Table 2.
Principles | Welfare criteria | Welfare indicators | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
Caretaker level | Herd level | Animal level | ||
Good health | Absence of injuries | Camel injury observed | Animals injured Type of injury |
Injury Scar Swollen Joint Lameness |
Absence of disease | Camel disease observed Camel health check Medical treatments |
Sick animals Type of disease |
Disease Hair coat conditions Ectoparasites Discharge Diarrhea Abnormal udder Abnormal breathing Coughing |
|
Absence of pain and pain induced by management procedures | Caretaker's ability to identify pain | Animals in pain Animals with a nose-ring, cauterizations and wounds from halters or similar |
Evident pain | |
Appropriate behavior | Expression of social behavior | Social behavior Aggressive behavior |
Social interaction | |
Expression of other behavior | Camel behavioral problems observed | Stereotypies Other abnormal behaviors |
Stereotypies Other abnormal behaviors |
|
Good human-animal relationship | Experience in camel handling | Approaching test | ||
Caretaker's skills in identifying distress | ||||
Caretaker's knowledge of animal welfare | ||||
Positive emotional state | Behavior repertoire |
The indicators were divided according to welfare criteria and source of information (Caretaker level: indicators collected through an interview of the caretakers; Herd level: indicators collected by a direct evaluation of a group of animals and their pen/box; Animal level: indicators collected by a direct evaluation of individual camels).