Skip to main content
. 2021 Feb 10;19(2):e06392. doi: 10.2903/j.efsa.2021.6392

Table E.7.

Residue definition for enforcement and risk assessment in plant commodities of substances included in CAG‐NCN

Substance Residue definition for enforcement applied to occurrence data collected during the reference period Residue definition for risk assessment (plant commodities) Conversion factor Comment
Acephate Acephate Acephate Methamidophos is monitored separately
Aldicarb Aldicarb (sum of aldicarb, its sulfoxide and its sulfone, expressed as aldicarb) Aldicarb (sum of aldicarb, its sulfoxide and its sulfone, expressed as aldicarb) EFSA scientific opinion 2006
Azinphos‐ethyl Azinphos‐ethyl Not available Not available The residue following application of azinphos‐ethyl consisted partly of the P = 0 metabolite presumably owing to its higher chemical stability. After 14 days approximately 10% of the residue could be determined by TLC and GLC as the P = 0 analogue.a
Azinphos‐methyl Azinphos‐methyl Azinphos‐methyl

Provisional, apples and pears only.

EFSA reasoned opinion 2014

Benfuracarb Sum of carbofuran (including any carbofuran generated from carbosulfan, benfuracarb or furathiocarb) and 3‐OH carbofuran expressed as carbofuran Sum of carbofuran and 3‐hydroxy carbofuran, both free and conjugated expressed as carbofuran Not available EFSA conclusion 2009
Cadusafos Cadusafos Cadusafos EFSA conclusion 2009
Carbaryl Carbaryl Sum of carbaryl, 4‐hydroxycarbaryl and 5‐hydroxycarbaryl expressed as carbaryl Available data not sufficient EFSA conclusion 2006
Carbofuran Sum of carbofuran (including any carbofuran generated from carbosulfan, benfuracarb or furathiocarb) and 3‐OH carbofuran expressed as carbofuran Sum of carbofuran and 3‐hydroxy carbofuran, both free and conjugated expressed as carbofuran Not available EFSA conclusion 2009
Carbosulfan Carbofuran (sum of carbofuran (including any carbofuran generated from carbosulfan, benfuracarb or furathiocarb) and 3‐OH carbofuran expressed as carbofuran) Sum of carbofuran and 3‐hydroxy carbofuran, both free and conjugated expressed as carbofuran Not available EFSA conclusion 2009
Chlorfenvinphos Chlorfenvinphos Chlorfenvinphos, sum of (E)‐ and (Z)‐ isomers JMPR, 1996b
Chlorpyrifos Chlorpyrifos RD‐risk assessment 1:
  • Raw commodities: chlorpyrifos

  • Processed commodities: sum of chlorpyrifos and its desethyl metabolite, expressed as chlorpyrifos (tentative)

EFSA MRL review 2017

RD‐risk assessment 2 (not relevant):
  • All crops: sum of 3,5,6‐trichloropyridinol (3,5,6‐ TCP) and its conjugates, expressed as 3,5,6‐TCP
Chlorpyrifos‐methyl Chlorpyrifos‐methyl RD‐risk assessment 1:
  • Fruit crops, root crops and pulses/oilseeds: chlorpyrifos‐methyl

  • Processed commodities: sum of chlorpyrifos‐methyl and desmethyl chlorpyrifos‐methyl, expressed as chlorpyrifos‐methyl (tentative)

EFSA MRL review 2017

RD‐risk assessment 2 (not relevant):
  • All crops: sum of 3,5,6‐trichloropyridinol (3,5,6‐ TCP) and its conjugates, expressed as 3,5,6‐TCP
Chlorpyrifos‐methyl Cereals only: sum of chlorpyrifos‐methyl and desmethyl chlorpyrifos‐methyl, expressed as chlorpyrifos‐methyl Cereals only: sum of chlorpyrifos‐methyl and desmethyl chlorpyrifos‐methyl, expressed as chlorpyrifos‐methyl (tentative) EFSA MRL review 2017
Diazinon Diazinon
  • Raw commodities: Diazinon

  • Processed commodities: sum of diazinon and desethyl diazinon

EFSA conclusion 2006
Dichlorvos Dichlorvos Not available Not available EFSA conclusion 2006: Not sufficient information to derive a RD
Dimethoate Dimethoate Dimethoate

EFSA conclusion 2018

Omethoate monitored separately

Dimethoate Sum of dimethoate and omethoate expressed as dimethoate See Dimethoate and Omethoate
Ethephon Ethephon Ethephon
  • Modification of existing MRL for ethephon in persimmons (EFSA reasoned opinion 2017)

  • EFSA MRL review 2009

Ethion Ethion Ethion JMPR, 1994c
Ethoprophos Ethoprophos

Residue definition in primary crops: ethoprophos and M5, expressed as ethoprophos

Residue definition in rotational crops: ethoprophos, EPPA and M5, expressed as ethoprophos

Not available

EFSA conclusion 2018

M5: Ethyl‐phosphate, O‐ethyl phosphoric acid

EPPA: (M31), M1M, M1, O‐ethyl Spropyl phosphorothioate

Fenamiphos Sum of fenamiphos and its sulfoxide and sulfone expressed as fenamiphos Sum of fenamiphos and its sulfoxide and sulfone expressed as fenamiphos EFSA conclusion 2019
Fenitrothion Fenitrothion Fenitrothion (Note: the toxicological relevance of desmethylfenitrothion and dimethylphosphorothioic acid is unknown. Therefore, this definition could be reconsidered in the future) EFSA conclusion 2006
Fenthion Sum of fenthion and its oxygen analogue, their sulfoxides and sulfone expressed as fenthion Sum of fenthion, its oxon and their sulfoxides and sulfones, expressed as fenthion JMPR, 1995, p. 109d
Fonofos Fonofos Not available Not available
Formetanate Sum of formetanate and its salts expressed as formetanate (hydrochloride) Formetanate Sum of formetanate and its salts expressed as formetanate (hydrochloride) EFSA MRL review 2010
Fosthiazate Fosthiazate Not available Not available
Malathion Malathion (sum of malathion and malaoxon expressed as malathion) Malathion and its metabolites malaoxon, desmethyl‐malathion, malathion monocarboxylic acid and malathion dicarboxcylic acid expressed as malathion toxic equivalents Pending, further consideration necessary EFSA conclusion 2009
Methamidophos Methamidophos Methamidophos Scientific support for preparing an EU position in the 44th Session of the Codex Committee on Pesticide Residues (CCPR) (EFSA scientific report 2012)
Methidathion Methidathion Methidathion Consumer safety assessment of the EU MRLs established for methidathion (EFSA reasoned opinion 2010)
Methiocarb Sum of methiocarb and methiocarb sulfoxide and sulfone, expressed as methiocarb Provisionally proposed as: 1) Methiocarb 2) M01 (a potency factor of 3 can be established to consider the sum of parent methiocarb and M01, if any genotoxicity potential can be ruled out for M01) 3) Sum of M03, M04 and M05, free and conjugated. Not available

EFSA conclusion 2018

M01: methiocarb sulfoxide

M03: methiocarb phenol

M04: methiocarb sulfoxide phenol

M05: methiocarb sulfone phenol

Methomyl Methomyl Methomyl (for fruit crops only; tentative for other crops) EFSA MRL review 2015
Methomyl Sum of methomyl and thiodicarb expressed as methomyl (applicable until May 2017) See methomyl and thiodicarb
Monocrotophos Monocrotophos Not available Not available New studies were carried out on the metabolism of monocrotophos in plants and its degradation in soil. The degradation products previously found were O‐desmethylmonocrotophos, dimethyl phosphate and N‐hydroxymethylmonocrotophos. Maize grains and fodder were analysed for trimethyl phosphate at various intervals after treatment but residues of this compound were not detectable. Residues of Nhydroxymethyl‐monocrotophos, which occurs as a glycoside in crops, were determined in maize and sugar cane. Residues in the edible parts of crops were not detectable but were present in foliage and fodder (FAO, 1991).e
Omethoate Sum of dimethoate and omethoate expressed as dimethoate See Dimethoate and Omethoate
Omethoate Omethoate Omethoate EFSA conclusion 2018
Oxamyl Oxamyl Oxamyl EFSA MRL review 2010
Oxydemeton‐methyl Sum of oxydemeton‐methyl and demeton‐S‐methylsulfone expressed as oxydemeton‐methyl Sum of oxydemeton‐methyl, demeton‐S‐methylsulfon (M01), metabolite M06 and metabolite M07 expressed as oxydemeton‐methyl Not available EFSA conclusions 2006
Parathion Parathion Not available Not available In a plant metabolism study parathion was the major component of the residue (62% of the 14C) in wheat grain harvested 7 days after the second application of ring‐labelled parathion to the plant. Paraoxon was not detected in the grain and 4‐nitrophenol comprised 7.4% of the 14C. Parathion, paraoxon and 4‐nitrophenol accounted for 37%, 1.2% and 13% of the 14C in the wheat straw, respectively. In the straw and grain 72% and 82%, respectively, of the 14C was extractable with aqueous methanol (JMPR, 1995).d
Parathion‐methyl Sum of Parathion‐methyl and paraoxon‐methyl expressed as Parathion‐methyl Not available Not available
Phenthoate Phenthoate Not available Not available Info on metabolism in plants and animal commodities in FAO, 1980f
Phosalone Phosalone Phosalone and oxophosalone Data not sufficient to derive a CF EFSA conclusion 2006
Phosmet Phosmet Phosmet (phosmet and phosmet oxon expressed as phosmet) Not available

EFSA conclusion 2011

Residue definition for RA is provisional, pending the results study aimed to compare the relative potency of phosmet oxon and parent phosmet

Phosmet Phosmet (phosmet and phosmet oxon expressed as phosmet) Phosmet (phosmet and phosmet oxon expressed as phosmet)

EFSA conclusion 2011

Residue definition for RA is provisional, pending the results study aimed to compare the relative potency of phosmet oxon and parent phosmet

Phoxim Phoxim Not available Not available Only info found on residues (FAO, 1984)g
Pirimicarb Pirimicarb Pirimicarb (sum of pirimicarb, desmethyl pirimicarb and desmethyl formamido pirimicarb, expressed as pirimicarb) 1.3 for fruits and spices (fruits and berries), 1.4 for fruiting vegetables, spices (seeds) and for pulses and oilseeds, 1.7 for stem vegetables and fresh legume vegetables, 1 for root and tuber vegetables, 2.8 for lettuces, brassica and herbs. EFSA MRL review 2014
Pirimicarb Pirimicarb (sum of Pirimicarb and Desmethyl pirimicarb expressed as Pirimicarb) Pirimicarb (sum of pirimicarb, desmethyl pirimicarb and desmethyl formamido pirimicarb, expressed as pirimicarb) Not available
Pirimiphos‐methyl Pirimiphos‐methyl Pirimiphos‐methyl EFSA MRL review 2015
Profenofos Profenofos Profenofos Scientific support for preparing an EU position in the 44th Session of the Codex Committee on Pesticide Residues (CCPR) (EFSA scientific report 2012)
Pyrazophos Pyrazophos Not available Not available
Thiodicarb Methomyl and Thiodicarb (sum of methomyl and thiodicarb expressed as methomyl) See methomyl and thodicarb EFSA conclusion 2006
Thiodicarb Thiodicarb Thiodicarb EFSA conclusion 2006
Tolclofos‐methyl Tolclofos‐methyl
  • For leafy crops (lettuce) and soil treatment: tolclofos‐methyl and the metabolites TM‐CH2OH conjugate and metabolite ph‐CH3-conjugate expressed as tolclofos‐methyl (preliminary pending on toxicological information and/or field trials).

  • For root and tuber (potato): tolclofos‐methyl and metabolite DM‐TM-CH2OH expressed as tolclofos‐methyl.

  • For processing: tolclofos‐methyl and TM‐DM (provisional).

Not available EFSA conclusion 2018
Triazophos Triazophos Triazophos Scientific support for preparing an EU position in the 46th Session of the Codex Committee on Pesticide Residues (CCPR) (EFSA scientific report 2014).
Trichlorfon Trichlorfon Not available Not available Additional info on residues (FAO, 1971)h