Table 3.
Comparison of rapid tests to “gold standard” viral culture and RT-PCR.
Method | Sample type1 | Cost | Complexity | Scalability | Sensitivity | Refs. |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Viral culture | NP in VTM | Expensive | Complex | Not scalable | Culturable when Ct <24 | [31] |
RT-PCR (central lab protocols) | Extracted NP |
Expensive | Complex | Kits, tubes and tips | Comparator | [45] |
Cepheid GeneXpert | NP in VTM | Expensive | Simple | Platform and single-use cartridges | 95−100% | [11,21] |
Abbott ID NOW | Direct NP | Expensive | Simple | Platform and single-use cartridges | 70−90% | [45,46] |
Abbott Panbio Ag | Direct NP | Cheap | Simple | Single-use cartridges | 75−85% | [34,47,48] |
NEB RT-LAMP | Extract-free NP | Cheap | Simple | Kit, tubes and tips | 75−95% | [23] |
NP: Nasopharyngeal, VTM: Viral transport medium.