Table 3.
Distribution of streak artifacts and noise among different reconstruction algorithms and implant configurations (screw/rod). Distribution of most pronounced streak artifacts of the screw shaft (in ΔHU) and corresponding reference HU values of bone and fat tissue among different image reconstruction algorithms. Noise was measured as ± standard deviation (SD) of reference muscle attenuation. Note significantly lower artifact degrees for carbon (C) screw compared to titanium (Ti) screw containing configurations. Rod material had comparably lower impact on artifact degree. Mean HU-values of reference muscle tissue showed no significant differences among reconstructions-algorithms (F = 0.815, p = .615) while in the vertebral body significant inverse correlation with tube voltage (Spearman’s rho= −656, p < .001) was seen. Image noise inversely correlated with tube voltage
Artifact degree (ΔHU) of screw shaft | Reference tissue attenuation (HU) | ||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Ti/Ti | Ti/C | C/C | C/Ti | Bone | Muscle | Noise (± SD) | |
sk SE 80 kV | − 859 | − 903 | − 37 | − 32 | 872 | 63 | 19 |
bk SE 80 kV | − 870 | − 898 | − 35 | − 58 | 871 | 63 | 45 |
sk SE 120 kV | − 848 | − 897 | − 11 | − 39 | 670 | 60 | 14 |
bk SE 120 kV | − 876 | − 920 | − 48 | − 69 | 656 | 61 | 37 |
sk SE 120 kV iMAR | − 768 | − 719 | − 71 | − 106 | 628 | 59 | 16 |
sk DE 120 kV Mix | − 664 | − 630 | 1 | − 58 | 559 | 61 | 15 |
bk DE 120 kV Mix | − 713 | − 674 | − 1 | − 63 | 562 | 61 | 43 |
sk SE Sn 150 kV | − 648 | − 617 | 0 | − 7 | 474 | 60 | 17 |
bk SE Sn 150 kV | − 691 | − 641 | − 10 | − 5 | 477 | 60 | 53 |
sk DE ME 130 keV | − 615 | − 582 | 13 | − 17 | 402 | 59 | 18 |
bk DE ME 130 keV | − 690 | − 608 | 11 | − 25 | 401 | 60 | 46 |
bk bone kernel, C carbon, DE dual energy, HU Hounsfield Units, iMAR iterative metal artifact reduction (brand name), ME monoenergetic extrapolation, SD standard deviation, SE single energy, sk soft tissue kernel, Sn tin-filtered, Ti titanium