Table 3:
Multimodal imaging, metabolites, and cognition in schizophrenia
Author | n (control/ patient) | Illness stage | Medication status | Cognitive domain (all are fMRI tasks) | Region | Tesla | Metabolite | Acquisition | MRS Sequence | TE (ms) | Reference | Metabolite level group difference | Associations between metabolites and fMRI |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
(Fusar-Poli et al., 2011) | 17/24 | ARMS | naïve | Verbal fluency task | ACC, left hippocampus and left thalamus | 3 | Glu | SV | PRESS | 30 | W | ↓Glu in thalamus | Thalamic Glu levels were negatively associated with activation in the right DLPFC and left orbitofrontal cortex, but positively associated with activation in the right hippocampus and the bilateral temporal cortex in ARMS; opposite pattern seen in HC. |
(Valli et al., 2011) | 14/22 | ARMS | naïve | Verbal episodic memory task | ACC, medial temporal cortex, and thalamus | 3 | Glu | SV | PRESS | 30 | W | Not reported | Medial temporal Glu was positively associated with medial temporal activation during the episodic memory task in HC; opposite pattern seen in ARMS. |
(Hutcheson et al., 2012) | 28/28 | Chronic | Medicated | Memory retrieval | Left hippocampus | 3 | Glx | SV | PRESS | 80 | Cr | - | Hippocampal Glx was positively correlated with the left IFG BOLD response during memory retrieval in HC, but not SZ |
(Falkenberg et al., 2014) | 17/17 | Chronic | Medicated | Bergen dichotic listening task | dorsal ACC | 3 | Glu | SV | PRESS | 35 | Cr | ↓Glu | Positive correlations between Glu and BOLD in inferior parietal in SZ; opposite pattern in HC. |
(Allen et al., 2015) | 27/33 | UHR | mixed | Verbal fluency task | Left thalamus | 3 | Glu | SV | PRESS | 30 | W | - | UHR subjects with poor functional outcome showed negative relationship between thalamic glutamate levels and prefrontal striatal activation, pattern not seen in those with good functioning and HC |
(Overbeek et al., 2019) | 21/17 | FEP | Medicated | RBANS, Stroop test | ACC | 7 | Glu, Gln, GABA | SV | STEAM | 5 | W | ↓Glu | ACC GABA was negatively correlated with Stroop effect reaction time. In FEP, the relationship between ACC Glu and BOLD response in the DMN was opposite to HC |
(White et al., 2015) | 19/22 | Chronic | Medicated | Prediction error task | SN | 3 | Glx | SV | PRESS | 80 | Cr | ↑Glx | In HC, but not in SZ, prediction error BOLD response was positively associated with SN Glx |
(Cadena et al., 2018) | 20/22 | Chronic | Un-medicated | Stroop task | ACC | 3 | Glx | SV | PRESS | 80 | Cr | - | In SZ, the relationship between ACC Glx and BOLD in regions of the salience network and posterior DMN was opposite to HC |
↑ Metabolite level is higher in patients than controls; ↓ Metabolite level is lower in patients than controls; - no group differences in metabolite levels
Abbreviations:
n: number of subjects; ARMS: at risk mental state; FEP: first episode psychosis patients; SZ: patients with schizophrenia; UHR: ultra high risk patients; HC: healthy controls
TE: Echo Time; SV: single voxel spectroscopy; PRESS: Point Resolved Spectroscopy; STEAM: STimulated Echo Acquisition Mode; W: water; Cr: creatine; Glu: glutamate; Gln: glutamine; Glx: glutamate+ glutamine; GABA: γ-aminobutyric acid
ACC: anterior cingulate cortex; BOLD: blood oxygen level dependent signal; DLPFC: dorsolateral prefrontal cortex; DMN: default mode network; SN: substantia nigra