L5-S1
(2) β-Hip
β-L5-S1
IMU Potentiometers Pre-defined force profiles (State machine)
Passive spine exoskeleton’ [25] 1 Dynamic bending
Static forward bending
Passive 30 Nm α-Hip (1)
Lower extremity exoskeleton’ [26] 1 Load lifting Passive α-Hip (1)

Abbreviations: DoF, Degree of Freedom; EMG, ElectroMyoGraphy; IMU, Inertial Measurement Unit; GRF, Ground Reaction Force; L5-S1, lumbo-sacral joint.