Skip to main content
. 2021 Feb 4;12:625370. doi: 10.3389/fphys.2021.625370

TABLE 3.

Accuracy, overprediction, and underprediction of each of the predictive equations compared to RMR measured by Fitmate GS in participants.

Male athletes
Female athletes
Males
Females
A*
OP+
UP++
A*
OP+
UP++
A*
OP+
UP++
A*
OP+
UP++
n % n % n % RMSE n % n % n % RMSE n % n % n % RMSE n % n % n % RMSE p**
Harris-Benedict 10 40 9 36 6 24 252 12 50 10 42 2 8 221 5 25 15 75 0 0 264 8 29 20 71 0 0 331 0.034
Mifflina 10 40 6 24 9 36 267 17 71 4 17 3 13 195 9 45 11 55 0 0 182 9 32 19 68 0 0 267 0.037
Mifflinb 15 60 2 8 8 32 419 14 58 4 17 6 25 298 16 80 2 10 2 10 212 13 46 13 46 2 7 167 0.218
Schofield 11 44 7 28 7 28 261 13 54 9 38 2 8 223 6 30 14 70 0 0 265 9 32 19 68 0 0 330 0.293
Cunningham 10 40 13 52 2 8 260 13 54 9 38 2 8 225 5 25 15 75 0 0 271 7 25 21 75 0 0 334 0.106
Owen 12 48 1 4 12 48 259 9 38 14 58 1 4 267 16 80 3 15 1 5 264 11 39 15 54 2 7 277 0.025
Liu’s 12 48 3 12 10 40 339 16 67 5 21 3 12 236 12 60 8 40 0 0 121 12 43 16 57 0 0 235 0.309
De Lorenzo 10 40 10 40 5 20 284 10 42 14 58 0 0 192 3 15 17 85 0 0 164 1 4 27 96 0 0 233 0.002
Bernstein 5 20 0 0 50 80 257 4 17 2 8 18 75 304 8 40 0 0 12 60 307 15 54 0 0 13 46 406 0.001
Nelson 15 60 2 8 8 32 270 8 33 2 8 14 58 209 16 80 2 10 2 10 118 16 57 2 7 10 36 137 0.001
Johnstone 13 52 6 24 6 24 274 13 54 7 29 4 17 252 11 55 9 45 0 0 115 10 36 18 64 0 0 137 0.457
Roza 6 24 11 44 8 32 310 9 38 15 63 0 0 232 8 40 11 55 1 5 133 7 25 21 75 0 0 294 0.517

**p < 0.05. Chi-squared test was used to compare the accurate predictions in participants grouped according to the gender and physical activity level.

RMSE was calculated to indicate the model’s predictive performance in our data.

*The percentage of participants predicted by the RMR equation within ± 10% of the RMR measured by Fitmate GS.

+The percentage of participants predicted by the RMR equation within > 10% of the RMR measured by Fitmate GS. ++The percentage of participants predicted by the RMR equation within < 10% of the RMR measured by Fitmate GS.

A, Accurate; OP, Over-Predicted; UP, Under-Predicted; RMSE, root-mean-squared prediction error.