Skip to main content
. 2020 Nov 2;77(3):1303–1315. doi: 10.1002/ps.6144

Table 4.

Analysis of variance (ANOVA) (degrees of freedom, df; F value statistic, F; P value, P) and analysis of deviance (degrees of freedom, df; chi‐square statistic, χ 2; P value, P) results from linear mixed models

Mortality after 7 days of Bt‐treated + 7 subsequent days of non‐Bt food + 7 days box Weight after 7 days of Bt‐treated food Weight after 7 subsequent days of non‐Bt food
df χ2 P df F P df F P
Treatment 6 54.52 <0.0001 6, 269 3.18 0.004 6, 269 12.95 <0.0001
Contrasts df z P df t P df t P
C vs BL NA 1.75 0.31 10.2 0.36 0.98 8.19 0.51 0.96
C vs BH NA 3.34 0.004 10.2 −0.20 0.99 8.19 −0.07 0.99
C vs VL NA 7.82 <0.0001 10.2 −1.63 0.43 8.19 −3.47 0.03
C vs VH NA 13.87 <0.0001 10.2 −2.66 0.09 8.19 −6.57 0.0008
C vs NL NA 3.82 0.0008 10.2 0.83 0.85 8.19 −0.36 0.98
C vs NH NA 4.35 0.0001 10.2 −1.55 0.47 8.19 −2.19 0.22

These models examined the effect of treatment [control (C); Bt galleriae formulation low and high concentration (BL, BH); Bt israelensis (VL, VH); Bt tenebrionis (NL, NH)] on total mortality (14 experimental days + 7 days exposed to non‐Bt treated food in boxes) and pine weevil weight (grams) after Hylobius abietis was exposed to 7 days of Bt‐treated food and 7 subsequent days to non‐Bt treated food (stem pieces of Picea abies). Pairwise comparisons (using Dunnett adjustment; t ratio, t or z ratio, z) examine differences between each treatment and the control group. For contrasts examining differences in mortality, no degrees of freedom can be calculated (NA in table). Significant effects (P < 0.05) are shown in bold.