TABLE 1.
Study | Task | Number of participants | MNI/Talairach | Coordinates | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Anderson et al., 2011 | Subjects were instructed, “Keep your eyes open and remain awake and try to let thoughts pass through your mind without focusing on any particular mental activity.” | 57 (100%) | MNI | −4 | −52 | 32 |
4 | −53 | 35 | ||||
−2 | 55 | −13 | ||||
2 | 55 | −13 | ||||
−49 | −62 | 34 | ||||
50 | −57 | 36 | ||||
Che et al., 2014 | Perceived social support at resting state. | 333 (100%) | MNI | 0 | −45 | 36 |
6 | 48 | −18 | ||||
−51 | −66 | 30 | ||||
48 | −63 | 39 | ||||
−6 | 54 | 45 | ||||
6 | 45 | −9 | ||||
−36 | −69 | 42 | ||||
39 | −66 | 42 | ||||
−6 | −54 | 45 | ||||
−3 | 54 | 3 | ||||
−51 | −69 | 33 | ||||
48 | −66 | 45 | ||||
Crittenden et al., 2015 | Switch between similar and dissimilar tasks, within a relatively large set of six tasks. | 18 (100%) | MNI | −30 | −36 | −6 |
33 | −36 | −9 | ||||
−21 | −42 | 9 | ||||
30 | −39 | 6 | ||||
−9 | −48 | 12 | ||||
9 | −51 | 12 | ||||
−12 | −54 | 24 | ||||
12 | −51 | 24 | ||||
−9 | 51 | −6 | ||||
9 | 48 | −3 | ||||
−39 | −75 | 33 | ||||
Luo et al., 2016 | To rest with eyes closed. | 148 (100%) | MNI | 0 | 51 | 39 |
−6 | −42 | 42 | ||||
−33 | −60 | 54 | ||||
Utevsky et al., 2014 | Three reward‐based decision tasks requiring externally focused attention and resting state. | 209 (100%) | MNI | 15 | −63 | 18 |
0 | −54 | 45 | ||||
−12 | −69 | 18 | ||||
6 | −42 | 3 | ||||
−3 | −45 | 6 | ||||
Vatansever et al., 2015 | Finger opposition paradigm with task and fixation periods versus. independent resting state. | 22 (100%) | MNI | 0 | 52 | 26 |
−6 | 52 | −2 | ||||
0 | 26 | −18 | ||||
−44 | −74 | 32 | ||||
44 | −74 | 32 | ||||
−54 | −54 | 28 | ||||
54 | −54 | 28 | ||||
−60 | −24 | −18 | ||||
60 | −24 | −18 | ||||
0 | −58 | 27 | ||||
−14 | −52 | 8 | ||||
14 | −52 | 8 | ||||
−27 | −15 | 26 | ||||
27 | −15 | 26 | ||||
−28 | −15 | −12 | ||||
28 | −15 | −12 | ||||
Doll et al., 2015 | To remain still with eyes closed and to not fall asleep during acquisition. | 26 (100%) | MNI | −6 | 53 | 1 |
−6 | 47 | −8 | ||||
6 | 47 | 7 | ||||
0 | −52 | 28 | ||||
6 | 61 | 28 | ||||
−6 | −52 | 28 | ||||
−6 | −61 | 34 | ||||
12 | −49 | 34 | ||||
12 | −67 | 34 | ||||
9 | −70 | 37 | ||||
−6 | −76 | 34 | ||||
Clemens et al., 2017 | Participants believe that they play a virtual ball tossing game with two other participants to whom they are supposedly connected via a computer, resting‐state data taken before and after game. | 89 (100%) | MNI | −6 | 28 | 32 |
50 | −14 | 26 | ||||
42 | 36 | 8 | ||||
22 | 8 | 50 | ||||
48 | 12 | 12 | ||||
4 | −62 | 18 | ||||
18 | −74 | 26 | ||||
Pletzer et al., 2015 | Four different tasks in a paper and pencil design to evaluate mathematical skills. Independent resting state. | 36 (100%) | MNI | 27 | −42 | −15 |
−24 | −45 | −15 | ||||
57 | −3 | −15 | ||||
−60 | −9 | −15 | ||||
−51 | −51 | 18 | ||||
−27 | 45 | 36 | ||||
33 | 42 | 30 | ||||
−18 | 66 | 3 | ||||
9 | 54 | −6 | ||||
39 | −15 | −6 | ||||
−42 | −57 | 21 | ||||
−18 | −6 | 21 | ||||
−6 | 57 | 3 | ||||
54 | 33 | 3 | ||||
−9 | −45 | 36 |
Lin et al., 2017 | Visual‐based attention task and then a resting‐state scan. | 14 (100%) | MNI | 0 | −53 | 26 |
−3 | 55 | 22 | ||||
−3 | 59 | −7 | ||||
−24 | 33 | −27 | ||||
30 | −33 | −27 | ||||
−52 | 69 | 26 | ||||
48 | −67 | 36 | ||||
−21 | 32 | 47 | ||||
12 | 44 | 48 | ||||
−61 | −17 | −30 | ||||
61 | −5 | −25 | ||||
Taruffi et al., 2017 | Listening to 4‐min blocks of sad and happy music (with the same tempo) with eyes closed. | 24 (100%) | MNI | −6 | 39 | −8 |
15 | 39 | −2 | ||||
0 | 45 | 31 | ||||
0 | −36 | 52 | ||||
21 | −51 | 16 | ||||
−48 | −69 | 43 | ||||
54 | −63 | 28 | ||||
48 | 12 | 25 | ||||
Stawarczyk et al., 2011 | Participants reported their conscious experiences in terms of both task‐relatedness and stimulus‐dependency while they performed the SART (Sustained Attention to Response Task). Independent resting state | 22 (100%) | MNI | 0 | 58 | −2 |
−8 | −62 | 20 | ||||
−38 | −80 | 36 | ||||
−16 | −48 | 0 | ||||
48 | 38 | 36 | ||||
−60 | −48 | 48 | ||||
2 | 58 | −2 | ||||
−2 | 70 | 20 | ||||
−2 | −50 | 22 | ||||
−44 | −72 | 48 | ||||
−64 | −22 | −26 | ||||
52 | −14 | −32 | ||||
−64 | −44 | −8 | ||||
−52 | 26 | 24 | ||||
De Luca et al., 2006 | Resting state, instructed to relax with their eyes closed, without falling asleep | 26 (100%) | Talairach | 6 | −78 | −3 |
24 | −78 | −10 | ||||
−30 | −89 | 20 | ||||
−2 | −51 | 27 | ||||
53 | −57 | 23 | ||||
2 | 54 | −3 | ||||
−20 | −19 | −18 | ||||
6 | −19 | 6 | ||||
−4 | −6 | 40 | ||||
−51 | −7 | 8 | ||||
−55 | −18 | 8 | ||||
57 | −5 | 20 | ||||
12 | −17 | 0 | ||||
22 | −16 | −13 | ||||
−2 | −21 | 43 | ||||
46 | 6 | 34 | ||||
44 | −48 | 46 | ||||
−38 | −56 | 48 | ||||
−55 | −58 | −9 | ||||
62 | −37 | −3 | ||||
52 | 26 | −4 | ||||
6 | 46 | 18 | ||||
8 | −46 | 41 | ||||
8 | −16 | 40 | ||||
Greicius et al., 2003 | Keep their eyes closed and to not think of anything in particular for 4 min. | 14 (100%) | Talairach | −2 | −51 | 27 |
−51 | −65 | 27 | ||||
−2 | 55 | −18 | ||||
−16 | 49 | 38 | ||||
−44 | 20 | 41 | ||||
−12 | −35 | 0 | ||||
18 | 54 | 32 | ||||
−58 | −18 | 14 | ||||
2 | 38 | −2 | ||||
2 | −51 | 27 | ||||
4 | −14 | 34 | ||||
4 | 9 | −6 | ||||
4 | −16 | −3 | ||||
−4 | −55 | 25 | ||||
0 | −49 | 30 | ||||
−4 | −49 | 26 | ||||
Horn et al., 2014 | Participants were asked to close their eyes. | 19 (100%) | Talairach | 6 | −61 | 34 |
−36 | −63 | 47 | ||||
45 | −43 | 52 | ||||
57 | −28 | 25 | ||||
6 | −58 | 34 | ||||
−54 | −66 | 32 | ||||
45 | −43 | 49 | ||||
60 | −28 | 25 | ||||
9 | −52 | 31 | ||||
−39 | −46 | 43 | ||||
48 | −46 | 28 | ||||
−3 | 62 | −8 | ||||
−30 | −100 | 4 | ||||
15 | −64 | 32 | ||||
−36 | −45 | 49 | ||||
39 | −40 | 46 | ||||
0 | 68 | 0 | ||||
−30 | 50 | 7 | ||||
−31 | −100 | 8 | ||||
Maresh et al., 2014 | Underwent two runs of the MID task, designed to assess one's neural response to the anticipation and receipt of rewarding or punishing monetary stimuli. | 84 (100%) | Talairach | −18 | −40 | 36 |
−30 | −56 | 36 | ||||
−8 | −54 | 48 | ||||
0 | −78 | 52 | ||||
−34 | −56 | 42 | ||||
−6 | −54 | 36 | ||||
−20 | 44 | 18 | ||||
−26 | 34 | 42 | ||||
−20 | 42 | 10 | ||||
−28 | 56 | 12 | ||||
−22 | 34 | 28 | ||||
−22 | 16 | 36 | ||||
−8 | −56 | 48 | ||||
−10 | −66 | 34 | ||||
−8 | −42 | 48 | ||||
−6 | −54 | 38 | ||||
−6 | −50 | 34 | ||||
−10 | −52 | 38 | ||||
−36 | −42 | 54 | ||||
−52 | −32 | 50 | ||||
8 | −48 | 60 | ||||
−36 | −54 | 54 | ||||
−42 | −48 | 56 | ||||
−46 | −50 | 56 | ||||
−50 | −50 | 50 | ||||
Fransson, 2006 | Two 10‐min scans during which they performed a resting‐state, low‐level baseline task (eyes open, visual fixation on a hair‐cross‐centered in the screen) and a sequential two‐back verbal working memory task. | 14 (100%) | Talairach | −39 | −75 | 45 |
−3 | −63 | 48 | ||||
3 | −66 | 30 | ||||
−33 | 18 | 57 | ||||
33 | 33 | 51 | ||||
−6 | 39 | 39 | ||||
9 | 45 | −12 | ||||
−12 | 45 | −12 | ||||
−60 | −27 | −15 | ||||
−57 | −36 | −6 | ||||
−27 | −27 | −24 | ||||
−42 | 9 | −42 | ||||
63 | −18 | −21 | ||||
48 | 9 | −42 | ||||
63 | −27 | −12 | ||||
39 | −72 | −42 | ||||
6 | −60 | −51 | ||||
−6 | −57 | −48 | ||||
30 | −18 | −24 | ||||
−24 | −90 | −27 | ||||
−27 | 27 | −24 | ||||
57 | 9 | 12 | ||||
45 | 12 | 6 | ||||
66 | −21 | 33 | ||||
63 | −18 | 24 | ||||
69 | −15 | 18 | ||||
−66 | −27 | 18 | ||||
−36 | 3 | 9 | ||||
Piccoli et al., 2015 | Subjects were asked to judge whether a given target stimulus had been part of a previous memory stimulus set or not. | 14 (100%) | Talairach | 2 | −44 | 31 |
−2 | 25 | −8 | ||||
41 | −56 | 33 | ||||
−54 | −63 | 20 | ||||
28 | −56 | 47 | ||||
−25 | −59 | 45 | ||||
44 | 3 | 24 | ||||
−55 | 5 | 30 | ||||
−2 | −48 | 24 | ||||
2 | 46 | 9 | ||||
50 | −59 | 23 | ||||
−44 | −71 | 30 | ||||
35 | −58 | 50 | ||||
−18 | −70 | 46 | ||||
40 | 18 | 35 | ||||
−27 | 31 | 28 | ||||
−10 | −53 | 13 | ||||
2 | 46 | 21 | ||||
46 | −70 | 26 | ||||
−50 | −65 | 38 | ||||
40 | −53 | 48 | ||||
−33 | −53 | 47 | ||||
43 | 22 | 27 | ||||
−38 | 16 | 24 | ||||
−4 | −37 | 36 | ||||
−3 | 28 | −3 | ||||
58 | −53 | 24 | ||||
−55 | −64 | 25 | ||||
33 | −56 | 44 | ||||
−36 | −38 | 37 | ||||
35 | 21 | 38 | ||||
−45 | 22 | 32 | ||||
2 | −44 | 30 | ||||
−7 | 37 | 9 | ||||
59 | −29 | 24 | ||||
−61 | −38 | 15 | ||||
30 | −53 | 30 | ||||
−40 | −50 | 33 | ||||
32 | 43 | 28 | ||||
−55 | 16 | 33 | ||||
−3 | −48 | 26 | ||||
−3 | 41 | 30 | ||||
30 | −81 | 36 | ||||
−43 | −74 | 32 | ||||
44 | −32 | 36 | ||||
−36 | −54 | 44 | ||||
42 | 38 | 39 | ||||
−41 | 30 | 38 | ||||
−1 | −40 | 28 | ||||
1 | 29 | −6 | ||||
41 | −77 | 38 | ||||
−50 | −74 | 20 | ||||
23 | −67 | 48 | ||||
−34 | −62 | 42 | ||||
35 | 29 | 25 | ||||
−21 | 35 | 28 | ||||
−3 | −54 | 20 | ||||
4 | 52 | 11 | ||||
56 | −58 | 32 | ||||
−53 | −58 | 21 | ||||
24 | −50 | 47 | ||||
−29 | −50 | 41 | ||||
22 | 28 | 28 | ||||
−36 | 25 | 26 | ||||
0 | −50 | 31 | ||||
−1 | 27 | −13 | ||||
54 | −63 | 24 | ||||
−46 | −65 | 26 | ||||
17 | −66 | 54 | ||||
−22 | −64 | 51 | ||||
44 | 35 | 27 | ||||
−43 | 24 | 33 | ||||
−3 | −42 | 29 | ||||
0 | 37 | −3 | ||||
39 | −69 | 28 | ||||
−52 | −70 | 24 | ||||
30 | −57 | 39 | ||||
−38 | −44 | 36 | ||||
44 | 30 | 33 | ||||
−28 | 28 | 33 | ||||
−9 | −51 | 26 | ||||
−2 | 31 | −4 | ||||
53 | −64 | 21 | ||||
−46 | −75 | 24 | ||||
26 | −66 | 36 | ||||
−37 | −37 | 38 | ||||
34 | 19 | 36 | ||||
−31 | 19 | 26 | ||||
−10 | −55 | 32 | ||||
−4 | 30 | −5 | ||||
39 | −71 | 34 | ||||
−48 | −77 | 30 | ||||
31 | −44 | 37 | ||||
−31 | −50 | 33 | ||||
51 | 28 | 32 | ||||
−49 | 25 | 33 | ||||
−8 | −35 | 33 | ||||
10 | 34 | 5 | ||||
50 | −65 | 30 | ||||
−54 | −65 | 28 | ||||
37 | −74 | 35 | ||||
−31 | −71 | 39 | ||||
35 | 36 | 38 | ||||
−45 | 32 | 31 | ||||
8 | −47 | 30 | ||||
2 | 42 | 2 | ||||
44 | −74 | 22 | ||||
−48 | −71 | 24 | ||||
26 | −68 | 45 | ||||
−43 | −38 | 45 | ||||
38 | 34 | 30 | ||||
−40 | 40 | 24 | ||||
Laird et al., 2009 | Investigating the Functional Heterogeneity of the Default Mode Network Using Coordinate‐Based Meta‐Analytic Modeling. | 840 (100%) | Talairach | −4 | −58 | 44 |
−4 | −52 | 22 | ||||
2 | 32 | −8 | ||||
52 | −28 | −24 | ||||
−2 | 50 | 18 | ||||
46 | −66 | 16 | ||||
−26 | 16 | 44 | ||||
−56 | −36 | 28 | ||||
−42 | −66 | 18 |
Chiong et al., 2013 | Moral reasoning task. | 16 (control subjects only) | MNI | 50 | −6 | 26 |
0 | −78 | 42 | ||||
4 | 34 | −14 | ||||
56 | −64 | 26 | ||||
4 | −58 | 24 | ||||
−20 | 4 | −12 | ||||
Poerio et al., 2017 | Viewed a fixation cross with eyes open. | 80 (100%) | MNI | −12 | −92 | −24 |
−48 | −72 | −28 | ||||
−48 | 24 | 32 | ||||
Spreng & Schacter, 2012 | Visuospatial planning was investigated by presenting participants with 2 configurations on a single screen: the “goal” position and the “initial” position. The objective of this task was for the participant to determine the minimum number of moves to accomplish the goal state. | 36 (100%) | MNI | −22 | −22 | −22 |
47 | −71 | 29 | ||||
Yang et al., 2012 | Subjects were asked to “relax and rest as we take pictures of your brain.” | 18 (100%) | Talairach | −10 | 40 | 50 |
10 | 66 | 10 | ||||
14 | 44 | −8 | ||||
−64 | −6 | −8 | ||||
−60 | −14 | −20 | ||||
64 | −8 | −26 | ||||
−30 | −22 | −20 | ||||
36 | −34 | −18 | ||||
Konishi et al., 2015 | Participants alternated between task blocks in which they either make decisions about the location of shapes as they are presented on screen or with respect to their location on the prior trial. | 29 (100%) | MNI | 4 | −64 | 30 |
18 | −52 | 16 | ||||
10 | −46 | 0 | ||||
32 | 14 | 42 | ||||
22 | 42 | 40 | ||||
28 | 20 | 46 | ||||
0 | 36 | 22 | ||||
16 | 64 | 0 | ||||
28 | 56 | 8 | ||||
44 | −58 | 36 | ||||
36 | −62 | 26 | ||||
40 | −68 | 44 | ||||
2 | −32 | 36 | ||||
10 | −46 | 34 | ||||
8 | −16 | 30 | ||||
−24 | −20 | −18 | ||||
−22 | −34 | −8 | ||||
−16 | −34 | 2 | ||||
−54 | −8 | −18 | ||||
−62 | −18 | −10 | ||||
−52 | −16 | −22 | ||||
−38 | −72 | 36 | ||||
−48 | −62 | 42 | ||||
−38 | −74 | 28 | ||||
−8 | −60 | 38 | ||||
−10 | −38 | 28 | ||||
−2 | −48 | 34 | ||||
−6 | −66 | 6 | ||||
−18 | −66 | 18 | ||||
−18 | −64 | 8 | ||||
Mason et al., 2007 | Minds could wander when they performed practiced versus novel task sequences. | 19 (100%) | Talairach | 6 | 62 | 11 |
0 | 62 | 16 | ||||
−12 | 49 | 45 | ||||
12 | 49 | 47 | ||||
21 | 40 | 45 | ||||
−38 | 20 | 48 | ||||
−9 | −39 | 35 | ||||
6 | −15 | 39 | ||||
24 | −7 | −20 | ||||
6 | 41 | 4 | ||||
−18 | −36 | −13 | ||||
−45 | −68 | 37 | ||||
−9 | −51 | 30 | ||||
42 | −11 | 3 | ||||
45 | −28 | 18 | ||||
−42 | −18 | −2 | ||||
−45 | −63 | 31 | ||||
−45 | −6 | −7 | ||||
50 | −57 | 33 | ||||
−30 | −39 | −13 | ||||
6 | 51 | −9 | ||||
3 | 57 | 42 | ||||
3 | −9 | 51 | ||||
−3 | 51 | 51 | ||||
−6 | 54 | 27 | ||||
−18 | 39 | 51 | ||||
15 | 48 | 42 | ||||
15 | 60 | 39 | ||||
21 | −24 | 72 | ||||
6 | 48 | 9 | ||||
−6 | −45 | 18 | ||||
−9 | −42 | 27 | ||||
3 | −45 | 18 | ||||
0 | −9 | 39 | ||||
54 | −57 | 36 | ||||
−48 | −66 | 30 | ||||
6 | −41 | 60 | ||||
45 | −24 | 18 | ||||
−42 | 0 | 9 | ||||
30 | −15 | 3 | ||||
36 | −3 | 9 | ||||
−36 | −9 | 9 | ||||
60 | −6 | 3 | ||||
−45 | −60 | 15 | ||||
−42 | −37 | 3 | ||||
Kennedy & Courchesne, 2008 | Subjects made true/false judgments for various statements about themselves (SELF condition) or a close other person (OTHER condition). | 13 (control only) | Talairach | −6 | 39 | 48 |
−2 | 51 | 28 | ||||
2 | −49 | 28 | ||||
−42 | 19 | 16 | ||||
−3 | −97 | 24 | ||||
−42 | 3 | 48 | ||||
−50 | −65 | 36 | ||||
−2 | 31 | 0 | ||||
−42 | 3 | −28 | ||||
58 | −65 | 28 | ||||
−50 | −33 | 4 | ||||
55 | −32 | 20 | ||||
7 | 39 | −1 | ||||
26 | −44 | 59 | ||||
51 | −8 | 12 | ||||
6 | −45 | 35 | ||||
10 | −28 | 44 | ||||
−53 | −61 | 24 | ||||
−37 | −12 | 0 | ||||
−2 | −89 | 20 | ||||
−6 | −73 | 0 | ||||
22 | −68 | 4 | ||||
7 | −57 | 27 | ||||
−18 | −45 | 4 | ||||
22 | −45 | 7 | ||||
18 | −25 | 17 | ||||
−38 | 28 | 0 | ||||
2 | −16 | 32 | ||||
−1 | 51 | 24 | ||||
−2 | 20 | 20 | ||||
−5 | −48 | 8 | ||||
−21 | 20 | 48 | ||||
3 | −33 | 39 | ||||
−18 | −33 | −12 | ||||
−38 | −73 | 29 | ||||
38 | 20 | 52 | ||||
47 | −68 | 24 | ||||
Xu et al., 2014 | Nondirective meditation. | 14 (100%) | MNI | 8 | 37 | 10 |
8 | 6 | 31 | ||||
−3 | 42 | −3 | ||||
Chen et al., 2017 | Resting state | 24 (control subjects only) | MNI | 3 | −54 | 27 |
−45 | −57 | 30 | ||||
−21 | −33 | −12 | ||||
−60 | −9 | −18 | ||||
−3 | 63 | 18 |