Skip to main content
. 2021 Feb 2;12:620401. doi: 10.3389/fpsyt.2021.620401

Table 3.

List of studies examining gray matter indices, indicating significant differences between groups either at baseline (BL) or a significant group x time interaction.

Dataset References BL: HR vs. HV Time:
HR vs. HV
Time: CHR-T vs. CHR-NT BL:
Predict Transition
Significant brain regions for HR vs. HV over time Significant brain regions for CHR-T vs. CHR-NT over time
Whole brain Frontal ACC Temporal Parietal Occipital Thalamus Amygdala Basal Ganglia Cerebellum Ventricle Whole brain Frontal Insula ACC Temporal Parietal Occipital Nucleus Accumbens Cerebellum Ventricle
Toho University Katagiri et al. (15) NA NA NA graphic file with name fpsyt-12-620401-i0001.jpg
ADAPT Damme et al. (16) graphic file with name fpsyt-12-620401-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-12-620401-i0001.jpg NA NA
NAPLS Cannon et al. (17) NA NA graphic file with name fpsyt-12-620401-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-12-620401-i0001.jpg ↓ CT ↑ Vol
Chung et al. (18) NA NA NA NA
Chung et al. (19) NA NA NA NA
Singapore Ho et al. (20) NA NA graphic file with name fpsyt-12-620401-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-12-620401-i0001.jpg ↓ Vol
NIMH COS Study Gogtay et al. (21) graphic file with name fpsyt-12-620401-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-12-620401-i0002.jpg NA NA ↓ CT ↓ CT ↓ CT
Mattai et al. (22) graphic file with name fpsyt-12-620401-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-12-620401-i0002.jpg NA NA ↓ CT ↓ CT ↓ CT
Zalesky et al. (23) NA graphic file with name fpsyt-12-620401-i0002.jpg NA NA ↓ Con ↓ Con
Greenstein et al. (24) graphic file with name fpsyt-12-620401-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-12-620401-i0002.jpg NA NA ↓ Vol
Mattai (25) graphic file with name fpsyt-12-620401-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-12-620401-i0001.jpg NA NA
Sibling pair, Utrecht Brans et al. (26) NA graphic file with name fpsyt-12-620401-i0001.jpg NA NA
Twin pair, Utrecht Hedman et al. (27) NA graphic file with name fpsyt-12-620401-i0002.jpg NA NA ↓ CT ↓ CT
Dutch Prediction Psychosis Ziermans et al. (28) graphic file with name fpsyt-12-620401-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-12-620401-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-12-620401-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-12-620401-i0001.jpg ↓ CT ↓ Vol ↓ CT ↓ CT ↓ CT ↓ CT
de Wit et al. (29) NA graphic file with name fpsyt-12-620401-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-12-620401-i0002.jpg NA ↔ SA ↔ SA
↑ Vol

SA
↓ Vol
↓ CT
↔ SA
↓ GI
↓ SA ↓ GI ↓ Vol
Vol
↑ Vol ↓ CT* SA*
Vol*
CT*

SA

Vol
↑ GI
↓ Vol*↓ CT*↔ CT
Vol*
CT*

Vol*
↑ Vol
Edinburgh High Risk Study Lawrie et al. (30) graphic file with name fpsyt-12-620401-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-12-620401-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-12-620401-i0002.jpg NA ↓ Vol
Job et al. (31) NA Effect of time Effect of time NA ↓ Vol ↓ Vol ↓ Vol ↓ Vol
Mcintosh et al. (32) graphic file with name fpsyt-12-620401-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-12-620401-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-12-620401-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-12-620401-i0001.jpg ↓ Vol ↓ Vol ↓ Vol ↓ Vol
Bois et al. (33) graphic file with name fpsyt-12-620401-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-12-620401-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-12-620401-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-12-620401-i0002.jpg ↓ CT,
↔ SA
↓ CT ↓ CT ↔ CT
Bois et al. (34) NA graphic file with name fpsyt-12-620401-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-12-620401-i0001.jpg NA ↔ Vol
Edinburgh Study of Comorbidity Moorhead et al. (35) NA graphic file with name fpsyt-12-620401-i0002.jpg NA NA ↓ Vol ↓ Vol
McKechanie et al. (36) NA NA NA NA
FEPSY project Walter et al. (37) NA NA graphic file with name fpsyt-12-620401-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-12-620401-i0002.jpg
Walter et al. (38) NA NA graphic file with name fpsyt-12-620401-i0001.jpg NA
Borgwardt et al. (39) NA NA graphic file with name fpsyt-12-620401-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-12-620401-i0002.jpg ↓ Vol ↓ Vol ↓ Vol ↓ Vol
OASIS Fusar-Poli et al. (40) graphic file with name fpsyt-12-620401-i0002.jpg Effect of time Effect of time graphic file with name fpsyt-12-620401-i0002.jpg ↑↓ Vol ↑ Vol ↓ Vol ↑ Vol ↓ Vol
PACE Pantelis et al. (41) NA NA Effect of time graphic file with name fpsyt-12-620401-i0002.jpg ↓ Vol ↓ Vol ↓ Vol ↑ Vol ↓ Vol
Sun et al. (42) NA NA graphic file with name fpsyt-12-620401-i0002.jpg NA ↓ SA
Takahashi et al. (43) NA NA graphic file with name fpsyt-12-620401-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-12-620401-i0001.jpg ↓ Vol
Takahashi et al. (44) NA NA graphic file with name fpsyt-12-620401-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-12-620401-i0002.jpg ↓ Vol
Ludwig Maximilians Koutsouleris et al. (45) NA graphic file with name fpsyt-12-620401-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-12-620401-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-12-620401-i0002.jpg ↓ Vol ↓ Vol ↓ Vol ↓ Vol ↓ Vol ↓ Vol ↓ Vol ↑ Vol ↓ Vol ↓ Vol ↑ Vol
Western Psychiatric Institute and Clinic Bhojraj et al. (46) NA graphic file with name fpsyt-12-620401-i0002.jpg NA NA ↓ SA
Bhojraj et al. (47) graphic file with name fpsyt-12-620401-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-12-620401-i0002.jpg NA graphic file with name fpsyt-12-620401-i0002.jpg ↓ Vol ↓ Vol ↓ Vol
Prasad et al. (48) graphic file with name fpsyt-12-620401-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-12-620401-i0002.jpg NA NA ↓ SA ↓ SA, ↓ Vol, ↑ CT ↓ Vol, ↑ CT ↓ Vol, ↑ CT ↓ SA, ↓ Vol
IMAGEN Yu et al. (49) NA graphic file with name fpsyt-12-620401-i0002.jpg NA NA ↔ Vol
Dublin & Kildare Calvo et al. (50) graphic file with name fpsyt-12-620401-i0002.jpg Effect of group NA NA ↓ Vol*
Barcelona Sugranyes et al. (51) graphic file with name fpsyt-12-620401-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-12-620401-i0002.jpg NA NA ↔ SA
Sugranyes et al. (52) NA NA graphic file with name fpsyt-12-620401-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-12-620401-i0002.jpg ↓ CT ↓ SA* NT vs. HV: ↔ SA+Vol ↓ CT
TOTAL: 9/14 20/24 15/19 9/15 6 9 6 16 6 4 1 1 2 4 2 3 6 1 4 9 4 3 1 3 3
BL:
HR vs. HV
Time: HR vs. HV Time: CHR-T vs. CHR-NT BL: Predict Transition Whole brain Frontal ACC Temporal Parietal Occipital Thalamus Amygdala Basal Ganglia Cerebellum Ventricle Whole brain Frontal Insula ACC Temporal Parietal Occipital Nucleus Accumbens Cerebellum Ventricle

Arrows indicate altered trajectories between groups in specified brain region, ↓ indicate a decrease in the HR or CHR-T group compared to HV or CHR-NT respectively, ↑ indicate an increase and ↔ indicate no change over time in HR whereas an increase/decrease is seen in HV. HR, high risk; HV, healthy volunteer; CHR-T, clinical high risk transition; CHR-NT, no transition; ACC, Anterior cingulate cortex; NA, Not Applicable (for example studies examine other contrasts such as medicated vs. unmedicated); CT, cortical thickness; Vol, gray matter volume; Conn, structural connectivity; SA, surface area; GI, gyrification.

*

volume was lower in HR vs. HV at both timepoints but there was no group × time interaction.