Skip to main content
. 2020 Dec 11;38(2):793–834. doi: 10.1007/s12325-020-01571-z

Table 1.

Characteristics of included studies: country, setting and population

References Country (population) Settinga Cases and controls
Cases (N) Controls (N)
Hosp Other All HC NM PM
Gastric cancer only
Cai et al. [23] China × 60 60 60 0 0
Chen et al. [24] China × × 249 1203 0 1203 0
Chen et al. [25] China × 87 105 40 65 0
Chung et al. [26] South Korea × 147 94 Ub Ub 24
Ding et al. [27] China × 110 110 110 0 0
Dong et al. [28] China × 90 57 57 0 0
Gantuya et al. [29] Mongolia × 50 752 0 752 0
Gwak et al. [30] South Korea U U 96 187 0 187 0
He et al. [31] China × 149 235 124 111 0
Hoshino et al. [32] Japan × 248 74 74 0 0
Huang et al. [33] China × 197 125 37 88 0
Huang et al. [34] China × × 62 59 59 0 0
Huang et al. [35] China × 60 60 60 0 0
Iwasaki et al. [36] Japan × 54 54 54 0 0
Ji et al. [37] China × 168 74 74 0 0
Juan Cai et al. [38] China × 106 358 160 198 0
Kaise et al. [39] Japan × 187 561 561 0 0
Kang et al. [40] South Korea × 380 626 228 291 107
Kikuchi et al. [41] Japan × 122 178 79 99 0
Kim et al. [42] South Korea × 120 120 Ub Ub 0
Kurilovich et al. [43] Russia × 52 104 104 0 0
Li et al. [44] China × 60 60 60 0 0
Li et al. [45] China × 79 112 81 0 31
Li et al. [46] China × 65 65 65 0 0
Li et al. [47] South Korea × 100 100 100 0 0
Li et al. [48] China × 234 428 270 0 158
Lim et al. [49] South Korea × 100 90 Ub Ub 30
Lim et al. [50] South Korea × 100 100 Ub Ub 30
Lin et al. [51] China U U 51 78 60 18 0
Liu et al. [52] China × 142 105 105 0 0
Liu et al. [53] China × 119 148 99 49 0
Liu et al. [54] China × 50 50 50 0 0
Meistere et al. [55] Taiwan, Latvia, Lithuania, Germany × × 829 929 929 0 0
Mroczko et al. [56] Poland × 73 61 61 0 0
Ning et al. [57] China × 169 75 75 0 0
Oue et al. [58] Japan × 123 96 76 20 0
Pan et al. [59] China × 81 130 77 53 0
Park et al. [60] South Korea × 81 103 32 63 8
Parvaee et al. [61] Iran × 50 50 50 0 0
Qin et al. [62] China × × 407 407 407 0 0
Qiu et al. [63] China × 200 200 200 0 0
Song et al. [64] China × 68 68 0 68 0
Su et al. [65] China × 82 59 50 9 0
Sun et al. [66] China × × 332 332 332 0 0
Tsalikidis et al. [67] Greece × 99 78 78 0 0
Wang et al. [68] Taiwan U U 170 116 116 0 0
Wang et al. [69] China × 72 54 54 0 0
Wang et al. [70] China × × 186 186 186 0 0
Wang et al. [71] China × 60 120 60 60 0
Werner et al. [72] Germany × 146 97 97 0 0
Wu et al. [73] China × 90 90 90 0 0
Wu et al. [74] China × 99 132 100 30 2
Wu et al. [75] China × 201 318 157 161 0
Yanaoka et al. [76] Japan × 63 5146 5146 0 0
Yang et al. [77] South Korea × 290 290 290 0 0
Yang et al. [78] China × 109 106 0 106 0
Yoon et al. [79] South Korea × × 500 200 200 0 0
Yun et al. [80] China × 194 376 185 191 0
Zayakin et al. [81] Latvia, Germany × 235 367 213 154 0
Zhang et al. [82] China × 114 298 187 111 0
Zhang et al. [83] China × × 80 70 0 70 0
Zhang et al. [84] China × 80 80 0 80 0
Zhou et al. [85] China × 50 50 Ub Ub Ub
Zhou et al. [86] China × 71 61 61 0 0
Zhou et al. [87] China × 70 70 70 0 0
Pancreatic cancer only
Akita et al. [88] Japan × 116 138 138 0 0
Balasenthil et al. [89] USA × 98 154 61 93 0
Brand et al. [90] USA × 173 120 120 0 0
Cao et al. [91] China × 156 115 0 57 58
Capello et al. [92] USA × 73 134 60 74 0
Chung et al. [93] South Korea × 55 93 70 23 0
Chung et al. [94] South Korea × 54 80 55 25 0
Deng et al. [95] China × 303 640 600 40 0
Duraker et al. [96] Turkey × 123 173 0 173 0
Firpo et al. [97] USA × × 75 261 150 84 27
Fukutake et al. [98] Japan × 240 7800 7772 28 0
Gao et al. [99] China × 70 120 50 70 0
Gold et al. [100] USA × 53 130 43 87 0
Gold et al. [101] USA × × 298 199 79 120 0
Groblewska et al. [102] Poland U U 62 65 65 0 0
Guo et al. [103] China × 250 300 150 150 0
Honda et al. [104] Japan, Germany × 319 291 181 110 0
Honda et al. [105] Japan, USA × × 384 342 192 150 0
Honda et al. [106] Ten European countriesc × 156 213 213 0 0
Jiang et al. [107] China × 96 252 200 52 0
Kaur et al. [108] USA × 154 167 0 167 0
Kim et al. [109] USA × × 278 418 220 83 115
Kuwatani et al. [110] Japan × 98 158 105 21 32
LeCalvez-Kelm et al. [111] Czech Republic, Slovakia × × 397 533 374 159 0
Lee et al. [112] South Korea × 51 112 0 112 0
Liao et al. [113] Taiwan × × 58 146 102 44 0
Liu et al. [114] China × 138 175 68 107 0
Liu et al. [115] China × 172 215 133 82 0
Liu et al. [116] China × 235 470 240 230 0
Matsubara et al. [117] Japan × 140 97 87 0 10
Mayerle et al. [118] Germany × 79 160 80 80 0
Mellby et al. [119] Denmark, USA × 143 276 219 57 0
Mizuno et al. [120] Japan × 180 180 84 96 0
O'Brien et al. [121] UK × 101 184 184 0 0
Park et al. [122] South Korea × 139 146 74 72 0
Park et al. [123] South Korea U U 292 165 94 71 0
Peng et al. [124] Taiwan × × 263 230 185 45 0
Poruk et al. [125] USA × × 86 134 86 48 0
Ritchie et al. [126] Canada × 84 99 99 0 0
Rychlikova et al. [127] Czech Republic × 64 185 48 137 0
Sakai et al. [128] Japan × 53 147 102 22 23
Song et al. [129] USA × 188 220 89 68 63
Tachezy et al. [130] Germany × × 116 243 128 115 0
Talar-Wojnarowska et al. [131] Poland × 85 122 50 72 0
Tavano et al. [132] Italy × 74 117 117 0 0
Ward et al. [133] UK × 75 61 0 61 0
Xu et al. [134] China × 156 180 65 57 58
Zhang et al. [135] China × 129 278 183 95 0
Zhang et al. [136] China × 67 206 145 61 0
Zhong et al. [137] China × 183 202 141 61 0
Zhou et al. [138] China × 152 207 96 91 20
Zhou et al. [139] China × 156 199 163 36 0
Zhou et al. [140] China × 64 64 64 0 0
Oesophageal cancer only
Bagaria et al. [141] India × 50 50 50 0 0
Bai et al. [142] China × 89 125 80 14 31
Bagaria et al. [143] India × 50 50 50 0 0
Brockmann et al. [144] Germany × 50 150 50 100 0
Huang et al. [145] China × 60 60 60 0 0
Jia et al. [146] China × 101 98 98 0 0
Liao et al. [147] China × 151 230 194 36 0
Lukaszewicz-Zajac et al. [148] Poland × 56 65 65 0 0
Lv et al. [149] China × 126 80 80 0 0
Pan et al. [150] China × 50 110 60 50 0
Peng et al. [151] China × 104 53 53 0 0
Sudo et al. [152] Japan × × 283 9364 9203 161 0
Wang et al. [153] China × 84 154 154 0 0
Xing et al. [154] China × 169 154 80 74 0
Xu et al. [155] China × 237 134 134 0 0
Xu et al. [156] China × 70 80 80 0 0
Yan et al. [157] China × 364 229 229 0 0
Zhang et al. [158] China × 81 81 81 0 0
Zhang et al. [159] China × 62 58 58 0 0
Zhang et al. [160] China × 81 81 81 0 0
Zhang et al. [161] China × 186 186 186 0 0
Zhang et al. [162] China × 112 112 112 0 0
Zheng et al. [163] China × 150 185 126 59 0
Zhou et al. [164] China × 88 479 200 0 279
Biliary tract cancers only
Deng et al. [165] China × 153 65 0 65 0
Leelawat et al. [166] Thailand × 59 128 0 128 0
Wang et al. [167] China × 78 156 78 78 0
More than one tumour type
Bagaria et al. [168] India ×

50 GC

50 OC

50 50 0 0
Markar et al. [169] UK × 163 GC or OC 172d 89 82 0
Ren et al. [170] China ×

1049 GC

268 OC

160 PaC

1019 747 272 0
Schneider et al. [171] Germany U U

122 GC

86 OC

53 53 0 0

GC gastric cancer, HC healthy control, Hosp hospital, NM non-malignant, OC oesophageal cancer, PaC pancreatic cancer, PM pre-malignant, U unclear, UK United Kingdom, USA United States of America

aDue to wide variations in health systems across different countries, hospital setting is a broad definition than can encompass secondary and tertiary care. Other setting refers to biobanks, reference sets, databases, or archived samples; general population cohorts or cohorts from population screening programmes; or cohorts from previous trials or observational studies

bIn most of these studies, unclear numbers refer to healthy controls and non-malignant conditions combined (70 controls for [26], 120 controls for [42], 60 controls for [49], and 70 controls for [50]). In the case of Zhou et al. [85], it is also unclear whether controls had pre-malignant conditions

cDenmark, France, Italy, Germany, Greece, Spain, UK, Norway, Sweden & Netherlands

dSum of controls does not add up to total number of controls (mismatch in paper)