Skip to main content
. 2021 Feb 10;11(2):e035978. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2019-035978

Table 1.

Characteristics of included studies

Author, year Study design Population Sample size Age mean (SD) Targeted FRIDs Intervention Control Study outcomes
Blalock et al, 201028 RCT
  1. Community setting

  2. Age ≥65 years

  3. Speak, read English

  4. ≥4 prescription medications; ≥1 high falls-risk medication

  5. ≥1 fall not attributable to syncope within previous year

186 (93 I/93 C) 74.8 (6.9) Benzodiazepines, antidepressants, anticonvulsants, sedative hypnotics, opioid analgesics, antipsychotics and skeletal muscle relaxants
  1. Pharmacist medication review

  2. Physician coordinated medication changes

  3. Fall brochure, home safety checklist

  • Fall brochure, home safety checklist

  1. Rate of falls

  2. Incidence of falls

Campbell et al, 199931 RCT
  1. Community setting

  2. Age ≥65 years

  3. Using benzodiazepine, other hypnotic, antidepressant or major tranquilliser

  4. Ambulatory

  5. No physiotherapy

  6. General practitioner thought psychotropic medication withdrawal beneficial

93
Arm 1: 24 (I)
Arm 2: 24 (I)
Arm 3: 21 (C)*
Arm 4: 24 (C)*
74.7 (7.2) Psychotropic medications (eg, benzodiazepines, hypnotics, antidepressants, tranquillisers) Arm 1
  1. Withdrawal of psychotropic medication over 14 weeks

  2. Placebo substitution

  3. Home exercise programme


Arm 2
  1. Psychotropic medication withdrawal

  2. Placebo substitution

  3. No home exercise programme

Arm 3
  1. No change in psychotropic medication

  2. Home exercise programme


Arm 4
  1. No change in psychotropic medication

  2. No exercise programme

  1. Rate of falls

  2. Incidence of falls

Mott et al, 201624 Cluster RCT
  1. Community setting

  2. Age ≥65 years

  3. English speaking

  4. Fall in last 12 months/fear of falling

  5. Workshop participation

  6. Capable of consent

80 (39 I/41 C) 75.6 (6.5) Neuroleptics, benzodiazepines, antidepressants, sedative-hypnotics, antihypertensives, cyclobenzaprine, carisoprodol, sedating antihistamines, oxybutynin, carbamazepine, methocarbamol, prochlorperazine, benztropine, trihexiphenidyl
  1. FRID pharmacist review

  2. Medication-related action plan developed by pharmacist for patient

  3. Pharmacist follow-up

  4. Patient given pamphlet describing the role of medications in falls and monthly falls calendars

Medications in falls pamphlet
  1. Rate of falls

  2. Incidence of falls

Patterson et al, 201025 Cluster RCT
  1. Nursing home setting with ≥30 beds; not exclusive care of terminally ill

  2. Age ≥65 years

334 (173 I/161 C) 82.7 (8.4) Psychoactive medications (ie, hypnotics, anxiolytics, antipsychotics)
  1. Monthly medication review via pharmacist for appropriateness

  2. Nurse and prescriber collaboration to improve medications

Usual care
  1. Rate of falls

Boyé et al, 201732 RCT
  1. Acute care emergency department setting; attended due to fall incident

  2. Age ≥65

  3. ≥1 FRID for ≥2 weeks prior to the fall

  4. MMSE ≥21/30

  5. Ambulates independently

  6. Community dwelling

  7. Informed consent by patient

612 (319 I/293 C) 80.2 (7.3) Anxiolytics/hypnotics, antidepressants, neuroleptics, antihypertensives, antiarrhythmics, NSAIDs, H2 receptor antagonists, opioids, sympathomimetics, antihistaminics, diuretics
  1. Investigator conducted FRID assessment, proposed changes

  2. Changes discussed with geriatrician and general practitioner/prescribing doctor

  3. If consensus, FRID discontinued, reduced dosage, substituted for potentially safer option

Usual care
  1. Rate of falls

  2. Incidence of falls

*Arm 3 and arm 4 classified as controls due to lack of FRID withdrawal in these arms of the factorial design.

C, control; FRID, fall-risk increasing drug; I, intervention; MMSE, Mini-Mental State Examination; NSAIDs, non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs; RCT, randomised controlled trial.