Table 1.
Domain | Pre-COVID-19 conditions | Innovations fueling transformation |
---|---|---|
1. Leadership Dewar et al. [25] Marcero [12] Purcell [29] |
Top-down, command-control Telling style of leadership communication Disrupted by global megatrends Inequities tolerated |
Adaptive with social networks Invitational dialogue & reciprocity Focus on institutional purpose Pursuit of equity |
2. Financials Huron [20] Marcero [12] Taparia [31] |
Weakened financials & dependence on fees income Investment in physical assets Research supported by cross-subsidy from other income Administrative bureaucracy |
Focus on income earned through value created & diversification of income Investment in digital & knowledge assets Research focused on scholarly inquiry & societal value Primacy of scholarly community |
3. Campus Brown and Kafka [37] Lanich [36] |
Campus as home Safety & security |
Scholarly community campus & digital Health & well-being |
4. Internationalization Dickler [49] Horne [48] |
Focus on student mobility Dominance of host-country pedagogy |
Focus on global citizenship Pedagogy of encounter & inter-cultural learning |
5. Teaching and Learning Gates [42] McMurtrie [55] Smith 2016 [11] Taparia 2020 [31] |
Scholarship for employability Opportunity gap persists & held as achievement gap Dominance of face–face pedagogy Synchronous learning |
Scholarship for societal impact Focus on equity: diversity, inclusion & belonging Blended learning Synchronous & asynchronous delivery |
6. Employability Strada Education Network [41] Willetts [59] |
Privileged individualism & competition Career-focus Job skills & competencies |
Focus on social justice & community Employability throughout life Life skills & values |
7. Sustainability SDSN [65] SDSN [66] THE [62] |
Environmental sustainability Operational focus Disconnected from formal curriculum |
Sustainable development Strategic agenda Education for sustainable development within formal curriculum |
8. Multi-stakeholder Partnerships Caplan et al. [69] Horan 2019 [71] Mataix et al. [68] Moreno-Serna et al. [70] |
Ivory tower Knowledge transfer Operational/tactical partnerships Pursuit of mission |
Connected university Knowledge exchange Strategic partnerships Multi-stakeholder assembly convened around shared societal purpose |