Randomized controlled trials |
Fischer et al. (2006) |
18 women
randomized to buprenorphine group (n=9) or methadone (n=9)
mean age of buprenorphine group: 26.2yo
mean EGA at enrollment of buprenorphine group: 24.0wk
study duration: 18.5wk
Addiction Clinic at Medical University of Vienna, Vienna, Austria
|
|
|
14.0 |
Not reported |
|
Cohort studies |
Lo-Ciganic et al. (2019) |
2363 women
mean age: 27.8yo
95% white
categorized into early initiators w/ persistently high adherence (EIwPHA, n=747), moderate-to-high adherence (EIwMtHA, n=357), declining adherence over time (EIwDA, n=248), early discharge before T3 (EIwED, n=393), late initiators w/ mod-to-high adherence (LIwMtHA, n=318), late initiators w/ low-to-mod adherence (LIwLtMA, n=298)
Pennsylvania Medicaid
|
|
During first trimester (T1):
EIwPHA: 17.4
EIwMtHA: 13.3
EIwDA: 16.6
EIwED: 12.6
Overall during pregnancy:
EIwPHA: 17.6
EIwMtHA: 15.7
EIwDA: 16.5
EIwED: 15.5
LIwMtHA: 15.3
LIwLtMA: 14.7
|
Not reported |
Not reported, though the study did follow women through 12 weeks postpartum |
not reported from pregnancy to postpartum
-
from T1 to pregnancy overall:
EIwPHA: +0.2 mg/day
EIwMtHA: +2.4 mg/day
EIwDA: −0.1 mg/day
EIwED: +2.9 mg/day
from T1 to overall for all groups with >1 data point: +1.2 mg/day
|
Brogly et al. (2018) |
59 women
mean age: 28yo
80.5% white
divided into group that had initiated treatment prior to conception (PTC, n=20) and group that initiated prenatally (PN, n=39)
Project RESPECT clinic (2015–16), Boston Medical Center
|
|
At pregnancy initiation:
|
14.7 |
Not reported |
|
Coker et al. (2018) |
64 women
mean age: 28.4yo
mean EGA at enrollment: 20.88wk
categorized as adherent (n=41), moderately adherent (n=8), nonadherent (n=15)
Women’s Mental Health Program at Univ of Arkansas
|
|
Overall at last visit: 14.98
moderately adherent: 14
nonadherent: 10
|
See other 2 columns |
Adherent at last visit: 17 |
Overall for adherent: +7 mg/day |
O’Connor et al. (2018) |
190 women
95% Caucasian
divided into still in treatment at 6 mos postpartum (S6, n=151), 12 mos postpartum (S12, n=135) and not in treatment at 6 mos postpartum (N6, n=39), 12 mos postpartum (N12, n=55)
rural Maine
|
|
Not reported prior to delivery |
S6: 15.1
N6: 14.0
S12: 15.3
N12: 14.3
|
Not reported, though changes to postpartum reported in next column |
S6:
51.3% at same dose as at delivery
15.9% increase (mean: +4.94 mg/day)
32.5% decrease (mean: −4.55 mg/day)
S12:
36.3% on same dose as delivery
15.6% increase (mean: +4.31 mg/day)
48.1% decrease (mean: −5.15 mg/day)
|
Welle-Strand et al. (2015) |
123 women: 43 on buprenorphine, 80 on methadone
divided into group that tapered dose >50% (TD50, n=7), group that tapered dose 11–50% (TD11, n=12), group that was stable or had increased dose (SoID, n=24)
Norway
|
Buprenorphine |
At pregnancy determination:
TD50: 14.6
TD11: 17.8
SoID: 15.6
Lowest dose during pregnancy:
TD50: 1.7
TD11: 11.4
SoID: 12.8
|
TD50: 2.3
TD11: 12.3
SoID: 17.8
|
Not reported |
From pregnancy determination to delivery:
TD50: −12.3 mg/day
TD11: −5.5 mg/day
SoID: +2.2 mg/day
|
Simmat-Durand et al. (2009) |
|
|
Overall during “early pregnancy”: 6.9
|
Overall: 5.4
|
Not reported |
not reported from pregnancy to postpartum
from “early pregnancy” to delivery: −1.5 mg/day
40% of participants had decreased dose during pregnancy, while 34% maintained same dose
|
Kahila et al. (2007) |
67 women
mean age: 24.6yo
categorized into 3 groups based on perceived compliance: compliant (A, n=9), non-compliant (B, n=37), maintenance (C, n=21)
Finland
|
once daily
sublingual buprenorphine
|
At start (<18 wk estimated gestational age, EGA):At 18wk EGA:At 24wk EGA:At 30wk EGA:At 36wk EGA:
|
|
Not reported |
|
Case control studies |
Concheiro et al. (2010) |
5 women
mean age 30.6yo
mean EGA at admission: 23.0
100% African American
Center for Addiction and Pregnancy Johns Hopkins, Baltimore, MD
|
|
|
18.4 |
Not reported |
not reported from pregnancy to postpartum
overall to delivery: +3.2 mg/day
from T3 to last month: +1.8 mg/day
|
Observational studies |
Bastian et al. (2017) |
13 women
evaluated in T2 (PK-2, n=7), T3 (PK-3, n=11), and postpartum (PK-P, n=10)
-
mean age of participants:
PK-2: 27.3yo
PK-3: 27.9yo
PK-P: 28.6yo
Magee-Women’s Hospital, Pittsburgh, PA
|
|
|
Not reported |
|
|
Caritis et al. (2017) |
14 women
evaluated in T2 (n=7), T3 (n=11) and postpartum (PP, n=10)
-
mean age of participants:
T2:27yo
T3: 28yo
PP:29yo
Magee-Womens Hospital Pregnancy Recovery Center (PRC)
|
twice daily
sublingual buprenorphine
|
|
Not reported |
|
|
Concheiro et al. (2011) |
3 women completed through 2 months postpartum (PP)
mean age: 30yo
100% black
Center for Addiction and Pregnancy Johns Hopkins, Baltimore, MD
|
|
collected during week 28 or 29 and week 34 of gestation
overall: 15.7
during gestational wk 28/29: 14.6
mean during gestational wk 34: 16.6
|
Not reported |
|
|
Ilett et al. (2011) |
|
|
Not reported |
Not reported |
|
Not reported |
Lacroix et al. (2011) |
|
|
|
Not reported |
Not reported |
|
O’Connor et al. (2011) |
|
Buprenorphine |
|
13.3 |
Not reported |
|
Kacinko et al. (2009) |
9 women
mean age: 30.0yo
mean EGA at admission: 22.8wk
8 African-American, 1 white
Center for Addiction and Pregnancy Johns Hopkins, Baltimore, MD
|
|
overall: 15.4
T2: 12.8
T3: 15.8
|
18.6 |
17.4 |
|
Lindelman et al. (2009) |
|
|
|
Not reported |
measured at 5–8 days postpartum (except in 1 case at 270 days) at a median 6 days, mean 43.7 days
median dose (mg/kg/day) : 0.29
|
|
Kacinko et al. (2008) |
|
|
overall: 15.0
in T3: 16.1
|
18.7 |
Not reported |
not reported from pregnancy to postpartum
from start to T3: +1.1 mg/day
from start to delivery: +3.7 mg/day
|
Goodwin et al. (2007) |
9 women
mean age: 30yo
8 African-American, 1 white
Center for Addiction and Pregnancy, Johns Hopkins, Baltimore, MD
|
once daily
sublingual buprenorphine
|
Initial: 8.2 |
18.7 |
Not reported, though does note that participants were maintained “up to 10 wks after delivery” |
|
Lacroix et al. (2004) |
34 women
mean age: 31yo
mean EGA: 142d
|
|
|
Not reported |
Not reported |
|
Johnson et al. (2001) |
|
|
Throughout pregnancy: 9.3 |
9.3 |
After delivery: women were maintained on buprenorphi ne ×21 days, then tapered off either with 21-day inpatient or 10-wk outpatient schedule |
From pregnancy to 13wks postpartum: −9.3 mg/day (due to study design—postpartum taper) |
Fischer et al. (2000) |
15 women
mean age: 24.0yo
mean EGA at enrollment: 27.9wk
drug addiction outpatient clinic, Department of General Psychiatry, Univ of Vienna, Vienna, Austria
|
|
At induction: 8.4 |
7.4 |
Not reported |
|
Fischer et al. (1998) |
|
|
8.1 |
8.1 |
Not reported |
|
Case report/series |
Ross. (2004) |
1 woman
24yo primigravida
Access Drug and Alcohol Clinic, Birralee Maternity Services, Box Hill Hospital, Victoria, Australia
|
Buprenorphine |
During “later stage of pregnancy, up to day of induction”: 34 |
34 |
Not reported |
Not reported, though paper does insinuate that patient’s dose increased during pregnancy |
Schindler et al. (2003) |
|
|
9 |
9 |
Not reported |
From conception to delivery: 0 mg/day |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|