Table 2.
First author (year of publication) | Sample | Duration of intervention (months) | EG Component | Experimental PE programme | Frequency (times/weeks) | Session duration (min) | Modality | CG | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Group | Single | ||||||||
Cormie et al. (2015) [24] |
EG: 32 CG: 31 |
3 | AE+RE |
Supervised: AE: 20–30 min at 70–85% max HR RE: 6–12 RM, 1–4 sets, reps NR Progression: intensity and volume |
2 | 60 | x | Standard care | |
Newton et al. (2019) [25] |
EG: 57 CG: 47 |
6 | RE+IE |
Supervised: RE: 6–12 RM, 2–4 sets, reps NR Progression: Intensity and volume IE: 3–5 times BW, 2–4 sets, 10 reps. Progression: Set and type of exercise |
2 | 60 | x | Printed booklet with information about exercise | |
Unsupervised: IE: two to four rotations of skipping (30 s), hopping, leaping, and drop jumping (all 10 times) |
2 | 60 | x | ||||||
EG: 50 CG: 47 |
6 | AE+RE |
Supervised: RE: 6–12 RM, 2–4 sets, reps NR Progression: Intensity and volume AE: 20–30 min at 60–85% max HR |
2 | 60 | x | |||
Taaffe et al. (2019) [26] |
EG: 54 CG: 50 |
6 | AE+RE+IE |
Supervised: AE: 25–40 min of 60–85% max HR RE: 6–12 RM, 2–4 sets, reps NR Progression: intensity and volume IE: 3·4–5·2 times BW, 2–4 sets, 10 reps Progression: set and type of exercise |
3 | 60 | x | Standard care | |
Nilsen et al. (2015) [27] |
EG: 28 CG: 30 |
4 | RE |
Supervised: RE: 6–10 RM, 1–3 sets, 10 reps. Progression: volume |
2 | 60 | x | Encouraged to maintain their habitual physical activity level and not to initiate strength training | |
Unsupervised: Home-based exercise session similar to supervised sessions performed at a moderate intensity |
1 | 60 | x | x | |||||
Uth et al. (2016) [28] |
EG: 29 CG: 28 |
3 | FT |
Supervised: 15 min warm-up (drills, balance, strength exercise) 2–3 sets × 15 min Progression: set and frequency |
2–3 | 45–60 | x | Encouraged to maintain their habitual physical activity level | |
Uth et al. (2016) [29] | 8 | ||||||||
Bjerre et al. (2019) [30] |
EG: 46 CG: 41 |
6 | FT |
Supervised: 20 min warm-up 20 min dribbling, passing, and shooting 20 min of 5–7-a-side football Intensity and progression are NR |
2 | 60 | x | 15/30-min telephone session covering options for physical activity and free-of-charge rehabilitation delivery by the municipalities and subsequently an email with the same information | |
Winters-Stone et al. (2014) [49] |
EG: 29 CG: 22 |
12 | RE+IE |
Supervised: RE upper body: 8–15 RM, 1–2 sets, 8–14 reps. RE lower body: 0–15% BW, sets NR, 8–12 reps IE: 0–10% BW, 1–10 sets, 10 reps Progression: Intensity and volume |
2 | 60 | x | Performed a series of whole body stretching and relaxation exercises | |
Unsupervised: Home-based exercise similar to class session but performed without weighted vests and replacing weights with resistance bands |
1 | 60 | x | ||||||
Kim et al. (2018) [50] |
EG: 26 CG: 25 |
6 | AE+RE |
Unsupervised: Core program: Weight-bearing + RE RE: 0–10% BW, 2–3 sets, 8–15 reps. IE: weight-bearing exercise 11–15 RPE, 3–5 sets, 20–30 min Progression: intensity, volume, and type of exercise Optional programme: stabilization/balance exercise + Circuit Resistive Calisthenics (same dose as core program) Stabilization/balance exercise: intensity and volume NR |
2–5 | NR | NR |
Stretching 3–5 times/week (a total of 9 movements); Ten-minute telephone sessions (weekly for the first month and at monthly intervals thereafter) |
AE aerobic exercise, BW body weight, CG control group, EG experimental group, FT football training, HR heart rate, IE impact-loading exercise, NR not reported, PE physical exercise, RE resistance exercise, Reps repetitions, RM repetition maximum, RPE rate of perceived exertion, S seconds