Skip to main content
. 2020 Dec 9;13(2):2031–2048. doi: 10.18632/aging.202199

Table 2. Subgroup analysis for overall survival.

Subgroups No. of Studies HR 95% CI I2
Tumor Stage
I-IV 7 3.37 2.22-5.12 55.2%
I-II 12 2.95 2.11-4.12 28.0%
III-IV 15 2.01 1.58-2.57 89.0%
Sampling Time
Baseline 30 2.42 1.95-3.01 88.4%
Post-operative 4 4.84 2.38-9.85 0.0%
Detection Marker
K-ras 20 3.31 2.53-4.34 48.6%
K-ras G12V 7 2.03 1.51-2.74 49.3%
K-ras G12D 4 1.77 1.22-2.58 55.6%
ERBB2 exon17 1 1.73 1.10-2.72 0.0%
ctDNA level 4 1.40 1.07-1.83 87.2%
Detection Method
PCR 9 3.77 1.77-8.02 81.6%
ddPCR 17 2.36 1.90-2.94 62.3%
NGS 5 2.14 1.17-3.91 85.4%
Safe-Sequencing System 2 4.35 1.67-11.32 0.0%
PCR&NGS 1 1.42 1.19-1.69 0.0%
ctDNA(+) Rate
<40% 19 3.08 2.22-4.28 74.1%
>40% 15 2.01 1.58-2.55 84.6%
Sample Origin
Plasma 30 2.60 2.08-3.26 88.6%
Serum 4 2.05 1.16-3.65 36.1%
Ethnicity
Asian 18 2.49 1.90-3.28 73.2%
Caucasian 16 2.47 1.85-3.30 85.5%
Patient Size
<50 15 3.14 2.01-4.90 60.3%
50-100 8 3.10 1.58-6.09 93.6%
>100 11 1.91 1.60-2.27 55.1%