Table 1.
Authors, Country | Aim of study | No. of cases studied | Clinical features & Radiological details | Biomarkers & Haematological findings | Histopathology & Cytomorphology | IHC/Immuno-floroscence | Electron microscopy |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Zhang H et al, China | Histo-pathological findings and IHC in COVID19 infected lung | 01 | C/F: 72-year-old diabetic & hypertensive presented with fever & cough. | – | DAD, intra-alveolar fibrinous exudates & loose interstitial fibrosis. | Rp3 NP protein of SARS–CoV-2: prominent expression on alveolar epithelial cells & on damaged desquamated cells within alveolar space. | – |
CT scan: Patchy ground glass–like opacifications with pleural thickening and mediastinal lymphadenopathy. | |||||||
Copin MC et al, France | Histological patterns of lung injury | 06 | – | – | -01 case: Lymphocytic viral pneumonia | – | – |
-05 cases: AFOP with intra-alveolar “fibrin balls” | |||||||
Xu Z et al, China | Pathological findings of COVID-19 associated with acute respiratory distress syndrome | 01 | Chest X-ray: Multiple patchy shadows in B/L lungs | Peripheral blood flow cytometry: |
LUNGS: -B/L DAD, cellular fibro-myxoid exudate. |
– | – |
- Reduced CD4 & CD8 T cells | -Viral cytopathic effect: multinucleated syncytial cells with atypical enlarged pneumocytes in intra-alveolar spaces. | ||||||
- High proportions of HLA-DR (CD4 3·47 %) & CD38 (CD8 39·4%) double-positive fractions |
HEART: -Interstitial mononuclear inflammatory infiltrates |
||||||
- Increased concentration of highly proinflammatory CCR6+ Th17 in CD4 T cells |
LIVER: -Moderate microvesicular steatosis with mild lobular & portal activity |
||||||
Fox SE et al, USA | Autopsy series studying pulmonary and cardiac Pathology in Covid19. | 04 | C/F: Aged 44−78 years with hypertension -Mild cough & fever with sudden respiratory decompensation | -Elevated ferritin & fibrinogen levels | -LUNGS: (04 cases) -Bilateral DAD, mild-to-moderate lymphocytic infiltrate, megakaryocytes within small vessels & alveolar capillaries. |
– | – |
-Increased AST | -Viral cytopathic effect: cytomegaly enlarged nuclei & bright, eosinophilic nucleoli within alveolar spaces. | ||||||
-Increased d-dimer levels in all patients near death. |
HEART: (04 cases) -Scattered individual cell myocyte necrosis. |
||||||
Schaller T et al, Germany | Postmortem Examination of Patients With COVID-19 | 10 | C/F: Fever, cough & dyspnea. | – |
LUNGS: (10 cases) -Disseminated DAD at different stages more pronounced in middle & lower lobes. |
– | – |
X ray: (09 cases) ground-glass opacity predominantly in middle & lower lung fields. | -Fully established fibrosis in 01 case. | ||||||
-Minor neutrophilic infiltration in 5 cases | |||||||
HEART: -Mild lymphocytic myocarditis (04 cases) & epicarditis (02 cases) |
|||||||
LIVER: -Non-specific Periportal liver lymphocyte infiltration & fibrosis |
|||||||
BRAIN: -No change |
|||||||
Giani M et al, Italy | BAL fluid analysis | 01 | C/F: Fatigue & fever progressing to respiratory distress & hypoxia | – | CYTOMORPHOLOGY: | – | – |
-Fibrino-hematic material with scattered alveolar macrophages & predominance of activated plasma cells (CD138+), admixed with T & scattered B lymphocytes. | |||||||
-Alveolar macrophages: showed nuclear clearing or intranuclear cytopathic inclusions | |||||||
Zhang Y et al, China | Assess liver impairment in COVID19 patients | 115 | C/F: Respiratory distress | Elevated levels of: |
LIVER: (01 case) -Non-specific findings. |
– | – |
-ALT: 11/115 | -Mild sinusoidal dilatation with minimal lymphocytic infiltration | ||||||
-AST: 17/115 | |||||||
-S.biliubin: 08/115 cases. | |||||||
Tian S et al, China | Pathological assessment of postmortem core biopsies, | 04 | C/F: Aged 59−81 years with each patient having at least one underlying disease, including immunocompromised status. | Case 1: -elevated pro-BNP & hypertensive cardiac troponin (d/t history of previous MI) | LUNGS: | – | – |
CT scan (03 cases): Multiple patchy ground glass opacities | - DAD (in all 04 cases) | ||||||
X ray (01 case): Patchy high-density shadows with worsening in subsequent days. | All 04 cases: | - Case no. 02: also showed pneumocyte injury with focal sloughing & formation of syncytial giant cells | |||||
-Normal AST/ALT/S.bilirubin levels | -Case no. 04: also showed fibrinoid necrosis in small vessels with abundant intra-alveolar neutrophilic infiltration, consistent with bronchopneumonia due to superimposed bacterial infection. | ||||||
LIVER: | |||||||
-Case 1: sinusoidal dilatation, nuclear glycogen in hepatocytes, focal macrovesicular steatosis and features of CLL | |||||||
-Case 2: cirrhosis consistent with his history & mild zone 3 sinusoidal dilatation | |||||||
-Case 3&4: mild lobular lymphocytic infiltration. | |||||||
HEART: -Non-specific findings with no epicardial/myocardial inflammation. |
|||||||
Su H et al, China. | Histopathological analysis of kidney biopsy in 26 postmortem cases. | 26 | C/F: 26 cases died of respiratory failure due to COVID19 | - Leukocytois in 10 cases. | -Prominent ATI -Loss of brush border, vacuolar degeneration & dilatation of tubular lumen with cellular debris in almost all cases, |
DIF:Nonspecific IgM & C3 trapping in glomeruli. | Coronavirus-like particles: |
−2 cases: multiple foci of bacteria & diffuse polymorphonuclear casts in tubular lumen. | Indirect IF: Positive granular nuclear and cytoplasmic staining with SARS-CoV nucleoprotein in tubular epithelium (in 03 out of 06 cases) | 65−136 nm, with distinctive spikes, 20 −25 nm in cytoplasm of renal proximal tubular epithelium/podocytes /less so in distal tubules. | |||||
−3 cases: pigmented casts with high levels of CPK possibly due to rhabdomyolysis | |||||||
−5 cases:Endothelial cell swelling with variable foamy degeneration in old/hypertensive/diabetic cases. | |||||||
−3 cases: segmental fibrin thrombus in glomerular capillary loops with severe injury of the endothelium Occasional podocyte vacuolation & detachment from the glomerular basement membrane. | |||||||
Christopher P. Larsen et al, USA | Collapsing Glomerulopathy in a Patient With COVID-19 | 01 | C/F: 63-year-old hypertensive male with fatigue, high-grade fever (39.7 | -Elevated CRP & D-dimer |
Kidney Biopsy: −14 glomeruli were globally sclerotic. Many of the intact glomeruli showed tuft collapse with overlying epithelial hypertrophy & hyperplasia in the Bowman space. |
DIF: Negative for IgA, IgG, IgM, C3, C1q, kappa & lambda in Glomeruli. | No definitive viral particles |
-Lymphopenia | -Tubular epithelium injury: most prominent in the PCT | ||||||
-Interstitial fibrosis, tubular atrophy, inflammatory infiltrate in interstitium consisting of lymphocytes, plasma cells with few scattered eosinophils | |||||||
Buja LM et al, USA | Emerging spectrum of cardiopulmonary pathology of COVID-19: | 03 | C/F: Autopsy done on: Case 1: 62-year-old obese male history of respiratory illness died of COVID19 Case 2: 34-year-old obese, diabetic hypertensive with headache, shortness of breath & productive cough died of COVID19 Case 3: 48-year-old obese died of COVID19 | – | LUNGS: | – | Case 1: |
CT scan: (Case 2) B/L upper & lower lobe ground-glass with early consolidative alveolar opacities of rounded morphology. | -Case 1: early DAD with multiple hyaline membranes & focal mild inflammation with lymphocytes & macrophages in some alveolar spaces. | -Strands of precipitated fibrin & entrapped neutrophils within alveolar capillaries -Larger deposits of fibrin in alveolar spaces. | |||||
-Case 2:interstitial lymphocytic pneumonitis with lymphocytic infiltrates around small blood vessels & terminal bronchioles. Microthrombi in some pulmonary arterioles. | -No Viral particles in heart or lungs. | ||||||
-Case 3: right pleura showed empyema. Right lung showed evidence of atelectasis & DAD. DAD was more pronounced in the expanded left lung. | |||||||
LIVER: | |||||||
-Case 1 & 2: Moderate macrovesicular steatosis | |||||||
-Case 3: Moderate macrovesicular steatosis, lympho-plasmacytic triaditis with portal fibrosis and early portal-portal bridging fibrosis. | |||||||
HEART: | |||||||
-Case 1: Cardiomyocytes with moderately enlarged hyperchromatic nuclei with vacuolar degenerative change. No myocarditis. | |||||||
-Case 2: Individual damaged cardiomyocytes | |||||||
-Case 3: Multifocal lymphocytic infiltrates in epicardium. Myocytes: enlarged hyperchromatic nuclei, changes of acute injury. | |||||||
KIDNEY: -Case 1: Hyaline arteriolosclerosis with glomerulosclerosis |
|||||||
-Case 2: Occasional fibrin-platelet thrombus in renal glomerular capillaries. | |||||||
-Case 3: Mild hyaline arteriolosclerosis, periglomerular hyaline arteriolosclerosis with rare holo-sclerotic glomeruli. | |||||||
Tavazzi G et al, Italy | Myocardial localization of coronavirus in COVID‐19 cardiogenic shock | 01 | C/F: 69-year-old patient with flu-like symptoms rapidly degenerating into respiratory distress, hypotension & shock. | -Lymphopenia |
HEART: -Cardiac myocytes showed non‐specific features consisting of focal myofibrillar lysis, and lipid droplets. |
Immune‐light microscopy: Large (>20 μm), vacuolated, CD68‐positive macrophages | Single / small groups of viral particles with electron‐dense spike‐like structures & size between 70–120 nm within the interstitial cells of myocardium. |
-Raised CRP | |||||||
- Increased hs‐TnI | |||||||
Varga Z et al, Switzerland. | Endothelial cell infection and endotheliitis in COVID-19 | 03 | C/F: Autopsies done on: Hypertensive males with COVID19 disease developing multi-organ failure | – | -Case 1: Inflammatory cells associated with endothelium & apoptotic bodies in heart, small bowel & lungs | – | Case 1: In transplanted kidney- Viral inclusion structures (dense circular surface with lucid centre) in endothelial cells |
-Case 2: Lymphocytic endotheliitis in lung, heart, kidney, and liver with liver cell necrosis. No lymphocytic myocarditis. | |||||||
-Case 3: Small intestine resection showed prominent endotheliitis of the submucosal vessels with apoptotic bodies | |||||||
Von Weyhern C.H., et al, Germany | Early evidence of pronounced brain involvement in fatal COVID-19 | 06 | C/F: Autopsies of 06 case aged 58−82 years who died from COVID-19 | -Elevated CRP & IL-6 in all the cases | BRAIN: | – | – |
-Leukocytosis in 2 cases | All cases:-Lymphocytic pan-encephalitis & meningitis | ||||||
-Patients with age <65yrs: Death due to Petechial bleeding and intracranial hemmorhage. | |||||||
LUNGS: | |||||||
−05 cases: DOD | |||||||
=01 case: Organizing Pneumonia Pattern | |||||||
Solomon IH et al, England | Neuropathological Features of Covid-19 | 18 | C/F: Myalgia headache & decreased taste | – | -All cases:Acute hypoxic injury in cerebrum & cerebellum with loss of neurons in the cerebral cortex, hippocampus & cerebellar Purkinje cell layer. No thrombi/vasculitis. | IHC to detect SARS-CoV: | – |
Negative in neurons, glia, endothelium& immune cells. | |||||||
−02 cases: perivascular lymphocytes | |||||||
−01 case: focal leptomeningeal inflammation | |||||||
Reichard RR et al, USA | A spectrum of vascular and acute disseminated encephalomyelitis (ADEM)-like pathology | 01 | C/F: 71-year-old male with fatigue and exertional dyspnea, | Elevated CRP, IL-6 & ferritin levels | -Perivascular acute disseminated encephalomyelitis (ADEM)-like pathology: Foci of intraparenchymal blood that disrupted the white matter, with macrophages at periphery of the lesions | – | – |
CT Chest: Parenchymal consolidation and surrounding ground-glass opacities following a peri-broncho vascular distribution. | - Luxol fast blue: loss of myelin, | ||||||
Poyiadji N et al, USA | COVID-19–associated Acute Hemorrhagic Necrotizing Encephalopathy | 01 | C/F: 58-year-old female with 3-day history of cough, fever & altered mental status. | – | – | – | |
NC-CT head: Symmetric hypoattenuation within the bilateral medial thalami. | |||||||
MRI: Haemorrhagic rim enhancing lesions within the bilateral thalami, medial temporal lobes & subinsular regions | |||||||
Galvan et al, Spain | Classification of the cutaneous manifestations of COVID ‐19 | 375 | C/F: | – | – | – | – |
-Pseudo-chilbain: 71cases | |||||||
-Vesicular: 34 | |||||||
-Urticarial: 73 | |||||||
-Maculo-papular: 176 | |||||||
-Livedo/ necrosis: 21 | |||||||
Recalcati et al, Spain | Cutaneous manifestations in COVID‐19: a first perspective | 18 | C/F: | – | – | – | – |
out of 88 cases -Skin lesions | -Erythematous rash: 14 | ||||||
-Urticaria: 03 -Chickenpox‐like vesicles :01 case | |||||||
Marzano AV, Italy | Varicella-like exanthem as a specific COVID-19–associated skin manifestation | 22 | C/F: Fever, cough headache, weakness, coryza dyspnea, hyposmia, hypogeusia, pharyngodynia, myalgia with skin lesions | – | -Varicella-like papulovesicular exanthem showing:Basket-wave hyperkeratosis,slightly atrophic epidermis, vacuolar degeneration of the basal layer with multinucleate, hyperchromatic keratinocytes & dyskeratotic cells | – | – |
Gianotti R et al, Italy | Clinical & histopathological study of skin dermatoses in patients with COVID-19 | 05 | C/F: Fever, sore throat & cough with development of skin lesions during hospital stay. | – | −02 cases: Grover & Kaposi’s varicelliform eruption- dyskeratotic cells, ballooning multinucleated cells, sparse necrotic keratinocytes with lymphocytic satellitosis. | – | – |
−3rd case:Perivascular spongiotic dermatitis with exocytosis with a large nest of Langerhans cells, dense perivascular lymphocytic infiltration with eosinophils around the swollen blood vessels. | |||||||
−4th case: Papular erythematous exanthema -edematous dermis with abundant eosinophils & lymphocytic vasculitis | |||||||
−5th case: severe maular haemorrhagic rash d/t fintravascular microthrombi within the small dermal vessels | |||||||
Xiao F et al, China | Evidence for Gastrointestinal Infection of SARS-CoV-2 | 73 | C/F: 73-year-old hospitalized patients infected with COVID19 | – |
Endoscopic biopsy: (01 case): -Lympho-plasmacytic infiltration along with interstitial edema in the lamina propria of stomach, duodenum, & rectum |
-ACE2: Rarely expressed on esophageal epithelium -abundantly distributed on cilia of glandular epithelia. | – |
-Occasional lymphocytes in esophageal squamous epithelium | -Viral nucleocapsid protein: cytoplasm of gastric, duodenal & rectum glandular epithelial cell, but not in esophageal epithelium. | ||||||
Carvalho A et al, USA | Gastrointestinal Infection Causing Hemorrhagic Colitis in COVID 19 | 01 | C/F: 71-year-old hypertensive female with nausea, vomiting, anorexia, diffuse abdominal pain & distention | Leukocytosis with neutrophilia | Edema in lamina propria with intact crypts with no colitis/ischemia/ or inflammatory bowel disease. | – | – |
CE-CT abdomen: Severe colonic inflammation, most pronounced in ascending, transverse & descending colon | |||||||
Yang M et al, China | Pathological Findings in the Testes of COVID-19 | 12 | C/F: Postmortem examination of the testes from 12 COVID-19 patients | – | -Sertoli cells showed swelling, vacuolation & cytoplasmic rarefaction, detachment from tubular basement membranes, loss and sloughing into lumens of the intratubular cell mass seen in all cases | ACE2: | No viral particles in all 03 cases tested |
-Classified injury to seminiferous tubules (ST) as: | -Diffuse expression on Sertoli cells. | ||||||
Mild – 02 cases | -Strongly expressed on Leydig cells. | ||||||
Moderate – 05 | -No expression on spermatogonia. | ||||||
Severe - 04 | |||||||
Brancatella A et al, Italy | Subacute Thyroiditis After Sars-COV-2 Infection | 01 | C/F: 8-year-old female with fever, neck pain radiating to the jaw & palpitations | -Elevated free thyroxine & free triiodothyronine levels | – | – | – |
USG neck: Bilateral and diffuse hypoechoic areas | -High inflammatory markers | ||||||
-Leukocytosis on peripheral smear | |||||||
Wei L et al, China | Pathology of the thyroid in severe acute respiratory syndrome | 05 | C/F: 05 autopsy cases who initially presented with fever and shortness of breath | Lymphopenia on peripheral smear | All cases: | Apoptosis with TUNEL assay: apoptosis was observed in both the follicular epithelium and the interfollicular region of all patients with SARS | – |
-Destruction of the follicular epithelium and exfoliation of epithelial cells into the follicle. | |||||||
-Follicles: dilated/ collapsed/distorted with an irregular outline/ microfollicle configuration. | |||||||
−01 case: congested with severe damage in follicular epithelium. |
KEY:
DAD - Diffuse alveolar damage.
AFOP -Acute fibrinous and organizing pneumonia.
B/L - bilateral.
AKI - Acute Kidney injury.
C/F - clinical features.
CRP - C-reactive protein.
IL-6 - Interleukin 6.
hs‐TnI - Troponin I.