Table 2.
Type of intervention | Author, year | Intervention | Control | Medication | Intensity | Depression measure | Results | Included in meta-analysis |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Complementary and alternative therapy (N = 5) | Lee et al., 2016 | Acupuncture | Sham group | No antipsychotic medication | 3d/wk*3wk | K-BDI | Favoring intervention | Yes |
Man et al., 2014 | Direct cranial electro-acupuncture stimulation | Body electro-acupuncture | SSRIs | 3d/wk*4wk | HRSD | Favoring intervention | Yes | |
Särkämö et al., 2008 | Music listening | Language listening | 40.7% of participants received antidepressants (citalopram or mirtazapine) | 1h/d*2m | POMS | Favoring intervention | Yes | |
Raglio et al., 2017 | Relational Active Music Therapy (RAMT) | Standard care | No psychotropic medications | 05h/d*20ses weekly | HADS-D | Favoring intervention | Yes | |
Menghan et al., 2017 | Tioshen Kaiqiao acupuncture | Meds+Body acupuncture | No antidepressants | 0.3–0.5h/d, 3d/wk*12wk | HRSD | No difference | Yes | |
Exercise (N = 6) | Lai et al., 2006 | Strength, balance, endurance, and upper extremity function | Usual care | 24.5% of Participants received antidepressants | 3d/wk*12wk for 36 ses (3months) | GDS | Favoring intervention | Yes |
Mead et al., 2007 | Mixed endurance & resistance training | Relaxation attention control | Not reported | 1.25h/d, 3d/wk*12wk | HADS-D | No difference | No (insufficient data) | |
Zedlitz et al., 2012 | Walking on a treadmill, strength training, homework assignments | Cognitive therapy | Not reported | 12wk | HADS-D | Favoring intervention | Yes | |
Vahlberg et al., 2017 | Progressive resistance and balance | Usual care | Not reported | 1h and 15min/d 2d/wk*12wk | GDS-20 | No difference | Yes | |
Rowe et al., 2017 | Robotic assistance (high assistance) | Robotic assistance (low assistance) | Not reported | 1h/d, 3d/wk*12wk | GDS | No difference | Yes | |
Topcuoglu et al., 2015 | Upper extremity aerobic exercise | Standard treatment | Not reported | 0.5h/d, 5d/wk*16wk | BDI | Favoring intervention | No (insufficient data) | |
Psychosocial therapy (N = 6) | Mitchell et al., 2009 | Psychosocial behavioral intervention | Usual care | Received antidepressants | 9 ses (8wk) | HRSD | Favoring intervention | No (publication bias) |
Watkins et al., 2009 | Motivational interviewing | Usual care | Not reported | 0.5–1h/ses, 4ses | GHQ-28, Yale | Favoring intervention | No (insufficient data) | |
Aben et al., 2013 | Memory self-efficacy training program | Attention control | Not reported | 1h/ses, 2d/wk, 9ses | CES-D | No difference | Yes | |
Visser et al., 2016 | Problem-solving therapy | Standard rehabilitation | 19.3% of Participants received antidepressants | 1.5h/wk, 8ses | CES-D | No difference | No (publication bias) | |
Kirkness et al., 2017 | Brief psychosocial intervention | Usual care | 44.4% of participants received antidepressants | Tel:10–80min, In-person: 26–38min | GDS, HRSD | Favoring intervention | Yes | |
Kootker et al., 2017 | Augmented cognitive behavioral therapy | Usual care | No antidepressants | 13–16ses for 4m | HADS-D | No difference | No (insufficient data) | |
Multifactorial therapy (N = 3) | Ihle-Hansen et al., 2014 | Multifactorial risk factor intervention program | Usual care | Not reported | Unclear | HADS-D | Favoring intervention | Yes |
Rochette et al., 2013 | We Call: a multimodal (telephone, Internet, paper) support intervention | You Call: standard care whereby contact with medical staff is initiated by patients | Not reported | Unclear | BDI | No difference | Yes | |
Wong et al., 2015 | Holistic care Interventions administered by a multidisciplinary team | Physical training program | Not reported | 4 wk | CES-D | Favoring intervention | No (insufficient data) | |
Cranial stimulation (N = 2) | Valiengo et al., 2017 | Transcranial direct current stimulation | Sham control | No antidepressants | 12–30min/ses for 6 wk | HRSD | Favoring intervention | No (insufficient data) |
Gu et al., 2017 | Repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation | Sham control | No antidepressants | 70mm/d 5d/wk*2wk | BDI | Favoring intervention | No (publication bias) |
(K-)BDI: (Korean version) of the Beck Depression Inventory, HRSD: The 17-item Hamilton Rating Scale for Depression, POMS: The Profile of Mood States, HADS-D: The Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale-Depression Subscore, GDS: The 15-item Geriatric Depression Scale, GHQ-28: 28-Item General Health Questionnaire, Yale: Yale Depression Screen, CES-D: The Center of Epidemiological Studies–Depression Scale, MES: The Bech–Rafaelsen Melancholia Scale