TABLE 2.
Reporting items for root and canal morphology in research studies
| Section | Number | Checklist item | Listed on page number |
|---|---|---|---|
| Type of study | 1 | Experimental or clinical (cross-sectional or other); retrospective or prospective | |
| Ethical approval | 2 | Approval from the ethical board committee | |
| Ethnic group/population | 3 | Details on ethnic group or population | |
| Tooth type (or roots) | 4 | Tooth (teeth) type included in the study and/or roots | |
| Sample size calculation | 5 | Information on how the sample size was calculated before undertaking the research | |
| Number of teeth (and/or roots) | 6 | The number of study samples should be reported. | |
| Inclusion/Exclusion criteria | 7 | Information on how the teeth were selected – e.g. caries, resorption defects, restoration, root canal treated teeth, mature root apex, fractures, etc. Other factors related to imaging/ processing issues such as artifacts or samples loss because of chemicals (such as staining and clearing) have to be mentioned as criteria for exclusion. | |
| Age | 8 | If applicable, the age range (or groups) of the study samples or patients should be reported. | |
| Gender | 9 | If applicable, the gender of study samples should be reported. | |
| Diagnostic device specifications and technique | 10 | Radiographic machine: This includes machine type, exposure settings Kv, mA, voxel size (if applicable), FOV (if applicable), angulation techniques, etc, as well as software programs used for analysis. | |
| Other diagnostic tools (such as staining and clearing, SEM, etc): | |||
| The specifications and procedures should be mentioned in details. | |||
| For all, calibration of the machine (if applicable) should be reported. | |||
| Qualitative analysis | 11 | Such as root canal configurations, evaluation of root canal shapes. | |
| Quantitative analysis | 12 | Such as measuring volumes, areas diameters, distances, angles. | |
| How the evaluation process was performed | 13 | Such as examining the coronal/axial/sagittal sections in 3D imaging, or observing the canal bifurcations in | |
| 2D imaging under magnification, etc. | |||
| Endodontic procedures (if applicable) | 14 | Magnification, modification of the access cavity, exploration, negotiation with our without troughing and others (applicable for 2D clinical studies). | |
| Classification used | 15 | Classification used for root canal configurations (with clear definition for orifice location and intercanal communications), root anomalies, accessory canals. | |
| Calibration and reproducibility | 16 | How the examiners were calibrated. Methods for calibration must be described clearly. Intra-rater and/orinter-rater reliability tests must be mentioned. | |
| Statistical analysis (if applicable) | 17 | The type of statistical method and software used for analysis should be reported. |