Skip to main content
. 2021 Feb 2;8:639641. doi: 10.3389/fvets.2021.639641

Table 2.

Outcomes evaluated in 26 clinical mastitis treatment trials.

Study Bact. cure New IMI Clinical cure SCC Recurrence Milk yield Culling
NEGATIVELY CONTROLLED RANDOMIZED CLINICAL TRIALS
Roberson et al. (39) NSDa NSD NSD SIGb Defined as CC NSD SIG
Suojala et al. (27) NSD NSD at day 21 No stats NSD
Schukken et al. (40) SIG SIG NSD NSD SIG
Persson et al. (41) SIG
Fuenzalida and Ruegg (22) NSD NSD NSD NSD NSD NSD
Fuenzalida and Ruegg (25) SIG NSD NSD NSD NSD NSD
POSITIVELY CONTROLLED TRIALS – NOT TESTING A NON-INFERIORITY HYPOTHESIS
Erskine et al. (34) NSD
Wraight (42) NSD NSD
McDougall (43) NSD SIG NSD SIG NSD
Taponen et al. (44) NSD NSD
Sérieys et al. (45) NSD NSD SIG
Taponen et al. (46) SIG NSD
Wenz et al. (33) NSD NSD NSD
Bradley and Green (47) NSD NSD
Swinkels et al. (48) NSD NSD SIG NSD
Kalmus et al. (49) NSD NSD NSD NSD
Truchetti et al. (50) SIG NSD NSD
Cortinhas et al. (51) NSD NSD NSD
Viveros et al. (52) NSD SIG SIG
McDougall et al. (53) NSD SIG NSD
POSITIVELY CONTROLLED TRIALS – TESTING A NON-INFERIORITY OR “EQUIVALENCY” HYPOTHESIS
McDougall et al. (54) NSD SIG Defined as CC
McDougall et al. (21) NSD SIG NSD Defined as CC NSD NSD
Schukken et al. (55) NIc NSD NI
Vasquez et al. (56) NI NI NI NI
Bryan et al. (57) NSD NSD Defined as CC
Tomazi et al. (58) Inconclusive Inconclusive NI
a

No significant difference;

b

statistically significant difference among treatments;

c

non-inferior.